Showing posts sorted by date for query "Jesse vinaccia". Sort by relevance Show all posts
Showing posts sorted by date for query "Jesse vinaccia". Sort by relevance Show all posts

Saturday, January 3, 2026

'Rubbish science'; Australia: (Shaken Baby Syndrome and much, much more!) Wonderful article in 'The Age' by senior writer and former deputy editor and investigations editor Michael Bachelard has relevance far beyond Australia's borders, with its message that: "Our system is good. It gets it right most of the time – 90 per cent of the time, indeed probably more. But all of us should find it disturbing that, when we get it wrong, people who’ve done nothing wrong end up serving time in prison. In Maxwell’s words, that’s “chilling”. It should, as Cordner said, “sear the soul”. Surely, the least we should demand of courts is that our juries are not being fed junk."



QUOTE  OF THE DAY:  “It is simply chilling to read of the hundreds of exonerations (through subsequent DNA testing) of individuals wrongfully convicted ... on the basis of ‘junk’ science.”

Former Victorian Appeal Court judge Chris Maxwell

———————————————

QUOTE TWO OF THE DAY: "Jurist Chris Maxwell says “the scientific illiteracy of the participants in the trial” all too often gives rise to miscarriages of justice."

————————————————

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: " If all this sounds dispiriting, it gets worse. Pretty much every scientific technique you saw on CSI to identify a “perp” – bite-mark evidence, blood-spray patterns, hair microscopy, voice spectrometry, lie-detector tests – are junk science. None of these was ever widely used in Australia, but it took a systematic review of forensic science in the United States to discredit them entirely. Even fingerprint matching – which does work, and has been used in Australia since the early 1900s – is prone to user error."

——————————————————

STORY: "When rubbish science sends the innocent to jail." by Michael Bachelard, published by  The Age, on January 3, 2026. (Michael Bachelard is a senior writer and former deputy editor and investigations editor of The Age. He has worked in Canberra, Melbourne and Jakarta, has written two books and won multiple awards for journalism, including the Gold Walkley.)

GIST: "In a courtroom drama, the moment the hero lawyer stands to begin their cross-examination, the room falls silent with expectation.

Fixing their opponent with a steely gaze, they quietly set about dismembering the testimony, character and credibility of someone whose evidence just minutes earlier seemed unassailable. In a flourish, the case is turned on its head.

Actual trials, I hate to report, are less dramatic and rarely as satisfying. But the mechanism is true to life.

Cross-examination is said in legal circles to be “the greatest legal engine ever invented for the discovery of truth”. In contested cases, courts rely heavily on a barrister’s ability to test character, tease out facts and unveil falsehoods.

Ken Crispin was just such a barrister, then a director of public prosecutions, then a judge in the ACT. And as a judge, in 2001, he wrote an extraordinary, prescient judgment in a trial over shaken baby syndrome which eviscerated the prosecution evidence. The scientific “proof” of the syndrome, Crispin wrote, was based largely on anecdote, theory and unreliable confessions.

I interviewed him for a forthcoming bonus episode of my podcast, Diagnosing Murder, and our conversation turned to how difficult it was even for a whip-smart practitioner such as himself to properly cross-examine scientists.

PHOTO CAPTION: Lindy Chamberlain was convicted over the death of her baby, Azaria, on the basis of seven pieces of scientific evidence. Six of them were wrong.


As a barrister, Crispin appeared in the 1986 royal commission investigating the wrongful conviction of Lindy Chamberlain. He wrote a book about it and decades later is still outraged at the forensic chicanery involved in her prosecution. There were major errors in six out of seven pieces of scientific evidence used against her. Proving it, though, wasn’t easy.

“We subpoenaed one bundle of documents from one witness and the first page consisted of a series of statements in point form and the points consisted in part of English words and in part of symbols,” he tells me.

“It took me 12 hours with a professor of immunochemistry to work my way through the document and understand exactly what the witness was saying and what might be wrong with it.”

“[After that], in almost any case in which expert evidence was to be given, I would try to persuade my instructing solicitors to engage an independent expert who could advise me, not just the court, so that I’d know what questions to ask,” Crispin says.

“It is simply chilling to read of the hundreds of exonerations (through subsequent DNA testing) of individuals wrongfully convicted ... on the basis of ‘junk’ science.”

