Tuesday, November 17, 2026

November 17: Yvonne "Missy" Woods: Colorado: Extraordinary Development in the aftermath of revelations of the former State Forensic Scientists breach of trust and her imprisonment: The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) alleges a years-long cover-up in the States Colorado DNA debacle and has called for Colorado Supreme Court action, as CBS News (Reporter Tori Mason) reports, noting that, "Matthew Segal, co-director of the ACLU's State Supreme Court Initiative, told CBS Colorado this should not be viewed as the misconduct of a single employee. "The evidence is that in both 2014 and 2018, fraud by Missy Woods was brought to the attention of supervisors at the CBI, and instead of discharging their obligation to do something about it and to disclose that fraud to criminal defendants, supervisors covered it up," Segal said. The ACLU argues that the failure to disclose Woods' misconduct violated defendants' constitutional rights and allowed her to continue working on criminal cases for years after concerns were first raised."


PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Investigators found Woods altered or deleted DNA data in at least 1,045 cases during her nearly three decades working for CBI. But attorneys argue the number of cases affected could be significantly higher, because some of the original forensic data is no longer available."

----------------------------------------------------

QUOTE OF THE DAY: ""It's important to remember here that it is the state that committed this misconduct," Segal said. Now, the ACLU wants the Colorado Supreme Court to shift responsibility for addressing those potentially compromised cases. Rather than requiring individual defendants to prove Woods tampered with evidence in their cases, attorneys want the state to demonstrate that misconduct did not occur. Segal said the issue is also about preserving confidence in Colorado's criminal justice system. "One way I would put it is that it takes a village to do a criminal case right, and it can take a village to taint a criminal case as well," he said. "And here, unfortunately, the second thing happened."'

----------------------------------------------------

SECOND QUOTE OF THE DAY: "In a statement to CBS Colorado, CBI Strategic Communications Director Rob Low wrote: "We continue to recognize the seriousness of Missy Woods' misconduct and the concerns it has raised about the integrity of forensic evidence. CBI has addressed these issues extensively and remains committed to ensuring the reliability of its forensic work and maintaining public trust."

STORY: "ACLU alleges years-long cover-up in Colorado DNA scandal, calls for Colorado Supreme Court action," by Reporter Tori Mason, published by CBS News, on November 10, 2026. (Tori Mason is an Emmy-award winning reporter and weekend evening anchor at CBS Colorado.)

GIST: "Missy Woods is behind bars for tampering with DNA evidence at the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. Now, the American Civil Liberties Union says her misconduct has exposed much deeper problems and is calling for accountability beyond the former analyst.

The ACLU, ACLU of Colorado and the Exoneration Project are urging the Colorado Supreme Court to hold the state accountable for what attorneys describe as a years-long cover-up that may have compromised thousands of criminal cases.

Investigators found Woods altered or deleted DNA data in at least 1,045 cases during her nearly three decades working for CBI. But attorneys argue the number of cases affected could be significantly higher, because some of the original forensic data is no longer available.

Matthew Segal, co-director of the ACLU's State Supreme Court Initiative, told CBS Colorado this should not be viewed as the misconduct of a single employee.

"The evidence is that in both 2014 and 2018, fraud by Missy Woods was brought to the attention of supervisors at the CBI, and instead of discharging their obligation to do something about it and to disclose that fraud to criminal defendants, supervisors covered it up," Segal said.

The ACLU argues that the failure to disclose Woods' misconduct violated defendants' constitutional rights and allowed her to continue working on criminal cases for years after concerns were first raised.

In a statement to CBS Colorado, CBI Strategic Communications Director Rob Low wrote:

"We continue to recognize the seriousness of Missy Woods' misconduct and the concerns it has raised about the integrity of forensic evidence. CBI has addressed these issues extensively and remains committed to ensuring the reliability of its forensic work and maintaining public trust.

We have confidence in the dedicated investigators and scientists who carry out CBI's mission every day. We respect the judicial process and believe that questions concerning individual cases are best addressed through that process."

The agency has a web page that details its response to Woods' misconduct.

According to the filing, the ACLU says the delay also resulted in the loss of crucial DNA instrument data, making it difficult or impossible to determine whether Woods manipulated evidence in additional cases.

"It's important to remember here that it is the state that committed this misconduct," Segal said.

Now, the ACLU wants the Colorado Supreme Court to shift responsibility for addressing those potentially compromised cases. Rather than requiring individual defendants to prove Woods tampered with evidence in their cases, attorneys want the state to demonstrate that misconduct did not occur.

Segal said the issue is also about preserving confidence in Colorado's criminal justice system.

"One way I would put it is that it takes a village to do a criminal case right, and it can take a village to taint a criminal case as well," he said. "And here, unfortunately, the second thing happened."

ACLU alleges years-long cover-up in Colorado DNA scandal, calls for Colorado Supreme Court action - CBS Colorado 

The entire story can be read at:


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true

Monday, November 16, 2026

November 16: Joshua Mounts: Ohio: Having won his appeal (In April) on a conviction of felony murder in the death of his 7-month old son, he may learn on Tuesday (November 17) whether the State will send him back to court for a new trial. For reasons set out in my publisher's note below, I truly hope this will not happen. Why? In Judge Kinsley's powerful words: "The State's case rested largely on expert testimony asserting that J.F.'s skull fracture was recent, thereby supporting the inference that the fatal injury occurred while J.F. was in Mount's care. Yet there was no direct evidence linking Mounts to the alleged abuse. As a result, this was simply a battle of the experts. Whichever set of experts the jury found more credible and believable was likely to prevail."


The Ohio Court of Appeal, First District decision:  (Case Law Wire note):  Link to the full decision: 

https://caselawwire.com/ohio/state-v-mounts-court-reverses-murder-conviction-and-remands-for-new-trial-finding-ineffective-assistance-of-both-trial-and-appellate-counsel/

----------------------------------------------------


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog:

INTRODUCTION:  Battle of the experts:  Over the years, I have run into far too many cases in which an innocent  parent is caught in what turns out to be a battle of experts in which the expert who the jury  finds most convincing determines the outcome of the case.

Justice Jennifer Kinsley's decision  for the unanimous three judge appeal panel overturning his conviction of felony murder  and his 15-years to life sentence  (November 2021) makes it abundantly clear that this is exactly what happened in Joshua's case.

In Judge Kinsley's ruling  for the court: "The State's case rested largely on expert testimony asserting that J.F.'s skull fracture was recent, thereby supporting the inference that the fatal injury occurred while J.F. was in Mount's care. Yet there was no direct evidence linking Mounts to the alleged abuse. As a result, this was simply a battle of the experts. Whichever set of experts the jury found more credible and believable was likely to prevail."

"This meant any significant error or omission by defence counsel on his presentation of J.F's medical information to the jury had the potential to tip the scales against Mounts," she continued. "And we believe they did in this case. Collectively and individually, defence counsel's mistakes allowed the jury to hear unchallenged or improper testimony while limiting the the defense's ability to prevent a complete and responsive  expert opinion."

