Friday, November 20, 2026

November 20: Confession Series: (Part 1): Confession': A fascinating commentary by Rob Henderson, a writer, political commentator, and Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute who focuses on psychology, social class, social status, and culture) which rests on a most interesting premise: "A totalitarian regime that can imprison you without evidence would seem to have little need for your confession. It can confiscate your property, starve you, torture you, and execute you. Why does it also need you to admit that you deserve it?"...Question of the day: What does a brutal technique used by Stalinist interrogators to coerce suspects into falsely confess have in common with a tactic that is commonly used by American interrogators? Steven A. Drizen, Director Emeritus at Northwestern CWC/Clinical professor of law should know. He writes about police interrogations, false confessions and wrongful convictions, and recently tweeted: "American interrogators, by and large, no longer use physical torture to coerce suspects into falsely confessing. But the title of this article is a standard tactic here: "we already know you are guilty, we just need you to say so." Watch "Confession." The article he is referring to is: “We Already Know You’re Guilty. We Just Need You to Say So.” A new film about Stalinist Russia explores Communist regimes’ obsession with extracting false confessions by Author Rob Henderson, originally published by City Journal.


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: This Blog is interested in false confessions because of the disturbing number of exonerations in the USA, Canada and multiple other jurisdictions throughout the world, where, in the absence of incriminating forensic evidence the conviction is based on self-incrimination – and because of the growing body of  scientific research showing how vulnerable suspects are to widely used interrogation methods  such as  the notorious ‘Reid Technique.’ As  all too many of this Blog's post have shown, I also recognize that pressure for false confessions can take many forms, up to and including physical violence, even physical and mental torture.

Harold Levy: Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog:

————————————————-

TWEET: American interrogators, by and large, no longer use physical torture to coerce suspects into falsely confessing. But the title of this article is a standard tactic here: "we already know you are guilty, we just need you to say so." Watch "Confession" 

Steven  A. Drizin: 


Professor Emeritus Steven Drizin is an internationally recognized authority on the role played by so-called 'confessions' in obtaining wrongful convictions. HL; 
-------------------------------------------

PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "What does a regime gainwhen its victim agrees to call himself guilty? That question runs through Confession, a new Daily Wire film written by Ben Shapiro and directed by Czech filmmaker Václav Marhoul. Set in Moscow in 1938, it follows Alexei (Rob Lowe), a literature professor sent to Lubyanka Prison. His interrogator, Vladimir (James Franco), once studied under him; Alexei describes him as his “most brilliant student.” Throughout the film, you see Vladimir attempting to persuade—and then coerce—his former professor into signing a confession: that he knew his priest had engaged in “counterrevolutionary activity.”

------------------------------------------

COMMENTARY: “We Already Know You’re Guilty. We Just Need You to Say So.”
A new film about Stalinist Russia explores Communist regimes’ obsession with extracting false confessions," by Rob Henderson,  published by City Journal, on November 13, 2026.

Rob Henderson is a writer, political commentator, and Senior Fellow at the Manhattan Institute who focuses on psychology, social class, and culture.

GIST: A totalitarian regime that can imprison you without evidence would seem to have little need for your confession. It can confiscate your property, starve you, torture you, and execute you. Why does it also need you to admit that you deserve it?

That question runs through Confession, a new Daily Wire film written by Ben Shapiro and directed by Czech filmmaker Václav Marhoul. Set in Moscow in 1938, it follows Alexei (Rob Lowe), a literature professor sent to Lubyanka Prison. His interrogator, Vladimir (James Franco), once studied under him; Alexei describes him as his “most brilliant student.” Throughout the film, you see Vladimir attempting to persuade—and then coerce—his former professor into signing a confession: that he knew his priest had engaged in “counterrevolutionary activity.”