Former Victorian Appeal Court judge Chris Maxwell

That costs money that many defendants can’t afford. But even if they can, the challenge remains to convey that information to a judge and jury.

“Judges usually know very little about the case at all until it starts,” says Crispin. “Traditionally, they derive all of their evidence from the witnesses in the case … so if there are any problems in the evidence, the courts are almost entirely dependent upon the cross-examination of the counsel … to bring out those errors.”

How good are barristers at doing this?

“Barristers vary from pretty hopeless to absolutely brilliant, with most of them more or less in the middle, being honest tradespeople trying their best,” Crispin says.

PHOTO CAPTION: Former Supreme Court judge Ken Crispin says judges are responding to what happens in court – not to the deeper issue of whther the scientific evidence presented has no proper basis.


If all this sounds dispiriting, it gets worse. Pretty much every scientific technique you saw on CSI to identify a “perp” – bite-mark evidence, blood-spray patterns, hair microscopy, voice spectrometry, lie-detector tests – are junk science. None of these was ever widely used in Australia, but it took a systematic review of forensic science in the United States to discredit them entirely.

Even fingerprint matching – which does work, and has been used in Australia since the early 1900s – is prone to user error.

Professor Gary Edmond, the director of the program in expertise, evidence and law at the University of NSW, tells me about an experiment in which researchers asked fingerprint experts to judge whether two sets of prints matched.

But there was a catch.

The same experts had previously matched the same prints in earlier court cases. To test the consistency of these findings, the researchers dropped subtle suggestions to their experts that the prints would likely not match. The result? “Most of the fingerprint examiners in that cohort reversed their opinion,” Edmond says.

What it shows is that, even on an objective test, experts are as susceptible to the power of suggestion as the rest of us. It’s an effect that happens “at levels that you’re not aware of, and you can’t train your way out of it”, Edmond says.

Science makes experiments “double-blind” to eliminate these biases. But in courts, says Edmond, biasing information is built in – from where the defendant sits to who hires the expert. Many scientists, including police traffic reconstruction experts and forensic doctors, actually work for the state and appear exclusively for the prosecution. The expectation on them is pretty clear.

And to juries, their evidence carries great weight. They are presented as having special knowledge, and are the only witnesses permitted to offer an opinion. A cross-examiner needs to be at the top of their game to successfully challenge this expertise. Even if they do, the jury must be focused enough “to comprehend the significance of the questioning and the significance of the answers”, Edmond says.

Almost a decade ago, all this led to one of our most eminent judges, Chris Maxwell, to a revelation.

“It is simply chilling to read of the hundreds of exonerations (through subsequent DNA testing) of individuals wrongfully convicted in US courts, and imprisoned, on the basis of ‘junk’ science,” Maxwell said in a speech to a law reform conference in 2017.

The problem, he thought, was “the scientific illiteracy of the participants in the trial”. As for judges, he echoed Crispin’s point: They “tend to be insulated from, and practically incapable of, engaging with scientific knowledge and the best scientific advice”.

PHOTO CAPTION: Jurist Chris Maxwell says “the scientific illiteracy of the participants in the trial” all too often gives rise to miscarriages of justice.


Two cases prompted Maxwell’s revelation. One was R v Klamo – a shaken baby case. The expert witness in that case made it clear that the evidence presented could not establish beyond reasonable doubt that the child’s death had been caused deliberately. But the jury either misunderstood or ignored his evidence and found the man guilty anyway.

Klamo spent a year in jail until the Court of Appeal, with Maxwell writing the key judgment, set him free.

The misunderstood expert was Professor Stephen Cordner – the former long-time head of the Victorian Institute of Forensic Medicine. Cordner told the Diagnosing Murder podcast that when he read Maxwell’s judgment, “I thought, ‘Thank God. Somebody … understood what I said’.”

He added: “That is the type of involvement that sears the soul. This is such serious stuff. People go to jail … So there’s nothing quite like that to focus the attention.”

That case prompted Cordner to take a harder look at shaken baby cases. He now wants an inquiry into the scientific basis for the diagnosis because convictions rely too heavily on the views of the state’s small group of forensic doctors. And they (for largely admirable reasons) have an immovable view of what globally is highly contested science.

PHOTO CAPTION: Emiturus Professor Stephen Cordner, an expert in forensic medicine, wants a public review into shaken baby syndrome.


