Monday, November 16, 2026

November 16: Alain Vizcay Osorio: (Granted green light for lawsuit against the police); Technology: Facial recognition gone terribly wrong - landing an innocent Kentucky man in jail for two weeks - even though he was working in Nebraska when the alleged fraudulent check was presented at a Kentucky bank. As reported by The Economic Times, "Osorio alleged that (Officer) Kilmer failed to adequately investigate or verify his identity before seeking an arrest warrant. According to the lawsuit, the photographs of Osorio and the person captured in the bank's security footage showed significant differences, including their head shapes, haircuts, facial features and complexions. The court also noted that the only apparent similarities between Osorio and the person in the footage were that both were Black men with facial hair. Osorio further alleged that Kilmer misrepresented the identification process in the criminal complaint by claiming to have used investigative tools and compared photographs, while actually relying exclusively on AI facial-recognition technology. The Florence Police Department's own policy stated that facial-recognition technology was advisory and could not establish probable cause without further investigation. Osorio has brought claims under federal and Kentucky law, including false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, assault and battery."


SYNOPSIS: In a significant ruling, a US federal judge has allowed a lawsuit against Detective Ryan Kilmer to advance regarding a wrongful arrest involving Alain Vizcay Osorio. Arrested due to faulty AI facial recognition technology that erroneously identified him, Osorio's case emphasizes the vital protection the Fourth Amendment offers against improper detentions.

-------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "In his November 9 hearing, Judge Meredith said the Fourth Amendment protects individuals from unreasonable arrests and seizures by the government. The judge said a police officer cannot delegate the responsibility of assessing probable cause entirely to artificial intelligence. He also pointed to the alleged failure to disclose the exclusive reliance on AI in the application for the arrest warrant.  The judge said there was good reason to believe that the warrant might not have been issued if the detective had fully explained how he identified Osorio."

------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "To illustrate his reasoning, Meredith used a hypothetical example involving a police detective who relies on a Magic 8 Ball to identify a suspect.
"While AI facial recognition technology has rapidly developed over recent years and is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball, placing unquestioned reliance on such technology is still not much different in principle from placing unquestioned reliance on a Magic 8 Ball.  He explained that an officer could not use the output of such a device as the sole basis for obtaining an arrest warrant and then claim immunity because there was no previous court ruling specifically addressing the use of a Magic 8 Ball. No reasonable officer would think that Detective Kilmer’s allegedly exclusive reliance on AI is lawful—especially given how Osorio’s booking photo looks nothing like the suspect from the security camera footage," the judge said."

--------------------------------------------

STORY: 'Fourth Amendment doesn't allow it': AI facial recognition mistake lands Nebraska man in jail for 2 weeks; Judge allows lawsuit against Kentucky cop," published by The Economic Times, on November 11, 2026. 

GIST: A US federal judge has allowed a lawsuit against a Kentucky police detective to proceed after a man alleged that he was wrongly arrested and jailed for more than two weeks because the officer relied solely on artificial intelligence (AI) facial-recognition technology to identify him as a check-fraud suspect.

The judge also rejected Kilmer's claim to qualified immunity, which can protect government officials from personal liability in certain circumstances.

The lawsuit was filed by Alain Vizcay Osorio, who has accused Kilmer of false arrest and malicious prosecution. Prosecutors dismissed the criminal charges against Osorio in May 2025 after he provided evidence that he was working in Nebraska when the alleged fraudulent check was presented at a Kentucky bank.

What happened?As per the court documents, the case dates back to August 30, 2024, when a man identifying himself as Ernesto Ramirez attempted to cash a suspected fraudulent check at Heritage Bank in Florence, Kentucky. The man presented a Texas driver's licence, but a bank teller suspected that the document was fake and refused to cash the check.

The individual then left the bank without receiving any money. Security cameras captured the incident, including an unobstructed view of the man's face.

A few weeks later, Detective Ryan Kilmer of the Florence Police Department began investigating the suspected fraud. After discovering that the Texas driver's licence was fake, he turned to the bank's security footage to identify the suspect.

According to the court documents, Kilmer took a screenshot of the man's face and used AI facial-recognition technology to compare it with a booking photograph and a Facebook profile image.

The detective allegedly relied solely on the AI-generated identification and concluded that the images matched.

The Facebook profile belonged to an individual identified as Yony Smith Npoles Charon. For reasons that were not explained in the complaint, Kilmer concluded that the person was actually Alain Vizcay Osorio, whose photograph appeared in the booking records.

Kilmer subsequently signed a criminal complaint stating that he had used investigative tools to identify Osorio as the person captured in the bank's security footage.

The complaint was used to obtain an arrest warrant. Officers arrested Osorio in Florida on January 9, 2025.

Osorio, who lived in Nebraska, was extradited to Boone County, Kentucky, where he faced charges of criminal possession of a forged instrument in the first and second degrees.

He was arraigned on January 23 and released on bond the following day. In March 2025, he was indicted on both charges.

However, on May 7, 2025, prosecutors dismissed the indictment with prejudice after Osorio established that he was working in Nebraska when the attempted check fraud took place.


Why did Osorio sue the detective?

Osorio alleged that Kilmer failed to adequately investigate or verify his identity before seeking an arrest warrant. According to the lawsuit, the photographs of Osorio and the person captured in the bank's security footage showed significant differences, including their head shapes, haircuts, facial features and complexions.

The court also noted that the only apparent similarities between Osorio and the person in the footage were that both were Black men with facial hair.

Osorio further alleged that Kilmer misrepresented the identification process in the criminal complaint by claiming to have used investigative tools and compared photographs, while actually relying exclusively on AI facial-recognition technology.

The Florence Police Department's own policy stated that facial-recognition technology was advisory and could not establish probable cause without further investigation.

Osorio has brought claims under federal and Kentucky law, including false arrest, false imprisonment, malicious prosecution, assault and battery.

Detective Kilmer has denied wrongdoing and argued that Osorio had failed to establish that the alleged conduct violated clearly established law.

What did the judge say?

In his November 9 hearing, Judge Meredith said the Fourth Amendment protects individuals from unreasonable arrests and seizures by the government.

The judge said a police officer cannot delegate the responsibility of assessing probable cause entirely to artificial intelligence.

He also pointed to the alleged failure to disclose the exclusive reliance on AI in the application for the arrest warrant.

The judge said there was good reason to believe that the warrant might not have been issued if the detective had fully explained how he identified Osorio.

To illustrate his reasoning, Meredith used a hypothetical example involving a police detective who relies on a Magic 8 Ball to identify a suspect.

"While AI facial recognition technology has rapidly developed over recent years and is likely more reliable than a Magic 8 Ball, placing unquestioned reliance on such technology is still not much different in principle from placing unquestioned reliance on a Magic 8 Ball.

He explained that an officer could not use the output of such a device as the sole basis for obtaining an arrest warrant and then claim immunity because there was no previous court ruling specifically addressing the use of a Magic 8 Ball.

No reasonable officer would think that Detective Kilmer’s allegedly exclusive reliance on AI is lawful—especially given how Osorio’s booking photo looks nothing like the suspect from the security camera footage," the judge said.

However, Meredith clarified that the case remains at an early stage. Evidence uncovered during discovery could change the outcome, and the detective could still raise further legal arguments.

The court allowed Osorio to file a second amended complaint and denied Kilmer's motion for judgment on the pleadings.

The detective was directed to file an answer or another response within 14 days. The court also scheduled a status conference for November 19, 2026."

The entire story can be read at: 


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;