The result is a thoughtful, absorbing film that takes deep moral questions seriously. Marhoul, shooting on a 35mm camera, gives the film real texture; the grime of Lubyanka is palpable. As Alexei communicates with Vladimir and his fellow prisoners, their long exchanges and literary references give it the feel of a stage play. At its center is a troubling question: What does a regime gain when its victim agrees to call himself guilty?

That question runs through Confession, a new Daily Wire film written by Ben Shapiro and directed by Czech filmmaker Václav Marhoul. Set in Moscow in 1938, it follows Alexei (Rob Lowe), a literature professor sent to Lubyanka Prison. His interrogator, Vladimir (James Franco), once studied under him; Alexei describes him as his “most brilliant student.” Throughout the film, you see Vladimir attempting to persuade—and then coerce—his former professor into signing a confession: that he knew his priest had engaged in “counterrevolutionary activity.”

The result is a thoughtful, absorbing film that takes deep moral questions seriously. Marhoul, shooting on a 35mm camera, gives the film real texture; the grime of Lubyanka is palpable. As Alexei communicates with Vladimir and his fellow prisoners, their long exchanges and literary references give it the feel of a stage play. At its center is a troubling question: What does a regime gain when its victim agrees to call himself guilty?

Communist regimes’ obsession with extracting false confessions has always fascinated me. Red Guards in Maoist China described it as “exhaustive bombardment.” The interrogator will essentially say, in so many words, “Look, we already know you are guilty. We just need you to say so. And if you acknowledge your guilt, then this will all go much easier for you.” Eventually, the tortured individual just wants the pain to stop and acquiesces, believing that if he confesses to the imaginary crimes, he will be released or will at least receive better treatment. But once he has acknowledged his guilt, he is typically shipped to a labor camp, if not executed.

In Confession, the interrogator Vladimir treats the desired confession as a settled fact merely awaiting the professor’s agreement. An interrogation supposedly oriented toward truth-seeking begins by announcing what that truth must be.

Communist interrogation tactics anticipated a form of postmodern logic. The truth of guilt was often genuinely hard to establish. A regime could seldom prove beyond all doubt that a person was a spy or a saboteur or a “counterrevolutionary.” But once certainty is abandoned as a standard, evidence itself is dispensable. All that remains is the preferred narrative of whoever holds power. A confession becomes the only proof that matters, and extracting it is the interrogator’s duty. This is why Communist regimes pursued confessions even from the obviously innocent. The goal was not merely to establish guilt. It was to establish that truth was whatever the Party required it to be.

Watching the exchanges between the film’s characters, I kept thinking of Nien Cheng’s 1986 memoir, Life and Death in Shanghai. During China’s Cultural Revolution, Red Guards ransacked Cheng’s home. She spent more than six years in prison, where she was subjected to psychological manipulation and physical torture designed to make her confess to crimes she had not committed.

Regime officials already controlled every aspect of Cheng’s life. Yet they wanted her help in explaining why they were destroying it. An interrogator described to her the purpose of the jail where she was housed: “This is the Number One Detention House, a prison for political prisoners. This is the place where counterrevolutionaries who have committed crimes against the People’s Government are locked up and investigated.” The description assumes guilt prior to any interrogation.

Cheng detailed how the system was designed to manufacture its own supporting evidence: “While I was being pressured and urged to provide incriminating material against others, those others were at the same time being pressured and urged to provide incriminating material against me.” Each coerced accusation justified the next interrogation. This is partly why terror in such regimes grows geometrically: every confession manufactures evidence for the next wave of victims.

The Russian-British philosopher Isaiah Berlin once recounted a chilling explanation of Stalin’s methods. To mold people according to his wishes, Stalin had to strip away the habits, rules, and expectations that gave their lives stability. Accused of crimes they never committed, or of breaking laws they could not understand, people lost any sense of how to protect themselves. Innocence offered no safety. Nor did obedience. Regardless of what you did or failed to do, punishment might still await. This made the accused person into a quivering and pliable mass of “jelly,” which the regime found easier to shape at will.