---------------------------------------------------

Two Competing Theories:

Judge kinsley also made clear that as no eyewitness testified as to  what precisely occurred to cause J,F,'s death, "Thus the  evidence at trial largely advanced two competing theories about how he died.

Competing theory one: On the  one hand, as Judge Kinsley set out,   the State contended that J,F. suffered blunt force trauma to his head during his overnight visit to Joshua Mount's home that Mounts, as the sole caregiver during that time, must have perpetrated,

Competing theory two: per Judge Kinsley:  Joshua's lawyers argued that Mounts argued that injuries to JF's brain were long-standing and could have been attributed to previous medical trauma, including both his mother's prenatal drug use, and JF's history  of Brief Resolved Unexplained events (so-called BRUE episodes) in which J.F. would stop breathing. (Judge Kinsley: "Both sides relied heavily on expert testimony to support their competing theories. 

In short, Joshua Mounts found himself caught  in the 'battle' between experts described by Justice Kinsley , which must have appeared to him as if was in an 'arena' rather than a 'courthouse - and given rulings made about the tactics used by the prosecutor to secure a conviction, it must also have appeared that the proverbial 'deck' was stacked against him.

How did the prosecutor stack the deck against Joshua Mounts?:

A:  By telling the jury  that eight unnamed doctors - none of whom had testified - agreed with the  prosecution's theory that Joshua was guilty of murder. As Justice Kinsley ruled: "Finally, we turn  to counsel's failure  to object to the prosecutor's closing argument, In a case turning on expert credibility, the State's  suggestion that eight additional doctors - none of who testified - would have supported its theory of the case,  dramatically altered the perceived balance of expert opinion. By effectively inflating the state's expert count from three to 11, the prosecutor invited the jury  to rely on evidence not in the record, In the absence of an objection these comments could only. have influenced the  jury's assessment, further undermining confidence in the outcome." My comment: Sure, his lawyer should have protested this comment to the roof-tops. But that doesn't excuse the prosecutor from going so far over the line  - I have never seen anything quite like it - to buttress a conviction. So unfair.

--------------------------------------------------

"SHE (DR. MAKEROFF)  WAS THE ONLY EXPERT TO EQUATE BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA WITH CHILD ABUSE, CONVERTING AN OTHERWISE AMBIGUOUS MEDICAL FINDING INTO AN ASSERTION OF INTENTIONAL, RATHER THAN ACCIDENTAL HARM. AND SHE DID SO WITHOUT PRIOR DISCLOSURE, DEPRIVING THE DEFENCE OF ANY MEANINFUL OPPORTUNITY TO PREPARE, INVESTIGATE, OR REBUT THE OPINION GIVEN THAT J,F.'S MEDICAL RECORDS DID NOT CONTAIN SUCH A CONCLUSION."

B: By putting forward  a 'child abuse'  witness found by the appeal court to have given 'expert evidence,'  who had not filed an expert witness report required by law in order to help the defendant prepare for trial.  As Judge Kinsley set out in her ruling, like any other defendant in a criminal case, Joshua had the right to expect  expert witnesses called by the prosecution to provide them with written report summarizing  the expert's testimony, findings, analysis, conclusions  conclusions , or opinion and the experts qualifications, As you might expect, that didn't happen here. The prosecutor called a  witness named Dr. Kathi Makoroff who, although entitled to testify as to  her observations, went far on by delivering devastating opinion testimony - none of which was backed up by a written report, Indeed, as Judge Kinsley wrote, "These opinions went beyond describing Dr. Makoroff's observations about J.F.'s condition and the treatment she provided. Rather Dr. Makoroff formed conclusions, based on her expertise, about what happened to J.F. She therefore testified as an expert who was required to comply with Crim. R. 16 (K). (The requirement to submit a full report. HL); As Judge Kinsley points out, "She  (Dr. Makoroff) was the only expert to equate blunt force trauma with child abuse, converting an otherwise ambiguous medical finding into an assertion of intentional, rather than accidental harm. And she did so without prior disclosure, depriving the defence of any meaningful opportunity to prepare, investigate, or rebut the  opinion given that J.F.'s medical records did not contain such a conclusion."  My comment: Yes.  Josh's lawyer failed to challenge Dr. Makoroff's testimony. But it was the prosecutor,  who went way  over the line by presumably knowing her background, and yet putting her in the witness box, without giving Josh the required expert witness report which would allow him to make his defence against her devastating testimony. Oh yes. As we learn elsewhere in Judge Kinsey's decision: "Without an objection from the defence, she also opined that J.F.s injuries did not predate his overnight stay with mounts, She explains that in her expert opinion, a child would not behave normally after sustaining the type of injuries J.F. had. Very damning indeed. All for the prosecution. All without having given Joshua the benefit of the report required by law. So unfair.

C: By attacking the credibility of Dr. Andrea Weins  (one of only 50 experts board certified in both forensic pathology and neuropathology) one of Joshua Mounts  three expert witnesses, the prosecutor  weakened the defence on 'a key defence position - that J.F.'s  brain injury predated his time with Mounts.  In Judge Kinsey's words: "With respect to Dr. Wiens specifically,  the jury heard the State accuse her of misidentifying the fracture site of the recut slide - which the State implied showed no healing".  Although the trial judge suggested that any confusion arising from her report (at least she had filed one)  could be corrected by amending her report,  Joshua's lawyer rejected this approach,  the judge placed limits on Dr. Wein's testimony at the prosecution's behest,  and, as the appeal court noted, "Preventing her (Dr. Weins) from clarifying this left the jury with a misleading impression." Most unfair: My comment: This is a prime example of the 'battle'   Judge Kinsey referred to. Too bad for Joshua Mount. He was facing life in prison for murder if convicted,  caught in an adversary system, the doctor who could show the jury that he had not killed his son - who in his short life had troubled health episodes - that doctor was now under attack. All of which shows that our adversary system of criminal justice  is poorly suited when it comes to trials.  Yes,  Joshua's defence lawyer  did not handle  this difficult situation well  (the appeal was granted because of 'ineffective assistance' from both Joshua's trial and appeal counsel);   But it was the prosecutor who so sorely crippled Joshua's defence.

---------------------------------------------

Why Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated  and to grieve the death of his son - and why he should not be put to the risk of a new trial.

The appeal court decision makes clear that Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated in court, because of the cascade of prosecution  errors that piled up against him his trial, noting that: "Each deficiency - the failure to present Dr. Weins full and accurate opinion,  the admission of undisclosed and highly consequential expert testimony from Dr. Makaroff, and the failure to object to the prosecutor's improper closing argument.  occurred in a case that turned entirely on expert credibility."

"Here, the errors did not merely accumulate," Judge Kinsley continued, "They compounded one another, allowing the jury to hear misleading or undisclosed expert opinions while preventing the defence from fully presenting the only defence expert who reviewed the original histology slide."