As for Maxwell, he was worried enough to write a new Supreme Court practice note instructing all lawyers on how to deal with expert evidence.

In June 2025, that note got a significant update. The judge behind the update was Justice Kristen Walker – who has her own experience of a major shaken baby case.

Walker was the dissenting judge in a Victorian appeal in 2021 that hammered out the scientific arguments around shaken baby syndrome. Walker thought the appellant, Jesse Vinaccia, should be released immediately because his conviction was unsound. But she was outvoted. Her two fellow judges preferred the forensic doctor’s assurances, Vinaccia stayed in prison, and a precedent was set.

Listen to Diagnosing Murder – Episode 1

Walker’s updated note on expert evidence now demands that where scientific, medical or technical evidence is led, the prosecution or defence should ensure it is “repeatable, reproducible and accurate”. Good science, in other words.

A recent judgment of the New Jersey Supreme Court, also in a baby-shaking case, found this kind of scientific proof was a “bedrock” of the legal system because “only evidence that is sufficiently reliable … may be presented to the jurors”. Their inquiry into that case found shaken baby syndrome was “conjecture”.

Australia, though – as the Australian Academy of Science has repeatedly pointed out – has no such “reliability” standard. So does the Victorian Supreme Court’s new practice note establish one?

Not really.

A defence lawyer working in the field, Holly Boylan – who had a client acquitted of child homicide in a shaken baby case last year – says the practice note, while admirable, is unenforceable.

“It’s a statement of expectations, but doesn’t dictate what happens if those expectations are not met,” Boylan says.

The blockage is a High Court case which, in 1998, said questions of the reliability of any evidence, including scientific evidence, was up to juries to decide. In practice, it means judges are rarely permitted to stop juries hearing expert evidence – even if it’s based on dodgy science.

That’s the law. And, as Boylan says, “the law trumps a rule”.

So we’re back where we began – relying on the knowledge, competence and eloquence of barristers and the intelligence and receptiveness of juries.

The entire story can be read at:

https://www.theage.com.au/national/when-rubbish-science-sends-the-innocent-to-jail-20251217-p5noht.html

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic"  section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

SEE BREAKDOWN OF  SOME OF THE ON-GOING INTERNATIONAL CASES (OUTSIDE OF THE CONTINENTAL USA) THAT I AM FOLLOWING ON THIS BLOG,  AT THE LINK BELOW:  HL:

https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/120008354894645705/4704913685758792985


———————————————


FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."

Lawyer Radha Natarajan:

Executive Director: New England Innocence Project;



FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true!


Christina Swarns: Executive Director: The Innocence Project;


---------------------------------------------------------------

Saturday, December 27, 2025

Part 2: Shaking baby Syndrome: The International Controversy: Jesse Vinaccia: Kerry Bream and Stephen Cordner weigh up the evidence and the ethics on Croakey Health Media noting that: "The international controversy has received little attention in Australian courts, faced with competing views of the Shaken Baby Syndrome, having been content to accept those held by local paediatric forensic physicians and forensic pathologists."


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Excellent discussion on the so-called shaken baby syndrome - with an Australian perspective,  published by Croakey Health media. An excerpt on 'The International  Controversy"  follows: 

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog; 

—————————————————————————————

PASSAGE OF THE DAY;  "Vinaccia's case epitomizes the difficulties that courts have faced with competing scientific evidence. The two judges who shared the majority opinion that Vinaccia's appeal must fail appeared to see their role in part as  choosing between the evidence given by three local experts and the new evidence  - not heard at the original trial -  give by three Swedish experts. The judges wrote: "Even if the evidence of the Scandinavian witnesses   represents  a respectable body of scientific opinion, which we doubt, it would do no more than stand against another respectable body of scientific opinion in the form of the evidence of…(three local expert witnesses.) As reported by Bachelard, a Swedish expert described the findings of these judges as "embarrassing."

———————————————————

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY:  "The third judge - who interestingly has a background in science - in her   minority opinion took a different view of the competing evidence. She held that if the jury had been exposed to the new (Swedish) evidence, including new evidence about a possible alternative diagnosis, their confidence in the case presented by the prosecution was likely to have been undermined to the extent that they could not have concluded guilt beyond reasonable doubt. This judge would have acquitted Jesse Vinaccia."

