skip to main | skip to sidebar

the charles smith blog

Saturday, September 15, 2018

Jeffrey Havard: Mississippi: Major Development: Shaken baby syndrome case. He no longer faces the shadow of death he has faced for 16 years: The Idaho Statesman (Associated Press reporter Jeff Amy) reports a judge has overturned the death sentence - "but upheld a man's murder conviction in a case that turns on evidence of shaken baby syndrome - something now distrusted by many scientists and doctors."


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: At the very least this ruling will prevent the execution of an innocent man. However,  Jeffrey Havard was convicted on the basis of a controversial 'syndrome', which should more accurately be referred to as a theory, and has all the hallmarks of 'junk science.' On this flimsy, hollow basis, Havard has spent 16 of his 39 years on Death Row, and now faces a re-sentencing that could take away much of the rest of his life. Removing him from death row is certainly a  major step. He never should have been placed there in the first place. Indeed,  he never should should have have been convicted on the basis of the dubious, much discredited syndrome. This decision cries out for an appeal in which the scientific reliability - or lack thereof -  of the syndrome will be addressed head on.

Harold Levy: Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog;

-----------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Mark Jicka, a lawyer for Havard, said he and other attorneys are considering an appeal. "We're glad that Jeffrey is off death row, but disappointed that a new trial was not ordered," Jicka said. "We hope that one day a jury will be able to hear the evidence that proves his innocence. Prosecutors said Havard also sexually assaulted the infant. Defense attorneys said that was not true, but they were not allowed to contest the finding in the hearing."

STORY: "Death penalty overturned, guilt upheld in shaken baby case," by Associated Press reporter Jeff Amy, published by The Idaho Statesman on September 14, 2018.



GIST: "A Mississippi judge has overturned a death sentence but upheld a man's murder conviction in a case that turns on evidence of shaken baby syndrome — something now distrusted by many scientists and doctors. Adams County Circuit Judge Forrest Johnson ruled Friday that a jury should consider a new sentence for 39-year-old Jeffrey Havard, who was convicted in the 2002 death of the infant daughter of his girlfriend. In a Mississippi capital murder case, the jury's only choices would be death or life in prison without parole. The Mississippi Supreme Court ordered a hearing on Havard's case in 2015, allowing him to present evidence disputing the validity of shaken baby syndrome as a cause of death. Havard has said he accidentally dropped his girlfriend's baby, 6-month-old Chloe Madison Britt, causing her to hit her head on the toilet. Johnson wrote that there's too much other evidence of Havard's guilt to overturn his conviction, including conflicting statements he gave. In one statement, he said he didn't know who or what caused the girl's injuries, while in a second statement he told police she fell, that he dropped Britt while bathing her and then shook her. "This court can say with confidence that the petitioner's evidence is not sufficient to undermine confidence in his conviction," he wrote. Mark Jicka, a lawyer for Havard, said he and other attorneys are considering an appeal. "We're glad that Jeffrey is off death row, but disappointed that a new trial was not ordered," Jicka said. "We hope that one day a jury will be able to hear the evidence that proves his innocence. Prosecutors said Havard also sexually assaulted the infant. Defense attorneys said that was not true, but they were not allowed to contest the finding in the hearing. The sexual assault claim makes Havard eligible for the death penalty. One of the state's witnesses in the original trial was pathologist Steven Hayne, whose autopsy work and testimony has been the subject of repeated challenges across Mississippi. During a 2017 hearing, Hayne testified that he still believed Britt's death was a homicide, but he also testified that he'd now describe the death as "abusive head trauma." In 2009 the American Academy of Pediatrics advised physicians to describe certain head injuries to infants. Other experts, though, testified during the 2017 hearing that didn't believe shaking alone could cause death. In his ruling, Johnson said he still found Hayne's new testimony "credible and reasonably consistent with his trial testimony, given the evolution of the (shaken baby syndrome) science." Despite upholding the verdict, Johnson said a new jury panel should be drawn to resentence Havard, saying the new arguments might have dissuaded the original jury from sentencing Havard to death. "While the evidence presented by the petitioner is not sufficient to undermine this court's confidence in the conviction, there is a cautious disturbance in confidence of the sentence of death, even if slight." Johnson wrote. Havard remains imprisoned at Mississippi State Penitentiary at Parchman."