Although his conviction has been overturned, on Tuesday (November 17) ,  Joshua, who had just turned 27 when  he was arrested in March, 2018, and is going to be 36 in January,  may learn if the prosecution is going to insist on  subjecting him to the risk and uncertainty, if not emotional torture,   of  a trial once again.  Considering the appeal courts unequivocal findings  relating to  abysmal prosecutorial misconduct,  I truly hope that this will not happen -  especially  when one considers that Joshua has been at CRC prison since his conviction, for almost 5 years - however, this doesn't  doesn't count the almost 4 years he was held on a $1 million-dollar straight bond in the Hamilton County Detention Center. (Joshua,  was arrested in March, 2018 and has remained incarcerated for a total of almost 9 years.)

Drs. Andrea Wiens, Dr. Andrew Guajardo (like Dr. Wiens, one of the 50 Neuropathologists in the United States) and Dr.   Satish Chundru, the experts who testified on  Joshua's behalf,  collectively concluded in their reports - yes, they all filed reports - that, as Judge Kinsley opines,  "As to J.F. s death,  they agreed that the blood near the fracture site they identified was not fresh and that J.F.'s skull exhibited evidence of healing, including new. bone formation, which included  that J.F.'s injuries were not recent. Dr. Wiens also testified that J.F.'s repeated  BRUE episodes created a greater likelihood  that underlying etiology  explained  his death."

Let justice prevail for Joshua.

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true

November 16: Alain Vizcay Osorio: (Facial Recognition Mishap): Granted green light for lawsuit against the police); Technology: Facial recognition gone terribly wrong - landing an innocent Kentucky man in jail for two weeks - even though he was working in Nebraska when the alleged fraudulent check was presented at a Kentucky bank. As reported by The Economic Times, "Osorio alleged that (Officer) Kilmer failed to adequately investigate or verify his identity before seeking an arrest warrant. According to the lawsuit, the photographs of Osorio and the person captured in the bank's security footage showed significant differences, including their head shapes, haircuts, facial features and complexions. The court also noted that the only apparent similarities between Osorio and the person in the footage were that both were Black men with facial hair. Osorio further alleged that Kilmer misrepresented the identification process in the criminal complaint by claiming to have used investigative tools and compared photographs, while actually relying exclusively on AI facial-recognition technology. The Florence Police Department's own policy stated that facial-recognition technology was advisory and could not establish probable cause without further investigation. Osorio has brought claims under federal and Kentucky law, including false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, assault and battery."


SYNOPSIS: In a significant ruling, a US federal judge has allowed a lawsuit against Detective Ryan Kilmer to advance regarding a wrongful arrest involving Alain Vizcay Osorio. Arrested due to faulty AI facial recognition technology that erroneously identified him, Osorio's case emphasizes the vital protection the Fourth Amendment offers against improper detentions.

-------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "In his November 9 hearing, Judge Meredith said the Fourth Amendment protects individuals from unreasonable arrests and seizures by the government. The judge said a police officer cannot delegate the responsibility of assessing probable cause entirely to artificial intelligence. He also pointed to the alleged failure to disclose the exclusive reliance on AI in the application for the arrest warrant.  The judge said there was good reason to believe that the warrant might not have been issued if the detective had fully explained how he identified Osorio."

------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "To illustrate his reasoning, Meredith used a hypothetical example involving a police detective who relies on a Magic 8 Ball to identify a suspect.
"While AI facial recognition technology has rapidly developed over recent years and is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball, placing unquestioned reliance on such technology is still not much different in principle from placing unquestioned reliance on a Magic 8 Ball.  He explained that an officer could not use the output of such a device as the sole basis for obtaining an arrest warrant and then claim immunity because there was no previous court ruling specifically addressing the use of a Magic 8 Ball. No reasonable officer would think that Detective Kilmer’s allegedly exclusive reliance on AI is lawful—especially given how Osorio’s booking photo looks nothing like the suspect from the security camera footage," the judge said."

--------------------------------------------

STORY: 'Fourth Amendment doesn't allow it': AI facial recognition mistake lands Nebraska man in jail for 2 weeks; Judge allows lawsuit against Kentucky cop," published by The Economic Times, on November 11, 2026. 

GIST: A US federal judge has allowed a lawsuit against a Kentucky police detective to proceed after a man alleged that he was wrongly arrested and jailed for more than two weeks because the officer relied solely on artificial intelligence (AI) facial-recognition technology to identify him as a check-fraud suspect.

The judge also rejected Kilmer's claim to qualified immunity, which can protect government officials from personal liability in certain circumstances.

The lawsuit was filed by Alain Vizcay Osorio, who has accused Kilmer of false arrest and malicious prosecution. Prosecutors dismissed the criminal charges against Osorio in May 2025 after he provided evidence that he was working in Nebraska when the alleged fraudulent check was presented at a Kentucky bank.

What happened?As per the court documents, the case dates back to August 30, 2024, when a man identifying himself as Ernesto Ramirez attempted to cash a suspected fraudulent check at Heritage Bank in Florence, Kentucky. The man presented a Texas driver's licence, but a bank teller suspected that the document was fake and refused to cash the check.

The individual then left the bank without receiving any money. Security cameras captured the incident, including an unobstructed view of the man's face.

A few weeks later, Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence Police Department began investigating the suspected fraud. After discovering that the Texas driver's licence was fake, he turned to the bank's security footage to identify the suspect.

According to the court documents, Kilmer took a screenshot of the man's face and used AI facial-recognition technology to compare it with a booking photograph and a Facebook profile image.

The detective allegedly relied solely on the AI-generated identification and concluded that the images matched.

The Facebook profile belonged to an individual identified as Yony Smith Npoles Charon. For reasons that were not explained in the complaint, Kilmer concluded that the person was actually Alain Vizcay Osorio, whose photograph appeared in the booking records.

Kilmer subsequently signed a criminal complaint stating that he had used investigative tools to identify Osorio as the person captured in the bank's security footage.

The complaint was used to obtain an arrest warrant. Officers arrested Osorio in Florida on January 9, 2025.

Osorio, who lived in Nebraska, was extradited to Boone County, Kentucky, where he faced charges of criminal possession of a forged instrument in the first and second degrees.

He was arraigned on January 23 and released on bond the following day. In March 2025, he was indicted on both charges.

However, on May 7, 2025, prosecutors dismissed the indictment with prejudice after Osorio established that he was working in Nebraska when the attempted check fraud took place.


Why did Osorio sue the detective?

Osorio alleged that Kilmer failed to adequately investigate or verify his identity before seeking an arrest warrant. According to the lawsuit, the photographs of Osorio and the person captured in the bank's security footage showed significant differences, including their head shapes, haircuts, facial features and complexions.

The court also noted that the only apparent similarities between Osorio and the person in the footage were that both were Black men with facial hair.

Osorio further alleged that Kilmer misrepresented the identification process in the criminal complaint by claiming to have used investigative tools and compared photographs, while actually relying exclusively on AI facial-recognition technology.

The Florence Police Department's own policy stated that facial-recognition technology was advisory and could not establish probable cause without further investigation.

Osorio has brought claims under federal and Kentucky law, including false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, assault and battery.