---------------------------------------------------------

GIST: "The international controversy has received little attention in Australian courts,  faced with  competing views of the Shaken Baby Syndrome, having been content to accept those held by local paediatric forensic physicians and forensic pathologists.This was most evident in a decision in Victoria in the case of Jesse Vinaccia, In 2016, Vinaccia was the carer for a 16-week-old baby boy whose death was attributed to violent shaking - the physical findings were those of the triad alone.

There were no bruises, abrasions or fractures, The alleged shaking was not witnessed and was denied by Vinaccia,  In 2019, he was tried, found guilty of child homicide, and sentenced to  eight and a half years imprisonment, He appealed the findings to the Victoria Court of Appeal where in 2022 the case was heard by three judges.

The judges were presented with two competing views of the :triad."  the prosecution presented the  pro- "shaking with or without impact: views if the staff of the Victorian Paediatric Forensic Medical Service with some supporting evidence  from the Victoria Institute of Forensic Medicine.

The defence called Swedish experts to contest the validity of the science behind the  conclusion of shaken baby syndrome based on the "triad" alone. Their evidence was backed by data from the above-imentionnned Swedish  review.

Viaccia's case epitomizes the difficulties that courts have faced with competing scientific evidence. The two judges who shared the majority opinion that Vinaccia's appeal must fail appeared to see their role in part as  choosing between the evidence given by three local experts and the new evidence  - not heard at the original trial -  give by three Swedish experts.

The judges wrote: "Even if the evidence of the Scandinavian witnesses   represents  a respectable body of scientific opinion, which we doubt, it would do no more than stand against another respectable body of scientific opinion in the form of the evidence of…(three local expert witnesses.)

As reported by Bachelard, a Swedish expert described the findings of these judges as "embarrassing."

The third judge - who interestingly has a background in science - in her   minority opinion took a different view of the competing evidence.

She held that if the jury had been exposed to the new (Swedish) evidence, including new evidence about a possible alternative diagnosis, their confidence in the case presented by the prosecution was likely to have been undermined to the extent that they could not have concluded guilt beyond reasonable doubt.

This judge would have acquitted Jesse Vinaccia."

The entire article - following the above introductions - is well worth the read, and can be read at:

https://www.croakey.org/weighing-up-the-evidence-and-ethics-on-shaken-baby-syndrome/


—————————————————————

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic"  section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

SEE BREAKDOWN OF  SOME OF THE ON-GOING INTERNATIONAL CASES (OUTSIDE OF THE CONTINENTAL USA) THAT I AM FOLLOWING ON THIS BLOG,  AT THE LINK BELOW:  HL:

https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/120008354894645705/4704913685758792985

———————————————————————————————

FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."

Lawyer Radha Natarajan:

Executive Director: New England Innocence Project;

—————————————————————————————————

FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true!


Christina Swarns: Executive Director: The Innocence Project;

-------------------------------------------------------------------

Monday, March 3, 2025

Question of the day: How can suspicion, fuelled by media, lead to wrongful convictions?, the subject of Peter Gill's fascinating post on Andrew L. Urban's Wrongful Conviction Report, loaded with examples from local (Australian) cases, such as Robert Xie: "The horrendous nature of the ritual slaying of the entire Lin family at North Epping led the media and public to portray the accused as a vile murderer, despite there being no evidence at all that this quiet man with no history of violence was responsible for the brutal killings. In this case, the false assumption by the media and public – that the police had got it right by arresting him – led to public condemnation of Xie, despite Xie himself doing nothing that was consistent with him being a murderer."... (Coming Soon: FRAMED – Andrew L. Urban’s book on how the legal system framed Robert Xie for the Lin family murders.)… "Public suspicion can (mis)lead courts & juries to miscarriages of justice, as contributor Peter Gill finds.":


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: A fascinating post by Peter Gill, on Andrew L. Urban's Blog 'The Wrongful Conviction's Report' explaining why the element of 'suspicion, fueled by media, is relevant to a wrongful convictions website prompted by the recent discovery  of the recent discovery of the dead bodies of Gene Hackman and his wife Betsy Arakawa. were found on Wednesday 26 February.

