Showing posts with label hair. Show all posts
Showing posts with label hair. Show all posts

Sunday, April 27, 2008

Part Two: "Forensic Stalker:" Former Oklahoma Forensic Scientist Gilchrist Accused of Hiding Or Destroying Hairs Sought For DNA Testing;

EARLY POSTING FOR MONDAY APRIL 28, 2008;

IN EACH OF ITS RULINGS OVERTURNING MCCARTY’S CONVICTIONS, THE APPEALS COURT NOTED THAT GILCHRIST INITIALLY SAID HAIRS FROM THE CRIME SCENE DEFINITELY DID NOT MATCH MCCARTY, THEN CHANGED HER RECORDS AND TESTIMONY TO SAY THEY DEFINITELY MATCHED HIM (YEARS LATER, GILCHRIST EITHER HID OR DESTROYED THOSE HAIRS WHEN THEY WERE SOUGHT FOR DNA TESTING).

FROM INNOCENCE PROJECT PRESS RELEASE HEADED "INNOCENT MAN FREED FROM DEATH ROW" - CASE INVOLVED OKLAHOMA FORENSIC SCIENTIST JOYCE GILCHRIST;

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Curtis McCarty's release after serving 21 years in prison in Oklahoma - including sixteen on death row - following his conviction on evidence given by now discredited forensic scientist Joyce Gilchrist - is the subject of a press release issued by the Innocence Project on May 12, 2007.

McCarty had been exonerated by DNA evidence;

In a recent post, I described how a Blog, operating out of Denver, Colorado, compared Dr. Charles Smith to Gilchrist, who's tainted evidence has been implicated in death penalty cases; ("Smith Compared To Notorious American Forensic Specialist - Called "Latest Forensic Stalker.")

The author states that, "While Joyce Gilchrist of Oklahoma apparently still holds the world's record for systematically framing the largest number of people over a period of years ,the Toronto Star reports today, December 10,2007,that Canada boasts a forensic expert who,in duration of his service(if not in the number of his victims)can at least equal Gilmore's achievement."

(Dr. Charles Smith has admitted making "errors" and "mistakes" during his evidence at the Goudge Inquiry but has consistently denied allegations that he deliberately set out to harm to any of the individuals who were affected by his flawed opinions.)

I was fascinated to note the allegation in the press release that Gilchrist had hid or destroyed hairs which had been sought for DNA-testing in the case - in light of Dr. Smith's admissions that he had kept in his personal possession (and failed to submit for testing) an apparent male pubic hair taken during the autopsy on Baby Jenna which could have been of significant evidentiary value to the defence.

The press release, datelined, Oklahoma City, appeared under the heading: "Another Innocent Man Freed From Death Row: Oklahoma City case is one of the worst cases of government misconduct in the history of the American criminal justice system, Innocence Project says."

"Curtis Edward McCarty, who was convicted twice and sentenced to death for the same murder in verdicts that were both thrown out based on evidence of his innocence and an extraordinary pattern of government misconduct, was released from prison this morning after a judge dismissed the indictment against him that would have led to a third trial," the release began;

"The prosecution said today that it will not appeal the decision – finally clearing McCarty after 21 years of wrongful incarceration, more than 16 of them on death row," it continued.

"In 1986, McCarty was convicted of a 1982 murder in Oklahoma City and sentenced to die.

Citing misconduct by the prosecutor and a police lab analyst, the Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the conviction, and McCarty was retried in 1989.

He was again convicted and sentenced to death. In 1995, the appeals court upheld his conviction but threw out his death sentence; in 1996, he was sentenced to death again.

In 2005, the Court of Criminal Appeals again overturned his conviction, citing the continued pattern of government misconduct – and new DNA tests showing
that semen recovered from the victim did not come from McCarty.

“Every piece of evidence in this case, including evidence that was used improperly to secure convictions, now shows Curtis McCarty’s innocence,” said Colin Starger, the Innocence Project Staff Attorney on the case who argued the motion to dismiss the indictment in a three-hour hearing yesterday afternoon.

“Semen recovered from the victim, material under the victim’s fingernails and a bloody print the perpetrator left on the victim’s body all come from someone other than Curtis McCarty.”

Robert H. Macy, who was the Oklahoma County District Attorney for 21 years, prosecuted McCarty in both of his trials.