Detective Kilmer has denied wrongdoing and argued that Osorio had failed to establish that the alleged conduct violated clearly established law.

What did the judge say?

In his November 9 hearing, Judge Meredith said the Fourth Amendment protects individuals from unreasonable arrests and seizures by the government.

The judge said a police officer cannot delegate the responsibility of assessing probable cause entirely to artificial intelligence.

He also pointed to the alleged failure to disclose the exclusive reliance on AI in the application for the arrest warrant.

The judge said there was good reason to believe that the warrant might not have been issued if the detective had fully explained how he identified Osorio.

To illustrate his reasoning, Meredith used a hypothetical example involving a police detective who relies on a Magic 8 Ball to identify a suspect.

"While AI facial recognition technology has rapidly developed over recent years and is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball, placing unquestioned reliance on such technology is still not much different in principle from placing unquestioned reliance on a Magic 8 Ball.

He explained that an officer could not use the output of such a device as the sole basis for obtaining an arrest warrant and then claim immunity because there was no previous court ruling specifically addressing the use of a Magic 8 Ball.

No reasonable officer would think that Detective Kilmer’s allegedly exclusive reliance on AI is lawful—especially given how Osorio’s booking photo looks nothing like the suspect from the security camera footage," the judge said.

However, Meredith clarified that the case remains at an early stage. Evidence uncovered during discovery could change the outcome, and the detective could still raise further legal arguments.

The court allowed Osorio to file a second amended complaint and denied Kilmer's motion for judgment on the pleadings.

The detective was directed to file an answer or another response within 14 days. The court also scheduled a status conference for November 19, 2026."

The entire story can be read at: 


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;

Sunday, November 15, 2026

November 15: Chicago: Former Police Detective Reynaldo Guevara's policing crime wave: Question of the day: Chicago is paying $260.8 m to 17 wrongly convicted in cases involving this former detective in settlements that decades of allegations that Guevara manipulated witnesses, coerced confessions and fabricated evidence to secure murder convictions, often involving young men suspected of gang affiliations, Criminal Justice Journalists reports. The questions abound. (Here's just a few of them: Who protected Guevara while he was conducting his wrongful conviction policing crime wave over so many years? Where was the media watchdog? Who was this man who destroyed so many lives, families? Can this happen again?


--------------------------------------------

Here are the 17 men Chicago has settled with: (WTTS: Reporter  Heather Cherone;)


------------------------------------------------

QUOTE OF THE DAY: "Attorney Anand Swaminathan, who represents the plaintiffs, said the financial compensation cannot undo the damage caused by nearly 400 years of wrongful imprisonment."

--------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Among the men receiving compensation are brothers Juan and Rosendo Hernandez, who will receive a combined $34.7 million after each spent approximately 25 years in prison for a 1997 murder.  Rosendo was convicted despite presenting evidence that he was at a bowling alley watching a boxing match during the shooting, while Juan was convicted after a judge prevented a witness from testifying that he had falsely identified the brothers under police pressure. Their convictions were overturned in 2022, and both received certificates of innocence in 2023.  Another case involves Louis Robinson, who will receive $18.8 million after spending 26 years in prison for the 1996 murder of 17-year-old Kelly Velez.  Robinson maintained that Guevara pressured the victim’s boyfriend to identify him as the shooter, even though Robinson did not match witness descriptions. His conviction was overturned in 2023, and he received a certificate of innocence the following year. "

----------------------------------------------------

STORY: "Chicago Paying $260M To 17 Wrongly Convicted In Police Cases," published by Criminal Justice Journalists, on November 12, 2026.

GIST: "Chicago taxpayers will pay $260.8 million to 17 men who collectively spent 383 years in prison after being wrongfully convicted in cases investigated by former Police Detective Reynaldo Guevara, reports WTTW News.

 The settlements follow decades of allegations that Guevara manipulated witnesses, coerced confessions and fabricated evidence to secure murder convictions, often involving young men suspected of gang affiliations.

 Many cases followed a pattern: Guevara received a tip identifying a suspect, obtained incriminating witness statements or confessions, and helped build prosecutions that resulted in lengthy prison sentences. 

The settlements will be distributed in four equal installments between April 2027 and October 2028, with the men’s attorneys receiving 40%.

 Attorney Anand Swaminathan, who represents the plaintiffs, said the financial compensation cannot undo the damage caused by nearly 400 years of wrongful imprisonment.

 The massive payout adds to the financial consequences Chicago faces over police misconduct and raises questions about accountability for investigations that sent innocent people to prison for decades.

Among the men receiving compensation are brothers Juan and Rosendo Hernandez, who will receive a combined $34.7 million after each spent approximately 25 years in prison for a 1997 murder. 

Rosendo was convicted despite presenting evidence that he was at a bowling alley watching a boxing match during the shooting, while Juan was convicted after a judge prevented a witness from testifying that he had falsely identified the brothers under police pressure.

 Their convictions were overturned in 2022, and both received certificates of innocence in 2023. 

Another case involves Louis Robinson, who will receive $18.8 million after spending 26 years in prison for the 1996 murder of 17-year-old Kelly Velez. 

Robinson maintained that Guevara pressured the victim’s boyfriend to identify him as the shooter, even though Robinson did not match witness descriptions.

 His conviction was overturned in 2023, and he received a certificate of innocence the following year. 

The settlements illustrate how questionable witness identifications and alleged investigative misconduct contributed to wrongful convictions that remained intact for decades before being overturned.

The entire story can be read at: 


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;

Saturday, November 14, 2026

November 14: Brigadier Alfred Dreyfus: Question of the day:"What can a political scandal that seized late-nineteenth century France tell us about the long afterlives of miscarriages of justice?" as discussed by Samantha Dulieu, News Editor of the Justice Gap, who notes that: "Dreyfus was convicted in the paranoid decades after the Franco-Prussian war when tensions remained heightened between France and Germany. He was accused of being a spy and selling military secrets to Germany. A note that was apparently written in Dreyfus’ hand was uncovered in the residence of the German Ambassador in France by a French intelligence agent and the blame immediately landed with Dreyfus. It was a time of antisemitic fervour in France. As a Jew, Dreyfus’ loyalties were assumed not to lie with France, and his conviction catalysed latent, outlandish antisemitic conspiracy theories. The significance of this recent anniversary is found in how long some of myths around the case have endured, and how relevant it still appears."


BACKGROUND: (From a previous post of this Blog): May 31, 2025:  "Brigadier General Alfred Dreyfus: (Tainted  handwriting comparison):  Major (Welcome) Development: The Government of France has moved to honour this victim of anti—semitism within the French army  with a posthumous promotion over a century after his wrongful conviction,  The Algemeiner reports, noting that:  "In 1894, Dreyfus, a 36-year-old army captain from the Alsace region in northeastern France, was accused of leaking secret information to a German military official and was put on trial amid a fierce antisemitic media campaign.  Despite a lack of evidence, Dreyfus was convicted of treason based on a handwriting comparison with a document found in a German official’s wastepaper basket in Paris, sentenced to life imprisonment on Devil’s Island in French Guiana, and stripped of his military rank.  Years later, French Lieutenant Colonel Georges Picquart, then head of military intelligence, secretly reopened the case and uncovered that the handwriting on the incriminating document belonged to another officer. But when he brought this evidence to the army’s general staff, Picquart was dismissed from his post and imprisoned for a year."