The story can be read at:
https://www.idahostatesman.com/news/nation-world/health-and-medicine/article218415085.html

See related Jerry Mitchell story in the Clarion Ledger: "Jeffrey Havard, now on Mississippi’s death row, insists he accidentally dropped the baby, Chloe Madison Britt, and that she hit her head on a toilet. A hearing in court on Aug. 14 will determine if Havard will receive a new trial in the 2002 crime.........Jeffrey Havard has spent nearly 16 years behind bars on Mississippi’s death row for a crime the state’s then-pathologist didn’t believe took place. On Friday, Adams County Circuit Judge Forrest A. Johnson ordered Havard off death row after questions arose regarding whether 6-month-old Chloe Madison Britt actually died of shaken baby syndrome. "While the evidence presented by the (defense) is not sufficient to undermine this Court's confidence in the conviction," Johnson wrote, "there is a cautious disturbance in confidence of the sentence, even if slight." Johnson vacated the death sentence and ordered a new sentencing hearing for Havard before a jury, which would decide between the death penalty and a life without parole. "With all due respect, we think the court got it wrong," said defense lawyer Graham Carner, who is representing Havard with Mark Jicka. "We are disappointed, but we are not done." Carner said he wants a jury to hear all of the evidence in the case "and not evidence that is unquestionably false and based on bad science. We have been fighting for Jeffrey for 10 years, and we will continue to do so." Havard has spent most of his adult life behind bars and will celebrate his 40th birthday in November. At the 2002 trial, the state’s then-pathologist Dr. Steven Hayne testified that Chloe died of shaken baby syndrome, comparing it to a motor vehicle crash or a fall from a significant height. But Hayne later backed off that conclusion, telling the Clarion Ledger there was “growing evidence” his shaken baby diagnosis was “probably not correct” because shaking alone couldn’t generate enough force to cause such injuries. After questions were raised about the case, the state Supreme Court in 2014 gave Havard permission to seek an evidentiary hearing. For decades, shaken baby syndrome was widely accepted, diagnosed through a triad of symptoms: subdural bleeding (blood collecting between the brain and the skull), retinal bleeding (bleeding in the back of the eye) and brain swelling. In the years since, medical belief that these symptoms provided ironclad proof of homicide began to crumble after a series of studies began to raise doubts. In 2009, the American Academy of Pediatrics recommended that the syndrome diagnosis be discarded and replaced with “abusive head trauma.” At the request of the Clarion Ledger, New York pathologist Dr. Michael Baden studied the autopsy report and other materials in Britt’s death. He found no support for the shaken baby conclusion, pointing to a lack of neck or chest injuries or spine or rib fractures that suggest such abusive shaking. At a hearing last year, Hayne testified that the term he would use now would be “abusive head trauma” to describe the injuries to Chloe, which he said included bruises on the forehead, scalp, back of head and mouth as well as bleeding between the skull and brain. He said he still believed her death was a homicide — and Johnson came to the same conclusion in his ruling Friday. The judge cited Havard's initial statement to authorities that he didn't know what happened to Britt. The morning after Chloe's death, Havard told authorities that he dropped the baby accidentally after getting her out of the bathtub and that she hit her head on the porcelain toilet. Hayne acknowledged that “tremendous G forces can be generated in a short fall. If it’s straight to the head, then it could cause serious injury.” Baden testified that the problem with the “abusive head trauma” conclusion is that it’s impossible to tell whether a person accidentally fell down the stairs or someone pushed that person. He said he disagreed with a prosecution expert from the 2002 trial who claimed Britt’s retinal hemorrhages proved that this baby had been shaken. “It’s my opinion that shaking had nothing to do with the death,” Baden said. “It’s my opinion that all of the injuries are consistent with blunt force impact.” The baby's injuries are consistent with the fall that Havard described, Baden said. “With short falls, you can have fatal injuries.” Last year’s hearing did not include a discussion about evidence about the alleged sexual abuse, the underlying felony, which qualified the case for the death penalty. “I didn’t think there was a sexual assault,” Hayne told the Clarion Ledger. “I didn’t see any evidence of sexual assault.” At trial, several emergency room nurses and doctors testified there was unquestionable evidence of sexual assault, saying they saw tears and rips in the child’s anus. “Maybe they were looking at folds and thought they were tears,” Hayne told the Clarion Ledger. “We were very careful, and we also took sections.” A rape kit also found no semen or foreign DNA, and he examined those sections under a microscope. He said the anal contusion he did could have been consistent with the child passing a harder stool. But jurors never heard that evidence, and they convicted Havard of capital murder. Baden said when doctors overstate the case, such as with shaken baby syndrome, “innocent people can get convicted.”"
https://www.clarionledger.com/story/news/2018/09/14/after-16-years-jeffrey-havard-off-mississippis-death-row/1296190002/

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog;
Posted by Harold Levy at Saturday, September 15, 2018
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Newer Post Older Post Home