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

———————————————————————————————

PASSAGE ONE OF THE DAY: "People – police, the public, jury members, anyone who’s watched crime shows on TV – simply don’t seem to like innocent explanations. Their minds, fuelled by crime shows in TV and movies – expect a culprit. But accidents do happen. Falls do happen. Often. Let’s look at a few local Wrongful Convictions to see if there is any trend for media speculation to turn an accident or the like (ie an obvious explanation) into murder, fuelling a murder trial which should eventually be overturned.

—————————————————————————————————————

PASSAGE  TWO  OF THE DAY: "Keli Lane: Keli was told that anyone involved in an illegal abortion would get 2 or 3 years in jail. Not wanting that to happen, and assured by her outclassed lawyers that she would not lose her trial, she expected that, after the media frenzy of her case settled down, she’d be found not guilty. That’s why she banged her head against the wooden dock so hard that paramedics were called, when she heard the guilty verdict. Keli copped a double whammy recently – she’s now eligible for parole, but in response to the media-swamped Chris Dawson rightful conviction, the NSW government introduced a “no body, no parole” law – if Keli can’t say where the dead body is, Keli can’t get parole. Since there’s no dead body, she’s a bit stuck. The trial and appeal revealed that, like Folbigg, Keli is a good mother, but in both cases the media and the prosecution thrived on suggesting otherwise."


----------------------------------------------------


POST: "Suspicion – fuelled by media – can lead to Wrongful Convictions," by Peter Gill, published by Andrew L. Urban's Wrongful Conviction Report, on March 3, 2025.


SUB-HEADING: "Public suspicion can (mis)lead courts & juries to miscarriages of justice, as contributor Peter Gill finds."

GIST: "Sadly, the dead bodies of Gene Hackman and his wife Betsy Arakawa were found on Wednesday 26 February. The media have reported the following:

  • Betsy’s partly-decomposed body was found on the bathroom floor, with a bottle of tablets scattered beside her. A black space heater had probably fallen in the bathroom too.
  • Gene’s pacemaker stopped recording his heartbeat on 17 February.
  • Gene’s partly-mummified body was found in the Mud Room, with his cane and sunglasses fallen beside him. A Deputy said it looked like he’d had a fall. A Mud Room is a small room near the front door, for taking your shoes off etc.
  • Fatal falls are relatively common. CDC data in USA for 2021 found twice as  many fatal falls as homicides. The CDC also found more than 14 million non-fatal falls in USA in 2021 by older people. Falls are an under-reported source of injury, anguish and even death, because – unlike murder and suicide – falls are not a crime, thus no good for selling newspapers. Falls are just accidents, un-newsworthy accidents.
  • Gene was 95. Betsy was 63.
  • One of their dogs was found dead in or near a closet attached to the bathroom. Their other two dogs were fine.
  • The gas valves and pipes have been checked, and are fine.
  • Bathrooms are one of the danger areas where people have falls.
  • When panicked, falls are more likely.

The media are rife with speculation about “suspicious” circumstances. That sells newspapers. Accidents do not sell newspapers. (Ed: in most cases)

Joining the dots from the above evidence produces this sad scenario – which might well be what happened. (Ed: Or not)

On Feb 17, Betsy reached for the tablets, screaming as she slipped  and fell onto the bathroom floor. Gene heard her scream, rushed inside, but fell in the Mud Room. They were unable to help each other. Their bodies were discovered nine days later by the first person (tradesman?) to arrive at the house. One dog, without access to water or food, sadly passed away too.

So why is this relevant to a Wrongful Convictions website?

Both the media and the social media discussions on Reddit etc of Gene’s death focus heavily on suspicious circumstances – suicide or murder.

People – police, the public, jury members, anyone who’s watched crime shows on TV – simply don’t seem to like innocent explanations. Their minds, fuelled by crime shows in TV and movies – expect a culprit. But accidents do happen. Falls do happen. Often.

Let’s look at a few local Wrongful Convictions to see if there is any trend for media speculation to turn an accident or the like (ie an obvious explanation) into murder, fuelling a murder trial which should eventually be overturned.

Lindy Chamberlain 

Simple explanation – a dingo took and killed her baby. Fuelled by suspicion and innuendo in the community and in the media, a witch hunt took off, pervading the court system, until at long last concrete evidence of a dingo’s culpability emerged when a tourist fell from Uluṟu to his death among dingo lairs. Dingo attacks had been rife at Uluṟu before Azaria died, but were covered up in an attempt to create a murder case.