-------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "All of the modern hallmarks of a miscarriage of justice are present in this fascinating case: A conviction based on dodgy hearsay evidence, a convenient scapegoat, overt prejudice and outlandish accusations with no basis in evidence. A polemical debate raged in the press, and favourable coverage in the media was a key part of securing a retrial. More important still was perhaps the redoubtable campaigning of Dreyfus’s wife, brother, and other allies, against an intransigent military and judicial system. But it would seem it doesn’t matter how high-profile a wrongful conviction, or how effectively exposed the cover-up may be, decades on many people will believe the establishment version of events, that there’s no smoke without fire, or indeed fall for the conspiracy theories that emerged at the outset of the case. Despite plenty of evidence that grave miscarriages of justice do happen, accompanied so often by the kind of cover-up as in the Dreyfus Affair, many people simply cannot entertain that the next one may come along sooner than they think."

--------------------------------------------------------
PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "Despite plenty of evidence that grave miscarriages of justice do happen, accompanied so often by the kind of cover-up as in the Dreyfus Affair, many people simply cannot entertain that the next one may come along sooner than they think. While people like Jeremy Bamber, Lucy Letby and others maintain their innocence while languishing in prison (whatever the outcome of any future appeals they may eventually be granted), it is worth remembering that the justice system can right a wrong after years or decades of dogged campaigning, but the cover-up and the conspiracy can last a century more."

----------------------------------------------------------

COMMENTARY:  "Conspiracies, campaigns and cover-ups: What the Dreyfus Affair can tell us 120 year on," by Samantha Dulieu, published by The Justice Gap, on November 12, 2026. "(Samantha Dulieu is a freelance writer and News Editor of The Justice Gap. She has covered some of the most high profile miscarriages of justice in the UK, as well as law, policy, human rights issues, prisons, protest and migration. She also offers her expertise to All party Parliamentary Group on miscarriages of justice through its secretariat, the Future Justice Project.)..."The Justice Gap is an online magazine about the law and justice run by journalists, The Justice Gap;)

SUB-HEADING: "What can a political scandal that seized late-nineteenth century France tell us about the long afterlives of miscarriages of justice?"

GIST: "Captain Alfred Dreyfus, the only Jewish Captain in the French army, was arrested then wrongfully convicted of treason in 1894. A new exhibition in London marks 120 years since Dreyfus was finally exonerated in 1906. This was only after he was found guilty a second time at a second trial – held after the real culprit had confessed and some within the French military establishment had even admitted the cover-up.

Dreyfus was convicted in the paranoid decades after the Franco-Prussian war when tensions remained heightened between France and Germany. He was accused of being a spy and selling military secrets to Germany. A note that was apparently written in Dreyfus’ hand was uncovered in the residence of the German Ambassador in France by a French intelligence agent and the blame immediately landed with Dreyfus. It was a time of antisemitic fervour in France. As a Jew, Dreyfus’ loyalties were assumed not to lie with France, and his conviction catalysed latent, outlandish antisemitic conspiracy theories.

The significance of this recent anniversary is found in how long some of myths around the case have endured, and how relevant it still appears.

A poster published in late nineteenth-century France featuring an antisemitic carton, Alfred Dreyfus is presented as the head of a Hydra. Wiener Holocaust Library, Courtesy of Birkbeck, University of London.

In 1945 a French far-right figure who had relished in denouncing Dreyfus in the 1890s was on trial for his role as a collaborator with Nazi Germany in the Vichy Regime. As the guilty verdict was read out, he exclaimed that he was a victim of ‘Dreyfus’s revenge’.

Speaking at the launch of the exhibition at The Wiener Holocaust Library, eminent historian Professor Sir Richard Evans described a scene from his youth in Oxford in the late 1960s. Watching an art-house film at the cinema, one of the characters described an event as ‘just like the Dreyfus Affair’, which prompted a French member of the audience to jump out of their seat and begin shouting that Dreyfus was guilty and always had been. It seemed he felt personally wronged that anyone should believe it was a true miscarriage of justice.

In 1995, over a century after the wrongful conviction, the French army formally announced that they believed Dreyfus was innocent of all charges and had been persecuted by the military because he was Jewish. The military official who said this at a meeting convened by a French-Jewish community group said remarks were nothing new and that the army had recognised Dreyfus’ innocence since the charges were dropped. However, the year before, the same official’s predecessor was ousted after he had suggested that Dreyfus was, in fact, guilty.

Several institutions over the intervening decades have refused to have a statue of Dreyfus installed outside their buildings, with the sculpture bouncing around Paris until it was finally given a permanent spot earlier this year.

All of the modern hallmarks of a miscarriage of justice are present in this fascinating case: A conviction based on dodgy hearsay evidence, a convenient scapegoat, overt prejudice and outlandish accusations with no basis in evidence. A polemical debate raged in the press, and favourable coverage in the media was a key part of securing a retrial. More important still was perhaps the redoubtable campaigning of Dreyfus’s wife, brother, and other allies, against an intransigent military and judicial system.

But it would seem it doesn’t matter how high-profile a wrongful conviction, or how effectively exposed the cover-up may be, decades on many people will believe the establishment version of events, that there’s no smoke without fire, or indeed fall for the conspiracy theories that emerged at the outset of the case. Despite plenty of evidence that grave miscarriages of justice do happen, accompanied so often by the kind of cover-up as in the Dreyfus Affair, many people simply cannot entertain that the next one may come along sooner than they think.

While people like Jeremy Bamber, Lucy Letby and others maintain their innocence while languishing in prison (whatever the outcome of any future appeals they may eventually be granted), it is worth remembering that the justice system can right a wrong after years or decades of dogged campaigning, but the cover-up and the conspiracy can last a century more."



PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;k

Friday, November 13, 2026

November 13: Richard Glossip: Oklahoma: Major (Welcome) Development: Oklahoma has dropped the murder charge he faced - after nearly executing him 9 times - The Intercept (Reporters Liliana Segura and Jordan Smith) reports, noting that: "But after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Glossip’s conviction in 2025, finding that it was rooted in false testimony and prosecutorial misconduct, Drummond, who by then was running for governor, did an abrupt about-face, announcing he would once again prosecute Glossip for first degree murder. In the year and a half since then, it has become glaringly apparent that prosecutors from Drummond’s office are grossly ill-equipped to take Glossip’s case to trial. Since his original trial in 1998, the state has lost or destroyed evidence, numerous witnesses have died, and prosecutors have conceded that their own star witness — who has sought to recant his testimony multiple times — can’t actually be expected to remember what happened the night of the killing. “For 30 years, Richard Glossip has maintained his innocence,” Knight said in a statement after the hearing. “After nearly executing him 9 times, the State of Oklahoma has now dismissed the murder charge against him. This morning, to finally put this matter to rest, Rich pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact. We believe Rich has more than paid his debt to society.”


