AS DR. MILROY STATED IN HIS EVIDENCE, SOME OF THE PEOPLE WHO DO CLINICAL CHILD PROTECTION WORK “SEE THEMSELVES AS ADVOCATES FOR THE CHILD”.
USING THE TERMINOLOGY OFFERED TO THE INQUIRY BY DR. POLLANEN, THE ADVOCACY ROLE IN THIS CONTEXT APPEARS TO HAVE RESULTED IN A “DEFAULT DIAGNOSIS” OF CHILD ABUSE.
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
FROM CLOSING SUBMISSIONS: AFFECTED FAMILIES GROUP;
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
This Blog is currently looking at the closing written submissions filed by various parties appearing at the Goudge Inquiry which is expected to report on September 30, 2008.
The current focus is on the submissions filed by the "Affected Families Group" - a group of families who were directly affected by the systemic failings which occurred in pediatric forensic pathology in Ontario between 1991 and 2001;
The Group is represented by lawyers Peter Wardle (Wardle, Daley, Bernstein) and Julie M. Kirkpatrick;
Today's focus is on the Group's allegation that Dr. Smith, backed by the Chief Coroner's office, assumed sexual abuse by default in several of the cases being reviewed by the Inquiry;
"Dr. Cairns came to the job of Deputy Chief Coroner in 1991 after presiding over a controversial inquest regarding suspected child abuse," the section begins;
"Addressing this issue became a central feature in his professional work with the Chief Coroner's Office over the next decade," it continues.
"From the perspective of the Chief Coroner's Office, of particular concern to Dr. Cairns were those cases where the Children’s Aid Society had been involved in monitoring families prior to a child’s death:
"…the focus of the joint mortality task force was, what was happening to children when they were being monitored by a Children’s Aid Society. So the focus when we brought all these extra cases was we felt we needed to have a much closer scrutiny of the role that Children’s Aid Societies were playing in deaths of these children. Between 1996 and 1998 we did six systemic inquests all addressing children who had died while they were being supervised by a Children’s Aid Society.
In this work, Dr. Cairns found a ready and willing partner in Dr. Smith, who already worked closely with the SCAN team at the Hospital for Sick Children.
Dr. Cairns became a friend and supporter of Dr. Smith and defended him in the media;
As Dr. Milroy stated in his evidence, some of the people who do clinical child protection work “see themselves as advocates for the child”.
Using the terminology offered to the Inquiry by Dr. Pollanen, the advocacy role in this context appears to have resulted in a “default diagnosis” of child abuse.
Indeed, in the Kassandra case, Dr. Marcella Mian stated to the police that “all she deals with is child abuse, so naturally she would assume abuse.”
The default diagnosis in many of the cases that are before this Inquiry came to be expressed by Dr. Smith in the following terms:
Valin: “in the absence of a reasonable explanation by history, they indicate non-accidental trauma including sexual abuse”
Nicholas: “in the absence of a credible explanation, in my opinion, the post-mortem findings are regarded as resulting from non-accidental injury”
Tiffani: “…of note are the presence of bilateral healing rib fractures which, in the absence of a reasonable explanation, are considered to be non-accidental in nature.”
Amber: “…look for evidence which might prove the babysitter to be innocent”
Dr. Cairns did not appear to understand the dangers of such logic.
His explanation for the opinion in Nicholas was as follows: “Commissioner I think he was making that reasoning in that there was no satisfactory explanation given as to how it may be accidental”.
Yet that form of reasoning has no basis in science.
As Dr. Pollanen explained:
We don’t say ‘in the absence of evidence to the contrary this is cancer.’
What we say is, ‘the findings of the histology are not sufficient to come to a diagnosis; re-biopsy."
Do more investigations to find out."
Harold Levy...hlevy15@gmail.com;