Showing posts with label child protection proceedings. Show all posts
Showing posts with label child protection proceedings. Show all posts

Monday, March 31, 2008

Part Four: Closing Submissions: The Government Is Responsible For Destroying The Families; It Must Try To Repair The Damage;

"WE HAVE A MORAL OBLIGATION TO THE CHILDREN WHO MAY HAVE BEEN WRONGLY SEPARATED FROM THEIR PARENTS AS A RESULT OF THE OPINIONS OF DR. SMITH AND DR. CAIRNS.

TO ABDICATE OUR RESPONSIBILITIES IN RESPECT OF THOSE PEOPLE WOULD BE IRRESPONSIBLE AND IMMORAL AND ARGUABLY IN BREACH OF THE UNITED NATIONS CONVENTION ON THE RIGHTS OF THE CHILD SUCH THAT “THIS MUST BE DONE;"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"DR. SMITH IN HIS EVIDENCE SUGGESTED THAT THERE MAY BE THREE TO FOUR OTHER CASES WHERE HE GAVE EVIDENCE THAT WERE NOT THE SUBJECT OF CRIMINAL PROCEEDINGS BUT WERE THE SUBJECT OF CHILD PROTECTION PROCEEDINGS.

GIVEN THE FRAILTIES OF DR. SMITH’S CREDIBILITY AND HIS HISTORY OF PROVIDING UNTRUE INFORMATION UNDER OATH, DEFENCE FOR CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL SUBMITS THAT THERE MUST BE A SYSTEMATIC REVIEW OF HIS WORK TO IDENTIFY CASES IN WHICH HIS OPINION MAY HAVE AFFECTED THE OUTCOME OF A CHILD PROTECTION PROCEEDING."

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
LAWYER SUZAN FRASER: CLOSING SUBMISSIONS;
-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The Goudge Inquiry has heard disturbing evidence about surviving children who have wrongfully been removed from their families as a result of Dr. Charles Smith's flawed opinions.

One of the toughest challenges will be to identify these children in the context of both criminal and child welfare proceedings.

Lawyer Suzan Fraser argues in her closing submissions on behalf of "Defence For Children International Canada" that, "we have a moral obligation to the children who may have been wrongly separated from their parents as a result of the opinions of Dr. Smith and Dr. Cairns."

"To abdicate our responsibilities in respect of those people would be irresponsible and immoral and arguably in breach of the United Nations Convention on the Rights of the Child such that “this must be done,” Fraser continues.

Defence For Children International accepts this position and submits that in order for confidence to be restored in pediatric forensic pathology, the Government must create a way to right a wrong.

Dr. Smith, through this inquiry, agreed to cooperate by identifying circumstances in which he gave evidence.

Dr. Smith in his evidence suggested that there may be three to four other cases where he gave evidence that were not the subject of criminal proceedings but were the subject of child protection proceedings.

Given the frailties of Dr. Smith’s credibility and his history of providing untrue information under oath, Defence For Children International submits that there must be a systematic review of his work to identify cases in which his opinion may have affected the outcome of a child protection proceeding.

At the child protection roundtable, (held by the Goudge Inquiry) Professor Bala proposed that legislation be enacted to provide for the identification of children who may have been affected by Dr. Smith’s work and the disclosure of that information to them."


Fraser,who advocates that corrective measures be advanced under a regulatory framework rather than waiting for legislative reform, says the identification process will be difficult because there are 53 different children’s aid societies.

She wants wants Justice Goudge to recommend the appointment of a task force which has the power and resources to identify the cases, review the pathology, notify the children and families involved,and then attempt to mediate s solution which is in the child's interest.

This appears to be an extremely difficult but manageable task if the government admits its responsibility for the mess and determines to rectify it.

Innocent parents would not have had their children seized from them - and children would not have gone through the horror and disruption of being taken away from their families without the intervention of government agents including police, prosecutors, social workers and children's aid officials in these cases;

This Blogster suspects that the Ontario government will be reluctant to undertake such a difficult and costly task.

I hope Justice Goudge will use his moral authority - having heard all of the disturbing evidence about destroyed families - to embarrass the government into taking prompt action.

Harold Levy...hlevy15@gmail.com;

Sunday, March 30, 2008

Part Three: Closing Submissions: Miscarriages of Justice And Ontario's Child Welfare System;

"CHALLENGES EXIST BECAUSE OF THE LACK OF RESOURCES AND PRESTIGE YET THE EFFECTS OF A MISCARRIAGE OF JUSTICE IN A CHILD PROTECTION PROCEEDING ARE UNIMAGINABLE."

LAWYER SUZAN FRASER IN HER CLOSING SUBMISSIONS TO THE GOUDGE INQUIRY ON BEHALF OF DEFENCE FOR CHILDREN INTERNATIONAL CANADA.

During the course of the Goudge Inquiry I have been stunned by the collateral damage caused by child protection authorities with respect to siblings when a parent is wrongly accused of murdering a child.

In most cases the damage happened at the outset - long before any conviction - while the accused parent was supposed to be presumed innocent.

We heard stories of children being seized from their still grieving parents and placed under the care and protection of a Children's Aid Society.

We heard stories of children baby's taken away from their loving mothers at birth and placed with strangers.

We heard about children who were ultimately put up for adoption into other families -the parents may never get them back.

Lawyer Suzan Fraser, who represents "Defence For Children International Canada" has done an excellent job at the Inquiry of reminding us that miscarriages of justice are not limited to the cases of wrongly convicted accused person;

Fraser reminds us in her closing submissions that Ontario's child welfare system is prone to miscarriages of justice too.

"The child welfare system has always been a poor cousin to the criminal justice system with fewer resources and less prestige than the criminal justice system," says Fraser.

"Challenges exist because of the lack of resources and prestige yet the effects of a miscarriage of justice in a child protection proceeding are unimaginable."

Yes, "unimaginable" is a very strong word.

But how else can you describe the horror experienced not only by the wrongly accused parent - but that experienced as well by the sibling that is being torn away from his or her parent in the circumstances;

Fraser also does a public service by pointing out that tunnel vision also contributes to miscarriages of justice in the child welfare system as she submits that "the need to guard against tunnel vision is as important in child welfare investigations as in criminal proceedings."

She also cautions that "social workers are slow to revise their judgments" - an apparent reference to Dr. Charles Smith who proved to be most reluctant to change an opinion once formed.

"Social workers need a greater acceptance of their fallibility and a willingness to consider that the judgements and decisions are wrong," Fraser adds.

"To change your mind in the light of new information is a sign of good practice, a sign of strength not weakness."

Fraser would like to see Justice Goudge make several recommendations aimed at preventing miscarriages of justice in the province's child welfare system, including:

0: Funding for counsel in child welfare proceedings;
0: Development and support of effective legal advocates for both parent and child in the child welfare proceeding through access to education initiatives;
0: Access to defence pathologists;
0: Funding for expert reports; and
0: Guarding against tunnel vision and confirmation bias.

Justice Goudge would do well to heed Fraser's advice.

Next posting: Part Four: Closing Submissions: And what about the children who were permanently given away?

Harold Levy...hlevy15@gmail.com;