Macy sent 73 people to death row – more than any other prosecutor in the nation – and 20 of them have been executed.

Macy has said publicly that he believes executing an innocent person is a sacrifice worth making in order to keep the death penalty in the United States.

Macy committed misconduct in the manner that he prosecuted McCarty and presented the case to the jury.

His misconduct was compounded when he relied on Joyce Gilchrist, a police lab analyst who falsified test results and hid or destroyed evidence in order to help secure McCarty’s convictions.

Gilchrist was the lead forensic analyst in 23 cases that ended in death sentences (11 of the defendants in those cases have been executed).

“This is by far one of the worst cases of law enforcement misconduct in the history of the American criminal justice system,” said Barry Scheck, Co-Director of the Innocence Project, which is affiliated with Cardozo School of Law.

“Bob Macy has said that executing an innocent person is a risk worth taking – and he came very close to doing just that with Curtis McCarty.”

Macy’s conduct in prosecuting McCarty was singled out in the Court of Criminal Appeals ruling that overturned McCarty’s first conviction; that ruling noted that the case was “replete with error” and referred to Macy’s conduct as “improper” and “unprofessional.”

In each of its rulings overturning McCarty’s convictions, the appeals court noted that Gilchrist initially said hairs from the crime scene definitely did not match McCarty, then changed her records and testimony to say they definitely matched him (years later, Gilchrist either hid or destroyed those hairs when they were sought for DNA testing).

The prosecution also claimed that semen on the victim’s body came from McCarty, while DNA testing now shows that it did not.

The prosecution maintained that McCarty acted alone in the crime, until evidence began to emerge that he was not the perpetrator; at that point, the prosecution began to say McCarty had an accomplice (though no evidence of multiple perpetrators was ever found or introduced).

McCarty was charged in 1985 with stabbing and strangling 18-year-old Pamela Kaye Willis three years earlier in Oklahoma City.

Willis, an acquaintance of McCarty’s, was found dead in the kitchen of a friend’s home on December 10, 1982.

Hairs and other biological evidence were collected by police at the crime scene.

Gilchrist, who testified in both of McCarty’s trials, was fired in 2001 for fraud and misconduct in McCarty’s case and others.

DNA testing conducted on post-conviction appeal in 2002 showed that sperm recovered from the victim’s body did not match McCarty and the Court of Criminal Appeals overturned the second conviction in 2005.

The Innocence Project became involved in the case in 2003; attorneys Perry Hudson and Marna Franklin also represent McCarty.

“For anyone who believes the death penalty is being carried out appropriately in this country, and anyone who believes that prosecutors and government witnesses can always be relied on to pursue the truth, this case is a wake-up call,” said Peter Neufeld, Co-Director of the Innocence Project.

“Three separate times, an innocent man was sentenced to die because of the actions of an unethical prosecutor and a fraudulent analyst.”

McCarty is the 201st person in the United States exonerated through DNA evidence – and the 15th of those 201 who has served time on death row.

McCarty is the ninth person to be exonerated by DNA evidence in Oklahoma and the third to be exonerated from the state’s death row.

Robert Miller was exonerated based on DNA evidence in 1998 after serving more than 9 years on death row in Oklahoma for crimes he didn’t commit.

Macy prosecuted Miller, and Gilchrist provided forensic testimony leading to his wrongful conviction."


Harold Levy...hlevy15@gmail.com;

Part One: "Forensic Stalker;" Smith Compared To Notorious American Forensic Specialist - Called "Latest Forensic Stalker."

"THE REPORT SAYS THAT “MISSING EVIDENCE IS OCCURRING IN MAJOR CASES.” SOME OF THOSE CASES WERE DEATH PENALTY CASES. ACCORDING TO THE REPORT, A FREEZER BREAKDOWN CONTAMINATED EVIDENCE FROM HUNDREDS OF CASES. THE REPORT ALSO SAID THAT BLOOD ANALYSIS FILES FROM THREE ENTIRE YEARS - 1980, 1981, AND 1990 - WERE MISSING, AND THAT RAPE EVIDENCE WAS SYSTEMATICALLY BEING DESTROYED AFTER ONLY TWO YEARS"

