Saturday, October 31, 2026

October 31: Scott Watson: New Zealand: From our 'Defending the Indefensible?' department. Prosecutors attempting to justify flawed police 'identification' practices have have met with severe challenges from justices presiding over his appeal, which is confined to the central identification issue, as the appeal draws to a close, Radio New Zealand (RNZ) Senior reporter Ellen O'Dwyer reports, noting that: "The justices questioned Baker on Watson's lawyers' argument that police pressured Wallace to identify Watson in an interview in early January, 1998. "It was inappropriate wasn't it?" Justice Joe Williams asked. "I've never in all the trials I did read an interview like that," Williams said."



BACKGROUND: I often check out Martyn Bradbury's Blog ' The Daily Blog' - when reporting a New Zealand case, as his posts are interesting and insightful, and  he doesn't hesitate to call the proverbial ' spade' a spade - as is his recent Blog  which is called "The Scott Watson Miscarriage of Justice'  (October 22, 2026)  -Scott Watson's appeal being heard in Supreme Court) and provides excellent  background information:


"Scott Watson’s appeal being heard in Supreme Court:  Scott Watson’s defence lawyers argue police pressured and “primed” a key witness to identify Watson as the man he saw on a yacht in the early hours of New Years’ Day. The argument came as Watson’s appeal of his double-murder conviction is being heard in the Supreme Court. Watson was sentenced to life imprisonment for murdering Ben Smart and Olivia Hope in the Marlborough Sounds and has now been behind bars for 27 years.  The Blenheim friends, aged 21 and 17, were last seen stepping off a water taxi onto a stranger’s yacht in Endeavour Inlet the early hours of 1 January, 1998, after a New Year’s Eve party at Furneaux Lodge. Their bodies have never been found. Watson was found guilty of the murders in 1999 after an 11-week jury trial involving about 500 witnesses. He appealed his convictions after the trial but the application was dismissed. He made another two applications that were unsuccessful before a 2017 bid for a royal pardon was granted, with the case heard by the Court of Appeal in 2024. Watson’s appeal focuses on one key point – the photo identification process used in the original trial  The 1998 murder of Ben Smart and Olivia Hope in the Marlborough Sounds is one of NZ most notorious double homicides and one of our most questionable convictions. There have always been enormous question marks over this case and it is right for the Supreme Court to review it because this could be a cruel miscarriage of justice. For me it never sat right that boat people saw a double masted Ketch and not the single masted boat Watson had. The convenient finding of hairs belonging to Olivia used to frame Scott Watson. The use of prison narks to frame Watson and most disturbingly, the fact that Police OffIcers involved in the Scott Watson case later went on to develop interview programs for the NZ Police that were found to be incredibly unsafe and produced false confessions. There’s an election on, the economy is melting down and we have run away climate change to worry about, but if Scott Watson is not guilty, we have kept an innocent man in jail for 27 years for two murders he didn’t commit. We need to give a damn about that."


---------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Another key issue that came up in the hearing was the photo police used of Watson in Montage B. Watson had his eyes half-closed in this photograph, and his lawyers said yesterday it unfairly stood out and led to Wallace and others identifying him. Chief Justice Helen Winkelmann put to Baker that this was "quite an extraordinary photograph", and asked him whether it was acceptable for police to choose a photo that most closely matches witness descriptions. Baker replied that he thought it was acceptable, but the other photos in the montage needed to have other similar characteristics. He said it didn't have the effect of substantially leading people to choose Watson, because about half of the 53 people shown the photo in montage b chose Watson."


-----------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "Watson's Court of Appeal bid sought to overturn his convictions on the question of reliability of DNA evidence of two blonde hairs found on Watson's boat, as well as the photo montage evidence. The Supreme Court is only considering the question of whether a miscarriage of justice arose from the decision of the original trial judge to admit Wallace's photo ID evidence. Tuesday's concludes the Supreme Court appeal hearing, with the justices reserving their decision."