The reality nowadays is that all the real evidence, ignoring any misleading created evidence, is that a dingo did it.

The ring road back to the simple explanation is over.

Tim Anderson 

Prosecutor Tedeschi’s first wrongful conviction. The media frenzy about the Hilton bombing, combined with Tim’s history, made Tim a suitable patsy when political pressure required a scapegoat to be found. Add to the media frenzy that the prosecutor Tedeschi never lost a jury trial in about 30 years of prosecuting, and Anderson had no chance. When freed, Anderson spent a decade trying to get authorities to rectify the system so that subsequent wrongful convictions didn’t happen, but his complaints fell on deaf ears before finally being dropped without ever being investigated. A chance to save heaps of money was thus lost by the authorities, whose stone wall in the face of any criticism circumvented any lessons being learned from the Lindy Chamberlain and Tim Anderson cases.

Gordon Wood in Sydney

His girlfriend jumped to her death. Masses of evidence indicated a suicide jump.

The police and others accepted that it was a suicide (ref Wikipedia). A couple of years later, the girlfriend’s father, whose wife had committed suicide and daughter taken an overdose a few years earlier, lobbied for it to be murder, and, fuelled by the media, the police used suspicion and innuendo to invent an implausible murder case, which was torn to shreds by Judges Peter McClellan and Stephen Rothman on appeal. Nowadays, every piece of real evidence indicates suicide, but even nowadays public discussions of the case on social media often don’t believe that reality.

Simon Gittany in Sydney

His fiancée fell accidentally to her death from a balcony. Masses of evidence indicates an accidental fall. Simon Gittany showed the police how to find a hidden camera whose video showed Simon Gittany with his mouth over his fiancée’s mouth to stop the neighbours from hearing her yelling. The police said they would never have found that camera hidden in a wall if Simon hadn’t volunteered its location to them. Hardly the act of a guilty man. The authorities widely circulated a freeze frame from that video, which to most viewers looks like he’s strangling her, though he is not. So he became the face of domestic violence, though the domestic violence never happened in this case. With such a background, Tedeschi had little trouble winning yet another conviction, and getting Gittany out of jail is going to be tough. Oh, the chaos that can unfold after an accident.

Gable Tostee 

Just after Gittany’s fiancée fell, Tostee was charged with murder when his date fell accidentally to her death from a balcony on the Gold Coast, after massive media publicity, Tostee was found not guilty by the jury. Lucky he didn’t have Tedeschi as a prosecutor, because Tedeschi won perhaps all his jury trials in his 30 year prosecuting career. (Several were overturned on appeal or after an inquiry…)

Rob Farquharson in Victoria

Media and the public fuelled his wrongful conviction after a tragic accident. Scientist Chris Brook’s book Road to Damnation methodically shows that it’s indisputable that Farquharson is not guilty, but Farquharson remains in jail. A theme of this case and the Folbigg case is the emotions arising when children die, which can make it hard for the public, the police and the judiciary to accept that there was no guilty perpetrator  to blame. The public are primed by TV shows and movies to expect that there’s a guilty person – on TV it’s almost never an accident at the end (otherwise the TV show would soon be off air).

Henry Keogh

After his fiancée accidentally drowned in a bath, a murder case was created by Colin Manock and others, based in part on incorrect assumptions. Yet another accident turned into a murder case.

Kathy Folbigg 

The media and public painting Folbigg as the most evil woman was based on the idea that if children die, someone must be responsible, and in this case they went after the good mother. Read Quentin McDermott’s new book Meadows Law, if you want to know more.

Keli Lane

Keli was told that anyone involved in an illegal abortion would get 2 or 3 years in jail. Not wanting that to happen, and assured by her outclassed lawyers that she would not lose her trial, she expected that, after the media frenzy of her case settled down, she’d be found not guilty. That’s why she banged her head against the wooden dock so hard that paramedics were called, when she heard the guilty verdict.

Keli copped a double whammy recently – she’s now eligible for parole, but in response to the media-swamped Chris Dawson rightful conviction, the NSW government introduced a “no body, no parole” law – if Keli can’t say where the dead body is, Keli can’t get parole. Since there’s no dead body, she’s a bit stuck. The trial and appeal revealed that, like Folbigg, Keli is a good mother, but in both cases the media and the prosecution thrived on suggesting otherwise.