STORY: "Oklahoma Drops Murder Charge Against Richard Glossip, Avoiding Third Trial," by Liliana Segura and Jordan Smith, published by The Intercept, on November 12, 2026. 
Liliana Segura,  Jordan Smith

SUB-HEADING: "Glossip agreed to plead guilty to a lesser charge to end his 30-year legal saga. He will be sentenced in December." 

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "The contours of Glossip’s plea are remarkably similar to a behind-the-scenes agreement made in 2023 between Drummond and Glossip’s lead attorney Don Knight. At the time, Drummond told Knight that if a court were to overturn Glossip’s conviction, he would resolve the case by accepting a plea to accessory after the fact in exchange for time served — and a promise that Glossip would not sue Oklahoma for anything related to his arrest and incarceration. But after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Glossip’s conviction in 2025, finding that it was rooted in false testimony and prosecutorial misconduct, Drummond, who by then was running for governor, did an abrupt about-face, announcing he would once again prosecute Glossip for first degree murder."

------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "Glossip’s sentencing hearing is scheduled for December 17. Since his release, Glossip has “been living a peaceful and law-abiding life,” Knight said in his statement. “We look forward to an opportunity to show why returning him to custody would not serve the interests of justice, and to ending this nightmare for Rich and all concerned.”


----------------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE THREE OF THE DAY: "GLOSSIP HAD ORIGINALLY been charged as an accessory after the fact for initially failing to give police information about the killing. The night Van Treese was killed, Glossip said, Sneed woke him up around 4 a.m. by knocking on the wall of his apartment, which was adjacent to the motel’s office. Standing outside with a black eye, Sneed told Glossip he had chased off some drunks who had broken a window in one of the motel rooms. According to Glossip, he asked Sneed about his black eye, and Sneed flippantly replied, “I killed Barry.” According to Glossip, it wasn’t until the next morning, when Van Treese was missing, that he realized Sneed might have been serious. Still, Glossip didn’t tell the cops right away; he said his girlfriend suggested waiting until they figured out what was going on. But Sneed told police Glossip was the mastermind behind the plot to kill Van Treese, and, with no other evidence tying Glossip to the crime, Sneed’s statement became the basis of the state’s case."


-----------------------------------------------------------------

GIST: "Less than a month before he was scheduled to stand trial a third time, accused of a murder he has always sworn he did not commit, Richard Glossip on Thursday agreed to plead guilty to a lesser charge, a final step toward bringing his three-decade legal saga to an end.

Glossip, 63, was twice convicted and sentenced to death for the 1997 murder of his boss Barry Van Treese inside Room 102 of the rundown motel the Van Treese family owned on the outskirts of Oklahoma City. A 19-year-old maintenance man named Justin Sneed admitted to killing Van Treese, but he insisted Glossip put him up to it. Sneed, who is currently serving a life sentence, escaped the death penalty by becoming the star witness against Glossip.

During a brief hearing that was originally scheduled to address pretrial matters, Oklahoma County Court Judge Natalie Mai instead accepted a plea from Glossip to accessory after the fact and dismissed the murder charge against him. With members of Van Treese’s family looking on from their seats in the jury box, Glossip stood to answer a series of routine questions to confirm that his plea was voluntary. Mai did not ask any specific questions about the crime itself.

Under Oklahoma law in place at the time of the killing, the maximum punishment for accessory after the fact was 45 years. Taking into consideration the decades Glossip spent on death row and credits earned for good behavior, Glossip’s attorneys say he would have been eligible for full release in 2016 and should serve no more time behind bars. But defense lawyers did not reach an agreement with the state as to a proposed sentence. In a statement released after the hearing, Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond, who once expressed deep concerns about the state’s case against Glossip, made clear that his office will be seeking additional prison time.

Ultimately it will be up to Mai to decide if Glossip should be sentenced to time served or if any additional punishment is warranted.

The contours of Glossip’s plea are remarkably similar to a behind-the-scenes agreement made in 2023 between Drummond and Glossip’s lead attorney Don Knight. At the time, Drummond told Knight that if a court were to overturn Glossip’s conviction, he would resolve the case by accepting a plea to accessory after the fact in exchange for time served — and a promise that Glossip would not sue Oklahoma for anything related to his arrest and incarceration.

“We believe Rich has more than paid his debt to society.”


But after the U.S. Supreme Court overturned Glossip’s conviction in 2025, finding that it was rooted in false testimony and prosecutorial misconduct, Drummond, who by then was running for governor, did an abrupt about-face, announcing he would once again prosecute Glossip for first degree murder.

In the year and a half since then, it has become glaringly apparent that prosecutors from Drummond’s office are grossly ill-equipped to take Glossip’s case to trial. Since his original trial in 1998, the state has lost or destroyed evidence, numerous witnesses have died, and prosecutors have conceded that their own star witness — who has sought to recant his testimony multiple times — can’t actually be expected to remember what happened the night of the killing.

“For 30 years, Richard Glossip has maintained his innocence,” Knight said in a statement after the hearing. “After nearly executing him 9 times, the State of Oklahoma has now dismissed the murder charge against him. This morning, to finally put this matter to rest, Rich pleaded guilty to being an accessory after the fact. We believe Rich has more than paid his debt to society.”

GLOSSIP HAD ORIGINALLY been charged as an accessory after the fact for initially failing to give police information about the killing. The night Van Treese was killed, Glossip said, Sneed woke him up around 4 a.m. by knocking on the wall of his apartment, which was adjacent to the motel’s office. Standing outside with a black eye, Sneed told Glossip he had chased off some drunks who had broken a window in one of the motel rooms. According to Glossip, he asked Sneed about his black eye, and Sneed flippantly replied, “I killed Barry.”

According to Glossip, it wasn’t until the next morning, when Van Treese was missing, that he realized Sneed might have been serious. Still, Glossip didn’t tell the cops right away; he said his girlfriend suggested waiting until they figured out what was going on.

But Sneed told police Glossip was the mastermind behind the plot to kill Van Treese, and, with no other evidence tying Glossip to the crime, Sneed’s statement became the basis of the state’s case. At Glossip’s 1998 trial, prosecutors said that he had taken advantage of the younger, more vulnerable Sneed, offering him money to kill their boss so that Glossip could take over the motel. “Glossip encouraged, aided and abetted and sent Mr. Sneed off to do his dirty work,” then-prosecutor Fern Smith told the jury.

But this story began falling apart not long after Glossip arrived on death row. A video of Sneed’s police interrogation cast serious doubt on the state’s version of events, revealing coercive questioning by Oklahoma City detectives who pressured Sneed into implicating Glossip.

Glossip’s defense failed to present the tape to the jury, which led an Oklahoma court to overturn Glossip’s first conviction based on ineffective assistance of counsel. Although a second jury convicted him and sent him to die in 2004, doubts over Glossip’s guilt continued to grow.