-----------------------------------------

STORY: 'Photos only a part of 'overwhelming' case against Scott Watson', Crown says, RNZ (Senior Reporter Ellen O'Dwyer covers Wellington issues, stories about the Capital, and its people - as well as stories on a national scale, including social issues, health and justice.)


GIST: "Crown lawyers in the Supreme Court today say a photo montage at the heart of Scott Watson's appeal is only one piece of evidence in an "overwhelming" case against him.


Watson is appealing his conviction for the murders of Ben Smart and Olivia Hope in Marlborough Sounds on New Years' Day in 1998.


His lawyers argue the evidence of water taxi driver Guy Wallace - used in the original trial - who picked out Watson in "Photo Montage B" as the man seen boarding a boat with the young pair, is inadmissible.


Crown lawyer Madeleine Laracy said the Crown always relied on a "large volume of evidence" - not just a photo montage.


"This was and is an overwhelming case."


Laracy referred to the Court of Appeal's judgment in 2024 - which rejected a previous bid by Watson to quash his convictions.


The Court of Appeal had found there were just too many factors pointing to Watson, Laracy said.


"If Mr Watson was not the man on the Naiad, then the lone man, like Mr Watson, happened to be alone, happened to have a yacht, happened to have moored his yacht out from the jetty, happened to be in the same age range, late twenties or early thirties, happened to have an appearance that was so like Mr Watson's as to mislead Mr Wallace into thinking it was the same man."


Crown lawyer Stuart Baker said Wallace's evidence did not solely rely on picking him out of a photo montage.


"This was not a case of a fleeting glance by Mr Wallace, rather Mr Wallace observed the male at the lodge for some time throughout the evening, both in the main bar and the garden bar."


Baker said Wallace gave descriptions of the "lone man", prior to going to the wharf, including who was on the naiad, where exactly they went, what was said, and a description of rafted boats in the bay, where the three people disembarked.


The justices questioned Baker on Watson's lawyers' argument that police pressured Wallace to identify Watson in an interview in early January, 1998.


"It was inappropriate wasn't it?" Justice Joe Williams asked.


"I've never in all the trials I did read an interview like that," Williams said.


Baker replied: "I accept that the officer...that the questioning was challenging, and was at a level that quite clearly wouldn't be dealt with at the present day."


Baker said Wallace didn't succumb to pressure at the time to identify Watson, and ended up identifying him due to other reliable factors.


Another key issue that came up in the hearing was the photo police used of Watson in Montage B.


Watson had his eyes half-closed in this photograph, and his lawyers said yesterday it unfairly stood out and led to Wallace and others identifying him.


Chief Justice Helen Winkelmann put to Baker that this was "quite an extraordinary photograph", and asked him whether it was acceptable for police to choose a photo that most closely matches witness descriptions.


Baker replied that he thought it was acceptable, but the other photos in the montage needed to have other similar characteristics.


He said it didn't have the effect of substantially leading people to choose Watson, because about half of the 53 people shown the photo in montage b chose Watson.


Laracy said a major point in the Crown's case at the original trial was motive.


"The motive is a long-harboured intention to kill a woman," she said, and in her address she referred to witnesses who had pointed to such comments expressed in different words and different places.


"It [That motive] is suffused throughout this Crown case, and the way it is held together, it's a very important aspect of the Crown's case for identity."


Watson's Court of Appeal bid sought to overturn his convictions on the question of reliability of DNA evidence of two blonde hairs found on Watson's boat, as well as the photo montage evidence.


The Supreme Court is only considering the question of whether a miscarriage of justice arose from the decision of the original trial judge to admit Wallace's photo ID evidence.


Tuesday's concludes the Supreme Court appeal hearing, with the justices reserving their decision.

https://www.rnz.co.nz/news/crime-and-justice/2053374/photos-only-a-part-of-overwhelming-case-against-scott-watson-crown-says

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com. Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD: (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases): "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions. They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;