Showing posts with label pollanen. Show all posts
Showing posts with label pollanen. Show all posts
Thursday, November 14, 2024

Canadian Pathologists (And Other Experts) Under Fire: Former Dr. Charles Smith; Dr. John Penistan: (The Guy Paul Morin Case): I dig into my archives to revisit the role played by Dr. Penistan in the Ontario Guy Paul Morin case and explore possible comparisons with the discredited former doctor Charles Smith………..Passage from Prof. James C. Morton. Ottawa Citizen…."Last week we were reminded daily of the miscarriages of justice caused by forensic pathologist Charles Smith -- the many parents and caregivers charged and some found guilty of murdering children, the scores of lives ruined, and families destroyed," it continues. "And in August, the Ontario Court of Appeal said that one of its main reasons for acquitting Steven Truscott had to do with the testimony of John Penistan, the pathologist in that long-ago case of rape and murder. Dr. Penistan's official autopsy report stated that 12-year-old Lynne Harper had died soon after Steven Truscott had been seen giving her a ride on his bike, at a time when he would have been by far the most likely killer. But in recent years researchers have found two earlier copies of the same report form, one of them filled out during the autopsy, both placing the girl's time of death much later, when Mr. Truscott absolutely could not have been the killer. Said the Court: "(The) nature of the changes in his opinion leaves Dr. Penistan's evidence reasonably open to the allegation that his opinion shifted to coincide with the Crown's case against the appellant."

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: When I recently began preparing for a 'talk' on wrongful convictions  that  I was graciously invited to delive...