Glossip subsequently came close to execution many times and may well have been executed if Drummond hadn’t intervened upon taking office in 2023. He ordered an independent investigation into the case, which concluded that rampant prosecutorial misconduct had infected Glossip’s conviction. Drummond asked the Oklahoma Court of Criminal Appeals to overturn the case. When that failed, joined Glossip in asking the Supreme Court to intervene, arguing that Sneed – whom the state has described as its “indispensable witness” – had lied on the witness stand.

Drummond’s concessions about the flaws in the state’s case and his unprecedented advocacy on Glossip’s behalf made his announcement in June 2025 that he would seek to retry Glossip for murder all the more shocking. According to Glossip’s lawyers, the decision also betrayed the long-standing agreement with Drummond to resolve the case and set Glossip free.

After that, Drummond essentially washed his hands of the case to focus on his ultimately failed attempt to become Oklahoma’s next governor, handing off prosecutorial duties to other lawyers in his office. Prosecutors declared that they intended to use the same discredited evidence to try Glossip a third time and spent months fighting to keep him in jail. Despite those efforts, Mai ordered Glossip’s release.

With a December 2026 trial date looming, tensions between the two sides have ratcheted up. Glossip’s lawyers have complained about prosecutors failing to turn over evidence as required under the law. Prosecutors have tried to limit what the defense can present to jurors at trial regarding the history of the case – including asking Mai to bar any mention of Drummond’s previous advocacy on Glossip’s behalf.

Glossip’s sentencing hearing is scheduled for December 17.

Since his release, Glossip has “been living a peaceful and law-abiding life,” Knight said in his statement. “We look forward to an opportunity to show why returning him to custody would not serve the interests of justice, and to ending this nightmare for Rich and all concerned.”

After the hearing, Glossip and his wife, Lea, stood with Knight to address reporters. Glossip thanked Knight and Lea for their support. “It was a hard day,” Lea told The Intercept, “but Richard and I are both people of faith.” She expressed that “today marks a meaningful step toward finally bringing this case to an end. We are both deeply grateful for the tireless efforts of his legal team.”

The entire story can be read at: 

https://share.google/vUYGbwYtXCLX9mwQK

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com. Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD: (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases): "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions. They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;

November 13: Recent National Registry of Exonerations (NRE) entry: Sheila Denton: Georgia: Evolving bitemark science - and mark those fatal, but often deceptive words, 'to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty.' Recent National Registry of Exoneration (NRE) entry: As Judge Brooks put it, on dismissing all of the charge, without the bitemark evidence: “the only evidence linking [Denton] to the murder was the testimony of a single witness [Jones] who testified that [Denton] admitted to the murder. However, a review of the trial transcript shows that this witness was effectively impeached at trial and had highly dubious credibility.” The evolving science? ... "In November 2017, Mark Loudon-Brown and Katherine Moss, attorneys from the Southern Center for Human Rights, filed an extraordinary motion for a new trial. The motion asserted that David’s testimony at the trial was no longer valid. The motion was based in part on advancements in the scientific understanding of bitemark evidence, changes in the American Board of Forensic Odontology (ABFO) guidelines, and new opinions from two other forensic odontologists that demonstrated that the bitemark evidence in the case could not affirmatively link Denton the murder."


PASSAGE ONE OF THE DAY: In March 2006, Denton went to trial in Ware County Superior Court. The prosecution’s primary evidence was testimony from Dr. Thomas David, a forensic odontologist.  David testified “to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty” that a bitemark had been found on Denton’s left arm and a bitemark had been found on Garner’s right forearm. David said “to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty” that it was probable that Denton left the bitemark on Garner and that it was probable that Garner left the bitemark on Denton. 

----------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "In addition, the motion said that David’s opinions on bitemark evidence had evolved as well. The motion said that in April of 2016, following the change in the ABFO Guidelines, David had authored an affidavit in a bitemark case in Pennsylvania. In that case, he had testified at the 1991 trial of John Kunco and linked Kunco to an injury that David said was a bitemark.  In his affidavit in that case, David had said that the “scientific knowledge and understanding on which these conclusions were based, however, has changed significantly,” and that he “would not proffer such testimony, since it is inconsistent with the current ABFO Guidelines and with current scientific understanding of the limitations of bitemark comparison.”

-------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE THREE OF THE DAY: "The motion said that during an evidentiary hearing in the Kunco case, David had modified his opinion in light of the changes in scientific understanding of bitemark evidence as was reflected in the new ABFO Guidelines. He had changed his opinion from the highest level of certainty that the injury was a bitemark to “cannot exclude.”  The motion said that David further admitted that he could not give an opinion as to how many people could have made the mark at issue because “[y]ou don’t know how many people might be included in an open population.”  “In other words, in Mr. Kunco’s case, Dr. David admitted that the new evidence—namely, the change in scientific understanding of bitemark analysis as reflected in the new ABFO Guidelines—would change the testimony he would offer at trial,” the motion said. (In 2019, after Kunco had been granted a new trial, he pled guilty to lesser charges for his release.) Waycross County Chief Superior Court Judge Dwayne H. Gillis held a hearing in May 2018."

-------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE FOUR OF THE DAY: "David testified, as did Dr. Cynthia Brzozowski and Dr. Adam Freeman—all board-certified by the ABFO. The defense also presented two affidavits co-authored by five board-certified ABFO odontologists. Each of the experts agreed that any testimony regarding the bitemarks, based on the current science, would no longer be incriminating.  David admitted that if he testified at Denton’s trial based on the recent advancements in science, his testimony would have been different."

---------------------------------------------------------


 National Registry of Exonerations: Sheila Denton: Georgia: Major (Welcome) Development: Contributing factors: False or Misleading Forensic Evidence, Perjury or False Accusation, Official Misconduct." By Maurice Possley: Entered on September 15.  2026.

On May 21, 2004, the body of 73-year-old Eugene Garner was found in his home in Waycross, Georgia. Neighbors called the police after entering his house, seeing signs of a struggle, and smelling natural gas. Garner was lying face down in the bedroom.

Police noticed that all of the gas stove burners were on, but the pilot lights were extinguished. Once the house cleared of gas, Garner’s body was removed. His pockets had been turned out of his pants.

An autopsy revealed that Garner died from manual strangulation and extensive blunt force trauma. An injury on his right forearm was characterized as a bitemark. His body had been doused with a liquid chemical.

Thirty-seven-year-old Sheila Denton became a suspect after she was arrested at midnight on the day Garner’s body was found and gave police a false name. Police determined that Denton knew Garner because she had delivered food to his house. Garner was commonly believed at the time to keep large amounts of cash in his house, although there was no evidence, beyond his turned out pants pockets, that any money was missing.

Police subsequently picked up Sharon Jones, an admitted crack cocaine addict and crack cocaine dealer. During an interrogation, Jones initially denied any knowledge of the crime. However, when she was threatened with being charged with Garner’s murder, she implicated Denton, claiming that Denton had confessed to the crime.