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"WILSON SAYS THAT THE ENTIRE SYSTEM IS TO BLAME FOR ALLOWING GILCHRIST TO CONTINUE WORKING. “I THINK YOU HAVE TO LOOK AT THE PROSECUTOR’S OFFICE, THAT THEY HAVE TO UNDERSTAND WHAT’S BEEN GOING ON. THEY HAVE TO HAVE SEEN ALL THE FLAGS THAT HAVE BEEN WAVED. THE JUDGES ARE NO DIFFERENT. THEY’VE SEEN THE APPELLATE COURT DECISIONS COME BACK. IT’S NOT JUST THE POLICE, IT’S NOT JUST THE PROSECUTORS, IT’S EVERYONE IN THE ENTIRE SYSTEM.”

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

"I THINK JOYCE GILCHRIST MAY HAVE FALLEN INTO AN INTERNAL FEELING THAT SHE WAS ON THE POLICE TEAM, SHE WAS ON THE PROSECUTION TEAM,” HE SAYS. “AND WHAT SCIENTISTS SHOULD ALWAYS FEEL LIKE IS THEY ARE ON THE SIDE OF SCIENCE.”

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

ALL QUOTES FROM CBS DOCUMENTARY: "UNDER THE MICROSCOPE: FORENSIC SCIENTIST ACCUSED OF MISHANDLING CASES;

-------------------------------------------------------------------------------

The growing international notoriety of Dr. Charles Smith is evident in a post on a Blog called "TalkLeft: The Politics of Crime" published out of Denver, Colorado.

The post was published on Dec. 10, TalkLeft, 2007 under the heading, "Suffer the Little Children To Come Unto Me - The Latest Forensic Stalker."

"The Latest Forensic Stalker" is the description given by the author to Dr. Charles Smith, who has admitted "errors" and "mistakes" but has consistently denied allegations made during the Goudge Inquiry that he deliberately set out to harm to any of the individuals who were affected by his flawed opinions.

The author of the post compares Dr. Smith to Joyce Gilchrist, a forensic scientist in the State Of Oklahoma, who has been implicated in death penalty cases;

"While Joyce Gilchrist of Oklahoma apparently still holds the world's record for systematically framing the largest number of people over a period of years, the Toronto Star reports today, December 10,2007, that Canada boasts a forensic expert who, in duration of his service(if not in the number of his victims) can at least equal Gilmore's achievement," the author says;

This is the same Joyce Gilchrist was the subject of a CBS: Sixty Minutes presentation on July, 24, 2002, under the heading: "Under the Microscope: Forensic Scientist Accused of Mishandling Cases;"

"DNA testing in old criminal cases is doing more than freeing dozens of innocent people from prison. It is also pointing the finger of blame at a legal system that has sometimes relied on bad science, and gotten bad results," the CBS story begins;

"That is the case in a growing legal scandal in Oklahoma City where one innocent man has been freed after 15 years in prison, triggering an investigation into the police chemist whose work put him and hundreds of other people behind bars," the story continues;

"The scientist's name is Joyce Gilchrist. Now she finds herself under the microscope and every case she worked on is in question.

For 20 years, Gilchrist examined crime scenes, looking for clues linking suspects to evidence she said she found. Often, her testimony in court meant the difference between innocence and guilt.

When 60 Minutes II first brought you this story last year, questions were just beginning to be asked. Joyce Gilchrist is the target of lawsuits and investigations, and there are concerns that she may have put people in prison with more sorcery than science.

In Oklahoma City, Gilchrist was considered so good at getting conviction that police had given her the nickname "black magic." She says it started with one particular case: “It was in reference to a homicide case where the defense attorney referred to me in his closing statements as a sorcerer - someone who conducted black magic, and stated that I seemed to be able to do things with evidence that nobody was else able to do.”

Now, she is the target of several investigations, and there are growing concerns that she may have put people in prison with more sorcery than science.

According to her critics, Gilchrist has a history of seeing things in the lab that other scientists can’t, and saying things in court that other scientists won’t.

But for nearly two decades, her work has been helping Oklahoma City police and prosecutors win convictions - whether the defendant was guilty or innocent.

Among the cases that Gilchrist handled was that of Jeff Pierce. Fifteen years ago, Gilchrist was the police chemist on his case. Pierce had been arrested for rape.

