BACKGROUND: "Mailman’s name came up in the investigation and detectives pulled out all the stops to make the case stick, even though they had nothing beyond rumour and suspicion against a backdrop of tunnel vision. There was no physical evidence against Mailman or Gillespie, and the two had a strong alibi placing them at a car parts dealership at the time of the murder. The police case, later prosecuted by Stephen Wood and James McAvity, was anchored in the testimonies of two witnesses: a troubled 16-year-old boy — who was paid cash before, during and after the trials — and a single mom originally charged in the murder who said the police threatened to take her kids away if she didn’t play along. She acted as a paid police informant, assigned to hang around Mailman and Gillespie to get incriminating evidence against them. They both later said they lied on the stand under police pressure. None of this evidence, which would have undermined the witnesses’ credibility, was disclosed to defence lawyers, let alone the jury at either trial.
Ottawa Citizen: "Presumed guilty: The Life sentence of Bobby and Wally: Senior Writer, Courts, Crime and Justice, Gary Dimmock: August 14, 2025.
QUOTE OF THE DAY: "Mailman, born on March 14, 1948, in Saint John, was the oldest child in a family that would grow to include 15 brothers and sisters.
In prison, he passed the time working at various jobs in the gym, the library and as a cleaner. And he kept up a strict exercise routine. He said he loved running, especially when it was raining. "Someone asked me one time, 'Why do you like jogging in the rain?"' he recalled. The answer: "Because no one sees you crying."
-----------------------------------------------
----------------------------------------------------
STORY: "'The predicament of my life': Wrongfully convicted N.B. man dies from cancer," by Candia Press Reporter Hina Alam, published by |CBC News on October 13, 2025.
SUB-HEADING: "Robert Mailman, who spent 18 years in prison, was acquitted in January 2024."
SUB-HEADING: :Robert Mailman was a convicted murderer for 40 years and spent 18 years in prison for a crime he didn’t commit."
GIST: "A New Brunswick man who spent 18 years in prison after he was wrongfully convicted of murder has died at the age of 77.
Robert Mailman spent more than half of his life under the cloud of a wrongful murder conviction.
On Thursday, less than two years after he was acquitted of the crime, Mailman died from liver cancer. He was 77.
On May 11, 1984, Mailman and childhood acquaintance Walter Gillespie were convicted in the 1983 beating death of George Gilman Leeman in Saint John. His body had been doused with gasoline and set on fire in Rockwood Park, court heard.
Despite strong alibis, the two accused were found guilty of second-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison with no chance of parole for 18 years. Mailman served 18 years.
Gillespie remained behind bars for 21 years.
Both men steadfastly denied any involvement in the crime.
With the help of advocacy group Innocence Canada, the pair filed for a federal criminal conviction review in December 2019.
Their bid for an appeal was rejected by the New Brunswick Court of Appeal. And the Supreme Court of Canada declined to grant them leave to appeal a few years later.
As their legal odyssey dragged on, Mailman's health took a dramatic turn in November 2023 after he passed out while exercising in his Saint John apartment. Tests confirmed he had terminal liver cancer. He was given three months to live.
"So I just got to accept it," he said in an interview. "There's no off-ramp. I'm going to die. Period."
New trial ordered
The following month, then federal justice minister Arif Virani ordered a new trial for the two men, saying new, significant information had not been submitted to the courts.
Mailman, born on March 14, 1948, in Saint John, was the oldest child in a family that would grow to include 15 brothers and sisters.
In prison, he passed the time working at various jobs in the gym, the library and as a cleaner. And he kept up a strict exercise routine. He said he loved running, especially when it was raining.
"Someone asked me one time, 'Why do you like jogging in the rain?"' he recalled. The answer: "Because no one sees you crying."
He once described living under the weight of an unjust murder conviction as "the predicament of my life."
James Lockyer, founding director of Innocence Canada, said Mailman approached the organization for help in the early '90s.
Lockyer described Mailman as "the more vocal of the two."
And the longtime lawyer praised Gillespie for being fiercely loyal to his friend. Gillespie had said he could have avoided a lengthy prison term by signing a false confession implicating Mailman in the killing, Lockyer noted.
"And he just refused to do it because neither of them had anything to do with the crime," Lockyer said. "So between the two of them, they were an extraordinary couple, and I think they have had an impact on the New Brunswick justice system."
'Miscarriage of justice'
On Jan. 4, 2024, the Crown decided not to call any evidence in the new trial. As a result, Chief Justice Tracey DeWare of New Brunswick's Court of King's Bench acquitted the two men of the charges and declared they were innocent in the eyes of the law.
DeWare apologized for the "miscarriage of justice." In a submission to the court, Innocence Canada highlighted a series of failings in the prosecution of the two men.
These included recanted testimony from key witnesses, evidence withheld from the defence, substandard forensic evidence and a disregard for the men's alibis.
In February of last year, Innocence Canada announced the two men had reached a "satisfactory" settlement with the New Brunswick government, details of which would not be disclosed as a condition of the deal.
Gillespie died in April 2024 at the age of 80. The cause of his death was not disclosed.
Mailman said he had asked his doctor to keep him alive long enough to attend the court hearing.
"And they really went overboard to help me and I really appreciate it," he said as he relaxed in his apartment, surrounded by framed photos of his children, grandchildren and great-grandchildren.
Before the settlement was reached, Mailman said no amount of money would bring back the lost time, adding that his two sons had died while he was in prison.
"I can never get them back.… My biggest loss is my sons."
His health continued to fade, and in January of this year, he said he weighed less than 100 pounds, down from his usual 160.
"I'm getting weaker," he said at the time. "I can feel it. The things I could do three weeks ago … I can't do it now."
But his sense of determination showed no signs of letting up.
"I can go sit in a corner and be pouting and sit there in pity, or just keep going. I'm going to keep going on until I can't."
Both men steadfastly denied any involvement in the crime.
The entire story can be read at:
—————————————————————————
————————————————————————————————
Win Wahrer, Director of Client Services, of Innocence Canada, stressed the nobility of this man, who along with the late Wally Gillespie, fought for over 40 years to clear his name of a crime they did not commit, saying:
It is with great sadness that we mourn the loss of Robert (Bobby) Mailman who lost his long battle with liver cancer on Thursday, October 9th.