Blog Nation Badge

Crime Blogs

Followers

The Charles smith blog

Blog Directory - Blogged

Blog Archive

  • ►  2025 (300)
    • ►  May (48)
    • ►  April (59)
    • ►  March (64)
    • ►  February (64)
    • ►  January (65)
  • ►  2024 (743)
    • ►  December (60)
    • ►  November (61)
    • ►  October (73)
    • ►  September (63)
    • ►  August (55)
    • ►  July (62)
    • ►  June (78)
    • ►  May (57)
    • ►  April (62)
    • ►  March (66)
    • ►  February (46)
    • ►  January (60)
  • ►  2023 (732)
    • ►  December (68)
    • ►  November (59)
    • ►  October (58)
    • ►  September (67)
    • ►  August (72)
    • ►  July (62)
    • ►  June (70)
    • ►  May (66)
    • ►  April (54)
    • ►  March (58)
    • ►  February (52)
    • ►  January (46)
  • ►  2022 (679)
    • ►  December (73)
    • ►  November (44)
    • ►  October (33)
    • ►  September (38)
    • ►  August (53)
    • ►  July (70)
    • ►  June (51)
    • ►  May (66)
    • ►  April (83)
    • ►  March (60)
    • ►  February (47)
    • ►  January (61)
  • ►  2021 (825)
    • ►  December (77)
    • ►  November (83)
    • ►  October (81)
    • ►  September (77)
    • ►  August (70)
    • ►  July (84)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (71)
    • ►  April (61)
    • ►  March (63)
    • ►  February (43)
    • ►  January (46)
  • ►  2020 (612)
    • ►  December (31)
    • ►  November (32)
    • ►  October (36)
    • ►  September (34)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (52)
    • ►  June (55)
    • ►  May (50)
    • ►  April (59)
    • ►  March (69)
    • ►  February (83)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ►  2019 (520)
    • ►  December (53)
    • ►  November (56)
    • ►  October (43)
    • ►  September (47)
    • ►  August (39)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (46)
    • ►  May (49)
    • ►  April (40)
    • ►  March (45)
    • ►  February (37)
    • ►  January (40)
  • ▼  2018 (561)
    • ►  December (39)
    • ►  November (44)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ▼  September (32)
      • Notice to Charles Smith Bloggians: I must take a ...
      • Michael Holick: New Yorker calls him "The Child-Ab...
      • Dangers of DNA Testing: Outstanding New York Times...
      • Deep-fake video's: Fascinating story from Radio Fr...
      • Flawed DNA evidence: Washington DC lawyer/commenta...
      • Houston Crime lab: Yet another apparent debacle: ...
      • Jeffrey Havard: Mississippi: Radley Balko: "The mu...
      • Centre of Forensic Sciences: Ontario; 'Renowned' C...
      • Mark Lundy: New Zealand: New Zealand reporter Stev...
      • Joe Bryan: Texas: Major Development: Prosecution e...
      • Motherisk: Hospital for Sick Children; Ontario: T...
      • Richard Wright: New York State; Major Set-back; He...
      • "Joyce"... Motherisk...Hospital for Sick Children ...
      • Terry Friesen; New Zealand; False confession case....
      • Jeffrey Havard: Mississippi: Major Development: Sh...
      • Technology Series; (Part 6): Will a scary new 'de...
      • Technology Series: (Part 5): Fake videos: The Cr...
      • Technology Series (Part 4): India: Massive biomet...
      • Technology Series: (Part 3): India: What happens w...
      • Radley Balko. National Registry of Exonerations. ...
      • Technology series (Part 2): Technology again - (al...
      • Technology series ( Part 1): Technology gone wild?...
      • Terry Turner: Georgia: From our 'When you think yo...
      • Forensic linguistics: Who wrote the op-ed? Associa...
      • Crime lab series: (Part 4): Scotland Yard Suspends...