“I voluntarily gave them hairs and blood,” says Pierce. “And they said, if this comes back and it doesn’t match, you can go home. And I voluntarily gave it to them. And they came back five minutes later and said, ‘Oh, it all matches... you’re going to prison.’”

Gilchrist used her microscope to match Pierce’s hair and blood to evidence found at the crime scene and on the victim. At trial, her testimony was devastating. She told jurors that the dozens of hairs she found were microscopically “consistent” with Pierce’s, and were a means of “positive” identification.

Pierce had a clean record, alibi witnesses and character references. In the end, though, he was found guilty. But three weeks ago, a DNA test proved he did not commit the rape that put him in prison.

Gilchrist says she did the best she could in the Pierce case: “Using the technology we had at the time, I did the best job I could and I presented the facts to the court and let the jury decide what they believed.”

But there are questions about Gilchrist’s lab work in the Pierce case. A few months ago, when Pierce’s defense team requested DNA testing, chemists pulled out the 15-year-old evidence and found that Gilchrist’s testimony didn’t match the facts. The FBI was sent in to investigate Gilchrist’s work in the Pierce case, and seven other controversial cases.

The official report found that in five cases, including Pierce's, there are “errors in identification,” and that lab notes were “incomplete or inadequate” In one case, the matches Gilchrist made “fall far below the acceptable limits of the science of hair comparisons.” The FBI suggested a review of all cases where her work was significant to the outcome of the trial.

Gilchrist herself isn’t sure about the FBI tests. “Let’s submit that evidence for DNA analysis and see,” she says. “I look forward to that. And if I’m wrong, you know, I would accept responsibility if I’m wrong. But I’ve never intentionally done anything wrong in a case I’ve ever been involved in.”

In 1985, she was named the police department’s Employee of the Year. But a more recent police memo paints a far different picture, suggesting that the lab Gilchrist supervised was chaotic.

The report says that “missing evidence is occurring in major cases.” Some of those cases were death penalty cases. According to the report, a freezer breakdown contaminated evidence from hundreds of cases. The report also said that blood analysis files from three entire years - 1980, 1981, and 1990 - were missing, and that rape evidence was systematically being destroyed after only two years.

“My administrators are the ones who make the decisions about the operation of the laboratory,” says Gilchrist. “I don’t make that decision. I just carry out those orders. That’s why I can’t comment right now.”

In going over Gilchrist’s notes, chemists found she had a wildly inappropriate way of jogging her memory about cases, repeatedly referring to victims or defendants as “fags” and “faggots.”

She admits to using those terms, and says she regrets it now. “At the time though, that’s the slang that was used,” she says.

In March, Gilchrist was suspended from her job by police chief M.T. Berry. “My biggest concern is that in my life as a law enforcement officer, I would rather let a guilty man go free than send an innocent man to the penitentiary. And my biggest fear is that may have happened in this case,” Berry says.

Gilchrist was part of thousands of police investigations. She testified in hundreds of cases. She helped send 23 people to death row. Eleven have already been executed. Now all of her felony cases are under review.

Over the years, Gilchrist’s testimony has been repeatedly criticized by appellate court judges, who have described her testimony as “misleading,” “untruthful,” and “inexcusable.”

“I don’t agree with (that characterization),” Gilchrist says. “Because I’ve never lied in court. I’ve always told the truth. I’ve never lied to anyone about anything. If you don’t want to know the truth, don’t ask me because I’m not going to sugarcoat anything for you. I’m going to tell it to you. I’ll tell it to you just the way it is.”

Gilchrist has been reprimanded by one professional forensic association, and expelled from another for unethical behavior.

John Wilson, chief chemist at the Kansas City police lab, filed an ethics charge against Gilchrist 15 years ago. “I’m not the only forensic scientist who has reviewed her work and said this is bad work,” he says. “The whole criminal justice system has failed. It has absolutely failed.”

Wilson says that the entire system is to blame for allowing Gilchrist to continue working. “I think you have to look at the prosecutor’s office, that they have to understand what’s been going on. They have to have seen all the flags that have been waved. The judges are no different. They’ve seen the appellate court decisions come back. It’s not just the police, it’s not just the prosecutors, it’s everyone in the entire system.”