Lloyd Rayney 

Media and public speculation about Rayney killing his wife, based on no evidence at all, swept through Perth a decade ago. The massive misguided focus on Lloyd prevented any focus on a relatively simple evidence-based explanation of his wife’s death, an explanation which is likely to be what actually happened.

Robert Xie

The horrendous nature of the ritual slaying of the entire Lin family at North Epping led the media and public to portray the accused as a vile murderer, despite there being no evidence at all that this quiet man with no history of violence was responsible for the brutal killings. In this case, the false assumption by the media and public – that the police had got it right by arresting him – led to public condemnation of Xie, despite Xie himself doing nothing that was consistent with him being a murderer. (Coming Soon: FRAMED – Andrew L. Urban’s book on how the legal system framed Robert Xie for the Lin family murders.)

Sue Neill Fraser 

Media Frenzy at its worst. The obvious explanation was ignored –  that the woman whose DNA was on the boat and who admitted what happened would never invent such a story. Based on my research, before the trial over 90% of Tasmanians had made up their minds, so Sue stood no chance at the trial.

An obvious explanation ignored, because the legal fraternity wouldn’t admit that they erred.

The Shaken Baby Syndrome (SBS) cases, including some in Victoria

Some babies die by accident. Alas, a worldwide witch hunt which jails fathers for murder is currently rife, with some scientists supporting a controversial scientific theory that a triad of “injuries” implies Shaken Baby Syndrome. Juries have to decide between a simple explanation of accidental death or a murderous shaking. Jesse Vinaccia and Joby Rowe, both locked up in Melbourne jails, are among the dads caught up in this nightmare scenario.

A new NZ podcast about SBS called Fractured can be found via this link Reprieve for man facing execution for same diagnosis as NZ case – Newsroom.

“Paul” (see Case 6 on the right of this website)

A simple explanation (no abuse) was ignored, especially when the media got hold of the story.

Jeff Gilham

A simple explanation held sway for many years, until Jeff’s Uncle Tony lobbied to have Jeff Gilham pursued. The scientific goofs at trial were exposed dramatically at the successful appeal, where Judge Peter McClellan seemed stunned by the inadequacy of the prosecution.

Summary

Gene and Betsy’s deaths have a logical explanation that follows directly from the available evidence, but the media so far is more intent on trying to make  the deaths look suspicious, because that sells more newspapers. Various wrongful convictions and other cases in Australia confirm that the media, the police and the judiciary have a habit of trying to develop a distorted murder case rather than stick to a simple explanation of deaths."

The entire post can be read at:

https://wrongfulconvictionsreport.org/2025/03/03/suspicion-fuelled-by-media-can-lead-to-wrongful-convictions/

——————————————————————————————

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am grateful to 'Authory' a valuable service which  creates a portfolio of all of my posts since I fired  my  first post into the cybersphere  on the   Charles Smith Blog    on September 29, 2007, some 17 years ago. Today's post is number 11, 784  Yikes! Yes, this is a compulsion, but it's a healthy one ! One of the best features of 'Authory'  (which I am trying out on the Blog for the first time, is a search engine for the portfolio  which  makes it easier  for  readers to follow the many important cases, issues and developments (and occasional rants)  in the area of flawed  pathology, flawed pathologists, and whatever else might cross my mind  in jurisdictions throughout the world which are at the heart of the Blog. So, dear reader, you can access the portfolio at the following link. Just type the inquiry into the  search box  at the following link,  and hit enter.  (The search box is on the top write side of the page under 'Read more.' Why not try it out, and,  as encouraging  use of this search function  by my readers is rather new to me, any feedback on how it is working would be appreciated at: hlevy15@gmail.com. Cheers!

https://authory.com/HaroldLevy

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

————————————————————------------------------------------------


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic"  section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

SEE BREAKDOWN OF  SOME OF THE ON-GOING INTERNATIONAL CASES (OUTSIDE OF THE CONTINENTAL USA) THAT I AM FOLLOWING ON THIS BLOG,  AT THE LINK BELOW:  HL:


https://www.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/120008354894645705/4704913685758792985


———————————————————————————————


FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."

Lawyer Radha Natarajan:

Executive Director: New England Innocence Project;


—————————————————————————————————


FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true!


Christina Swarns: Executive Director: The Innocence Project;

----------------------------------------------------------------