      • Crime lab series: (Part 3): Medical testing giant ...
      • Crime lab series: (Part 2): Even more for our 'He...
      • Crime lab series: (Part 1): From our 'Here we go a...
      • Cameron Todd Willingham; Texas; (Part 2): Arson ...
      • Cameron Todd Willingham: Texas; (Part 1): 'Trial...
      • More from Nebraska: Jeff Boppre; State is fighting...
      • False confessions (Suppressed memories and intimid...
    • ►  August (55)
    • ►  July (53)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (60)
    • ►  April (42)
    • ►  March (44)
    • ►  February (54)
    • ►  January (62)
  • ►  2017 (621)
    • ►  December (42)
    • ►  November (39)
    • ►  October (79)
    • ►  September (48)
    • ►  August (56)
    • ►  July (39)
    • ►  June (63)
    • ►  May (47)
    • ►  April (76)
    • ►  March (65)
    • ►  February (5)
    • ►  January (62)
  • ►  2016 (1013)
    • ►  December (82)
    • ►  November (106)
    • ►  October (105)
    • ►  September (99)
    • ►  August (90)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (42)
    • ►  May (93)
    • ►  April (91)
    • ►  March (80)
    • ►  February (72)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ►  2015 (939)
    • ►  December (70)
    • ►  November (76)
    • ►  October (92)
    • ►  September (92)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (90)
    • ►  June (87)
    • ►  May (76)
    • ►  April (114)
    • ►  March (54)
    • ►  February (84)
    • ►  January (47)
  • ►  2014 (597)
    • ►  December (40)
    • ►  October (49)
    • ►  September (47)
    • ►  August (50)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (61)
    • ►  May (70)
    • ►  April (64)
    • ►  March (76)
    • ►  February (73)
    • ►  January (64)
  • ►  2013 (661)
    • ►  December (42)
    • ►  November (61)
    • ►  October (99)
    • ►  September (83)
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (33)
    • ►  June (43)
    • ►  May (61)
    • ►  April (52)
    • ►  March (46)
    • ►  February (56)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ►  2012 (619)
    • ►  December (55)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (19)
    • ►  September (58)
    • ►  August (71)
    • ►  July (73)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (34)
    • ►  April (68)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (48)
    • ►  January (50)
  • ►  2011 (830)
    • ►  December (59)
    • ►  November (58)
    • ►  October (65)
    • ►  September (86)
    • ►  August (54)
    • ►  July (78)
    • ►  June (79)
    • ►  May (68)
    • ►  April (84)
    • ►  March (86)
    • ►  February (47)
    • ►  January (66)
  • ►  2010 (764)
    • ►  December (62)
    • ►  November (8)
    • ►  October (105)
    • ►  September (63)
    • ►  August (83)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (71)
    • ►  May (65)
    • ►  April (57)
    • ►  March (87)
    • ►  February (49)
    • ►  January (31)
  • ►  2009 (465)
    • ►  December (55)
    • ►  November (28)
    • ►  September (53)
    • ►  August (49)
    • ►  July (32)
    • ►  June (34)
    • ►  May (56)
    • ►  April (34)
    • ►  March (42)
    • ►  February (43)
    • ►  January (39)
  • ►  2008 (370)
    • ►  December (47)
    • ►  November (21)
    • ►  October (49)
    • ►  September (36)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (41)
    • ►  April (54)
    • ►  March (35)
    • ►  February (33)
    • ►  January (38)
  • ►  2007 (103)
    • ►  December (20)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ►  October (31)
    • ►  September (4)