Gilchrist says that Wilson is a sore loser. "He has come into Oklahoma County, in district court, to testify against me on several occasions... expert witness for the defense. But the juries did not believe his testimony. And I don't think he's been back since."

Gilchrist agreed to talk to us only if we would agree to talk to her old boss Dave McBride. Ten years ago, he was Oklahoma City's police chief. Asked if he had any reason to suspect that she was not doing her job well, McBride says: "No one ever raised the issue." He says that no one mentioned to him that there was a problem with the crime lab: "Never. Not one time, not ever."

McBride believes that what has happened in Oklahoma City could happen anywhere that a forensics lab is attached to a police agency, and that is the case in most large American cities. He says it creates scientists who consider themselves cops in lab coats.

“I think there’s an inherent potential conflict there,” he says. “And I don’t know that that’s always healthy for the criminal justice system. But I certainly think that the investigators liked working with her. And I know that the district attorney loved having her as a witness.”

“I think Joyce Gilchrist may have fallen into an internal feeling that she was on the police team, she was on the prosecution team,” he says. “And what scientists should always feel like is they are on the side of science.”

After Pierce was convicted, Gilchrist received an honorary citation from the Oklahoma City police and a commendation from the district attorney, for her “skillful work in the careful analysis of the forensic evidence.”

Pierce says that he is still outraged at Gilchrist: “She’s ruined me and countless lies. They lost their kids, lost their wives, lots their families.”

When Pierce last saw his sons, they were 1 year old. He and his wife decided they didn’t want prison to be part of their children’s lives. So the boys and their mother moved out of state. They grew up without knowing their father, or even where he was. Pierce didn’t want them to know he was in prison.

Last night, Pierce was released from prison. He was asked what he wanted to say to Gilchrist. “Why? Why did you do this?” he said.

Hundreds of cases that Gilchrist handled are now under review. The worry in Oklahoma City is that Pierce isn’t the only innocent person Gilchrist helped send to prison - just one of the lucky few to get out.

July 2002 Update:

Since his release, Jeff Pierce has been getting reacquainted with his ex-wife and twin sons in Michigan. In April, he filed a $75 million federal lawsuit against the state of Oklahoma and Oklahoma City, Also named in the lawsuit is former prosecutor Bob Macy and Joyce Gilchrist.

Gilchrist was fired from her job in September. She is suing the city demanding her job back."


Bloggist's Note: Sound familiar?

Next posting: "Part Two: "Forensic Stalker:" Former Oklahoma Forensic Scientist Gilchrist Accused of Hiding Or Destroying Hairs Sought For DNA Testing;"

Harold Levy...hlevy15@gmail.com;qwq

Monday, February 25, 2008

Dr. Smith's Character: The Nasty Side: Part Two; How Low CanYou Go?

Previous postings relating to Dr.Smith's character detailed the famed pathologists attempt to intimidate an Ontario Provincial Police Officer who pulled him over for speeding not to give him a ticket - and his denigration of the work of experts who disagreed with his opinion from the witness box.

But to this Blogster nothing demonstrates Dr. Smith's nasty nature as much as the message he communicated to the Kawartha Children's Aid Society in the context of the Waudby case on May 6, 1999;

Here is some background.

Brenda Waudby had been charged with second-degree murder in connection with the death of her two and a half year-old daughter Jenna based on Dr. Smith's opinion that Waudby had exclusive access to the child at the time the fatal injuries were inflicted.

However, numerous experts consulted by both the Waudby's defence lawyer and prosecutor Brian Gilkinson - including Dr. Sigmund Ein, a staff surgeon at the Hospital for Sick Children) - concluded, to the contrary that the injuries had been inflicted on Jenna shortly before her death, while she was under the exclusive control of J.D. her teenage male babysitter.

An Overview Report on Jenna's case prepared by Goudge Inquiry staff, notes that around the time Smith spoke to the Childrens Aid Society official, Gilkinson had begun thinking, after meeting with Ein, that the murder charge should be withdrawn

(During that meeting Ein had told Gilkinson that he was ninety-nine percent certain, based on the autopsy findings, that the fatal injuries occurred after five o'clock on
the day of Jenna's death - on the babysitter's watch);

The Overview Report also indicates that at the time of what lawyer Peter Wardle referred to as the "famous" meeting with Dr. Ein, Brenda Waudby was about to have another child , and that she did, in fact, gave birth to a son, who immediately became the subject of an apprehension proceeding.