On August 13, 2004, Denton was indicted on charges of malice murder, felony murder, and giving a false name to the police.

In March 2006, Denton went to trial in Ware County Superior Court. The prosecution’s primary evidence was testimony from Dr. Thomas David, a forensic odontologist.

David testified “to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty” that a bitemark had been found on Denton’s left arm and a bitemark had been found on Garner’s right forearm. David said “to a reasonable degree of scientific certainty” that it was probable that Denton left the bitemark on Garner and that it was probable that Garner left the bitemark on Denton.

An analyst from the Georgia Bureau of Investigation's Division of Forensic Sciences testified that she had examined hairs that were found in Garner’s hand. The analyst said that the hair belonged to Garner. She said no hair associated with Denton was found at the scene.

Jones testified that at 4:30 a.m. some day in May 2004, Denton came to a known crack house where Jones was guarding about $500 worth of crack cocaine. When Denton first came to the door, according to Jones, Denton said, “I did something.” Jones said that Denton had cuts and scratches on her arms and legs. Jones testified that she asked Denton, "What’s wrong with you? What happened?”

Jones said that Denton replied, “I just killed the man that stay in front of Wally’s,” referring to a convenience store across the highway from Garner’s residence. Jones said that Denton, who typically had little money, bought $300 worth of crack cocaine and left.

Jones testified that she didn’t believe Denton. She said that she thought Denton had fallen in some bushes.

She admitted that she implicated Denton only after the officers “kept saying I did it.” She said the police told her they had found her fingerprints in Garner’s home and that they had a videotape of her in the home. Jones said she knew that wasn’t true, but the officers threatened to put her in jail.

The prosecution conceded during closing arguments that if not for the bitemark testimony, “I have to admit that’s reasonable doubt” in the case.

On March 15, 2006, the jury acquitted Denton of malice murder, and convicted her of felony murder and giving a false name to the police. She was sentenced to life in prison plus one year.

Denton appealed, arguing that Jones was not a credible witness because of the amount of crack cocaine she was smoking at that time, the tricks and lies the police officers told to get her to talk to them, and contradictions between her trial testimony and her statements to police officers.

In February 2010, the Georgia Supreme Court rejected these arguments and affirmed the convictions and sentence. “The transcript reveals that all of these matters going to Jones’s credibility were thoroughly addressed by defense counsel on cross-examination,” the Court said. “Assessing the credibility of Sharon Jones was a matter lying within the province of the jury, not this Court.”

In November 2017, Mark Loudon-Brown and Katherine Moss, attorneys from the Southern Center for Human Rights, filed an extraordinary motion for a new trial. The motion asserted that David’s testimony at the trial was no longer valid.

The motion was based in part on advancements in the scientific understanding of bitemark evidence, changes in the American Board of Forensic Odontology (ABFO) guidelines, and new opinions from two other forensic odontologists that demonstrated that the bitemark evidence in the case could not affirmatively link Denton the murder.

In addition, the motion said that David’s opinions on bitemark evidence had evolved as well. The motion said that in April of 2016, following the change in the ABFO Guidelines, David had authored an affidavit in a bitemark case in Pennsylvania. In that case, he had testified at the 1991 trial of John Kunco and linked Kunco to an injury that David said was a bitemark.

In his affidavit in that case, David had said that the “scientific knowledge and understanding on which these conclusions were based, however, has changed significantly,” and that he “would not proffer such testimony, since it is inconsistent with the current ABFO Guidelines and with current scientific understanding of the limitations of bitemark comparison.”

The motion said that during an evidentiary hearing in the Kunco case, David had modified his opinion in light of the changes in scientific understanding of bitemark evidence as was reflected in the new ABFO Guidelines. He had changed his opinion from the highest level of certainty that the injury was a bitemark to “cannot exclude.”

The motion said that David further admitted that he could not give an opinion as to how many people could have made the mark at issue because “[y]ou don’t know how many people might be included in an open population.”

“In other words, in Mr. Kunco’s case, Dr. David admitted that the new evidence—namely, the change in scientific understanding of bitemark analysis as reflected in the new ABFO Guidelines—would change the testimony he would offer at trial,” the motion said. (In 2019, after Kunco had been granted a new trial, he pled guilty to lesser charges for his release.) Waycross County Chief Superior Court Judge Dwayne H. Gillis held a hearing in May 2018.

David testified, as did Dr. Cynthia Brzozowski and Dr. Adam Freeman—all board-certified by the ABFO. The defense also presented two affidavits co-authored by five board-certified ABFO odontologists. Each of the experts agreed that any testimony regarding the bitemarks, based on the current science, would no longer be incriminating.

David admitted that if he testified at Denton’s trial based on the recent advancements in science, his testimony would have been different.

Brzozowski testified that at the time of Denton’s trial, the testimony given by David was permissible. However, by 2019, saying that an injury was probably a bitemark was no longer a permitted conclusion by ABFO guidelines.

“He [David] testified that Ms. Denton was the probable biter of Mr. Garner and that Mr. Garner was the probable biter of Ms. Denton. And today we would not testify as to a probabilistic association,” Brzozowski said.

She said she had reviewed photographs of the injuries and concluded there was “insufficient evidence to determine that either of these injuries are human bite marks.”

Freeman testified that under the current AFBO guidelines, David’s trial testimony concerning probability would be “a misrepresentation of what the underlying science supports.” He said that in his opinion, neither injury was a bitemark at all.

On Feb. 7, 2020, Denton's conviction was vacated with assistance from the Innocence Project. Judge Gillis granted the defense motion, vacated Denton’s convictions, and ordered a new trial.

“The defense testimony and evidence in this case is profound and leads one to conclude that bitemark evidence is no longer a valid subject of scientific inquiry unless it can exonerate one or exclude a particular person,” Judge Gillis wrote.

The judge noted that “David admitted that, today, he would not even compare the marks on [Garner] with the teeth of Denton, because it is uncertain as to what caused the injury at all.”

Moreover, Judge Gillis said, “This record is clear that the expert opinion evidence has changed. Additionally, it is clear that the ABFO guidelines changed due to the realization that bitemark evidence is inherently unreliable.”

He said that the ABFO’s recognition of the inadequacies of bitemark evidence "is profound and undisputed." He added that the bitemark evidence presented in Denton' s trial "was not competent evidence.”

On April 8, 2020, more than 15 years after her arrest, Denton was released pending a retrial.

On September 9, 2026, Ware County Superior Court Judge J. Kelly Brooks dismissed all of the charges against Denton.

In a one-page ruling, Judge Brooks declared that “the State does not believe there is sufficient evidence likely to obtain a conviction beyond a reasonable doubt.”

Judge Brooks noted that without the bitemark evidence, “the only evidence linking [Denton] to the murder was the testimony of a single witness [Jones] who testified that [Denton] admitted to the murder. However, a review of the trial transcript shows that this witness was effectively impeached at trial and had highly dubious credibility.”"

The entire entry can be read at: 


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com. Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD: (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases): "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions. They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;