About Me

My photo
Harold Levy
Two Blogs Now: The Charles Smith Blog; The Selfless Warriors Blog: I created the Charles Smith Blog in 2007 after I retired from The Toronto Star to permit me to keep digging into the story of the flawed pathologist and the harm he had done to so many innocent parents and caregivers, and to Ontario’s criminal justice system. Since then it has taken new directions, including examinations of other flawed pathologists, flawed pathology, and flawed science and technology which has marred the quality of justice in courtrooms around the world. On International Wrongful Conviction Day in 2024, I was thrilled to have the Blog recognized by Innocence Canada, when I was presented with the, "Rubin Hurricane Carter Champion of Justice Award." The heart of the Blog is my approach to following cases which raise issues in all of these areas - especially those involving the death penalty. I have dedicated 'The Selfless Warrior Blog’ (soon to appear) to those exceptional individuals who have been ripped out of their ordinary lives by their inability to stand by in the face of a glaring miscarriage of justice. They are my ’Selfless Warriors.’ Enjoy!
View my complete profile
 

Search This Blog

https://forensicresources.org/

  • The Marshall Project
    Five Years After George Floyd’s Murder, Police Reforms Are Being Rolled Back
    1 day ago
  • Pursue Democracy
    Albowen killing the Australian energizer bunny
    1 day ago
  • Forensic Resources
    State Crime Lab Tour Offered
    2 days ago
  • CSI DDS | Forensic Science Testimony. CSI bad science issues and their contribution to wrongful convictions.
    Forensics: TX Appeals courts use wrong standards in junk science review cases. Inmate execution looms based on shaken baby myth used at trial.
    3 days ago
  • Comments on: In a Louisiana Parish, Hundreds of Cases May Be Tainted By Sheriff’s Office Misconduct
    “If You Want to Live, Don’t Drink the Water”
    3 days ago
  • Wrongful Convictions Report
    High Court orders retrial. Why?
    6 days ago
  • In the news by Karen Franklin PhD
    Adolescence, interrogated
    4 weeks ago
  • Crime & Justice Research Alliance
    Program That Aims to Reduce Cyclical, Retaliatory Gun Violence Saw Shootings Decline After Prevention Program in Lansing, MI
    1 month ago
  • Grits for Breakfast
    Grits publishes "Tulia" zine for 25th anniversary: Preorder now!
    7 months ago
  • Wrongful Conviction News
    Life after a wrongful conviction: Meet Charles Jackson
    2 years ago
  • MIP
    2022 Annual Report
    2 years ago
  • Stop Wrongful Convictions
    Truth About The Innoculations – Dr. Chetty
    3 years ago
  • Wrongly Convicted Group Website
    Could Conner Have Washed Ashore?
    4 years ago
  • Gamso - For the Defense
    Luck
    5 years ago
  • Wrongful Convictions Blog
    Ohio Chief Justice Convenes Wrongful Conviction Task Force
    5 years ago
  • Forensic Science in North Carolina
    Forensic Toxicology Online Symposium
    6 years ago
  • Little Rascals Day Care Case
    Death noted: Former publisher of Edenton paper
    6 years ago
  • Forensic Pathology Forum
    My Father Killed Himself — Advice from a Physician and Suicide Survivor.
    6 years ago
  • Innocence Project of Florida
    Exoneration Anniversary: Wilton Dedge
    6 years ago
  • The Watch
    Afternoon links: Conservatives and criminal-justice reform
    6 years ago
  • Comments for Fault Lines
    Comment on Thank You, and Farewell by Brian Cowles
    7 years ago
  • View-from-Wilmington
    A new book on forensic science and the law
    8 years ago
  • Megrahi: You are my Jury
    Sunday Times letter highlights errors in Kenny MacAskill’s book
    8 years ago
  • Justiceforaarushitalwar.com
    CBI USES ‘TYPOGRAPHICAL ERROR’ TO SAVE FACE !!
    9 years ago
  • Innocence Matters: The Innocent should not be in prison
    John Klene's Innocence Matters
    12 years ago
  • Todd Willingham was Executed, but His Story Gets a New Life | The Arson Research Project
    March 25 2013
    12 years ago
  • On SBS
    New Research Questions Classic Model of Shaken Baby Syndrome
    13 years ago
  • Welcome to the Justice 4 Simon website
  • The Crime Report – Criminal Justice News, Statistics & Resources
  • The Wrongful Conviction of Jason Payne / Home
  • Susan Neill-Fraser is Innocent | Facebook
  • The Innocence Project - Home
  • Home
  • The Exoneration Initiative
  • Simple Justice
  • Comments on: MAIN
  • Petition | Free Pam Jacobazzi | Change.org
  • Envista Forensic Engineering Services and Forensic Consultants
  • innocent.org.uk
  • The Crime Report – Criminal Justice News, Statistics & Resources
  • The Innocence Project
  • The Marshall Project
  • Inquiry into Pediatric Forensic Pathology in Ontario - Home Page
  • Jeffrey Havard
  • Medill Innocence Project
  • Home
  • AIDWYC: The Association In Defence of the Wrongly Convicted
  • The case of Hank Skinner
  • Free Rodney Lincoln - Free an innocent man from a wrongful conviction in St. Louis, Missouri
  • McElroy Law
  • NZPIP - The Home of the New Zealand Public Interest Project. Working in the interests of justice and the public good.

http://www.personal.psu.edu/dhk3/blogs/DoubleHelixLaw/

  • The Marshall Project
    Five Years After George Floyd’s Murder, Police Reforms Are Being Rolled Back
    1 day ago
  • Pursue Democracy
    Albowen killing the Australian energizer bunny
    1 day ago
  • Forensic Resources
    State Crime Lab Tour Offered
    2 days ago
  • Comments on: In a Louisiana Parish, Hundreds of Cases May Be Tainted By Sheriff’s Office Misconduct
    “If You Want to Live, Don’t Drink the Water”
    3 days ago
  • Innocence Project
    Perry Lott is Exonerated After 35 Years of Wrongful Conviction in Ada, Oklahoma
    1 year ago
  • Wrongly Convicted Group Website
    Could Conner Have Washed Ashore?
    4 years ago
  • On SBS
    New Research Questions Classic Model of Shaken Baby Syndrome
    13 years ago
  • BEtter Consulting – Legal Services
  • Free Clayton Allison