Under cross-examination by Wardle, Smith acknowledged that he was was aware that Gilkinson was considering withdrawing the murder charge when he spoke with the Children's Aid official - after the baby had been born and there had been a first court appearance on the child apprehension proceedings.

Wardle's cross-examination proceeds as follows:

MR. PETER WARDLE: So let me just read (the note on Kawartha Children's Aid letterhead H.L.) it to you, sir. It -- it says:

"Addendum to B.B. note, re. telephone call with Dr. C. Smith on May 6."

You can just see that faintly above the word "Smith".

DR. CHARLES SMITH: Yes.

"When Dr. Smith was advised that there was a possibility of [and this is Ms. Waudby's baby] returning home, he replied, 'Well, I guess I'll be doing his autopsy too'."


Let's stop here for a second.

Brenda Waudby has been charged with murder based on Dr. Smith's now suspect opinion of the time when the fatal injuries were inflicted.

It must be apparent to Dr. Smith that he may have caused a wrongful prosecution in which an innocent mother has been arrested for murdering her very own baby daughter, has been put through utter hell, and now the authorities are contemplating seizing her new-born child.

However, instead of reflecting on where he went wrong and how all this could have been avoided, he continues to characterize her as a murderer and is doing his best to convince the Children's Aid Society that Brenda's newly born son is at risk.

It gets worse.

We know now, based on evidence called at the Inquiry, at the moment he was passing on his ugly message to the Children's Aid Society, he had in his possession a dark, curly, male-type hair which he had removed from Jenna's sexual organs during the autopsy and kept untested in his personal possession.

Since he is now aware that Brenda Waudby may be innocent, surely he must have recognized that someone else must have committed the brutal crime - and that person (most likely J.D. the teenager who had exclusive access to Jenna at the time the injuries were inflicted) is still at large.

(The Overview Report indicates that J.D. ultimately was arrested, charged with murdering Jenna and sexually assaulting her, and ultimately pleaded guilty to manslaughter in connection with the brutal crime);

What was going on in Dr. Smith's mind at the time?

Did he lash out against Waudby during his conversation with the Children's Aid official, because he was a sore loser - and could not tolerate his opinion being contradicted successfully by other experts, who he undoubtedly perceived as his inferiors?

Could it have been that he continued to believe Waudby was guilty - in spite of the contrary opinions - because, as his notes filed at the Inquiry suggest, he believed Waudby, a single mother, lived a life-style which pre-disposed her to the crime?

Lawyer Wardle had some pointed questions for Smith about his conversation with the Children's Aid Society official;

MR. PETER WARDLE: Now just pausing there, sir, does that give us some sense of the inner Dr. Charles Smith and your approach to these kinds of cases?

DR. CHARLES SMITH: No. I'm -- I have no recollection of this, and I'm -- and -- and I'm embarrassed by this.

MR. PETER WARDLE: Well, would -- would it be fair to say that you're embarrassed by it, because it suggests that not only had you pre-judged the criminal charge that was before the court --

DR. CHARLES SMITH: No, I had never pre-judged the criminal charge on that case. Never.

MR. PETER WARDLE: But you were also --

DR. CHARLES SMITH: Never.

MR. PETER WARDLE: -- you were also making a sweeping characterization about what would happen to this newborn baby?

DR. CHARLES SMITH: The -- the comment is a -- is -- is one that I shouldn't have made. There are other comments in there which -- which may adequately reflect some of my concerns about -- about a child.

The comment that I made in quotes is -- is one that I shouldn't have made. But I never -- never pre-judged any -- any possible person in Jenna's death...

I always recognized that there was a range of possibilities in which the fatal injury could have occurred, and I never ruled out the possibility of an
earlier injury on pathologic grounds."


Embarrassed?

What does that mean?

To this Blogster it suggests that Dr. Smith is embarrassed that someone kept a record of his ugly remarks, that he was caught, and that it gives the public a glimpse into his dark soul.

Embarrassed?

Why couldn't he have just said: "I'm sorry Mrs. Waudby."

Harold Levy: hlevy15@gmail.com;