In Confession, Vladimir offers intellectual defenses of this arrangement. He describes to Alexei a material system in which ordinary ideas about good and evil become luxuries. Yet Vladimir also suggests that evil is required to defeat greater evils, such as exploitation and inequality.

This is among the film’s more useful observations. Most people, regardless of the brutality of their actions, still require moral claims to justify them. They believe that their cruelty serves a sufficiently worthy end. The prospect of a better world in the future supplies a reason to ignore the suffering of the flesh-and-blood individuals in front of them.

Vladimir makes threats against Alexei’s son. This, too, was an intriguing feature of the Soviet regime. The Soviets claimed to explain human action through material conditions—denying the role of biology and genetics—yet they treated guilt as something one could genetically inherit.

The film conveys one of its deepest ideas through a small, understated detail. Alexei notices a tiny insect crawling in a corner of the interrogation room. Here is something alive in the room that is unaffected by human ideology. Cheng found similar comfort watching a spider spin a web across her prison window. It reminded her of a world beyond the reach of her jailers. She writes, “It helped me to see that God was in control. Mao Tse-tung and his Revolutionaries seemed much less menacing. I felt a renewal of hope and confidence.”

A regime can control a person’s surroundings so completely that it appears to encompass all of reality. But faith, memory, literature, and even an insect can preserve the sense that something exists beyond its authority.

Confession is an absorbing film that trusts its audience to take serious ideas seriously. The film’s characters frequently quote Dostoevsky and other literary giants as they wrestle with questions about guilt, freedom, and the soul. These exchanges suit a struggle between a professor and his former student, whose shared education gives their conflict a particular depth. A few of the other conversations Alexei has with his cellmates would have benefited from greater restraint.

Still, the film’s willingness to give important ideas room to breathe is part of its appeal. For those interested in the history of Communism, Confession is a useful starting point for exploring works such as Arthur Koestler’s Darkness at Noon, Vasily Grossman’s Life and Fate, Robert Conquest’s The Great Terror, and Cheng’s memoir."

The entire commentary can be read at:


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;

Thursday, November 19, 2026

November 19: Joshua Mounts: Ohio: Publisher's Note: Bottom line: He remains in a cruel limbo. My last post on the case - November 16 - (Link Below) was prompted by the possibility that his prosecutor's might advise the court whether they were seeking a new trial following the overturning of his felony murder conviction on a charge of felony murder in the death of his 7-month-old son J.F. - which in my view would have been utterly ludicrous given the powerful evidence of a medical (non) criminal cause of J.F's death, the resting of the entire case on 'expert' evidence, (no direct evidence linking Josh to the alleged abuse, as the court found) and the appeal court's condemnation of the outrageous tactics the prosecution used to obtain the conviction. As I understand it, that did not happen, as the session was devoted to legal issues), the case was put over to another day, and Joshua remains in a cruel limbo. I will report back to you dear readers, when new developments occur. Harold Levy. Publisher. The Charles Smith Blog.


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: "Bottom line: He remains in limbo. My last post on the case -November 16 - (Link Below) was prompted by the possibility that his prosecutor's might advise whether they were seeking a new trial following the overturning of his felony murder conviction on a charge of felony murder in the death of his 7-month-old son J.F. - which in my view would have been utterly ludicrous given the powerful evidence of a medical (non) criminal cause of J.F's death, the resting of the entire case on 'expert' evidence, (no direct evidence linking him to the alleged abuse, as the appeal court found), and the appeal court's condemnation of the outrageous tactics the prosecution used to obtain the conviction. As I understand it, that did not happen, as the session was devoted to legal issues, the case was put over to another day, and Joshua remains in a cruel limbo. I will report back to you dear readers, when new developments occur. Harold Levy. Publisher. The Charles Smith Blog. 

-------------------------------------------------

The previous post can be read at:

https://draft.blogger.com/blog/post/edit/120008354894645705/5271634434285326769

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com. Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD: (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases): "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions. They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true;

November 19: Technology: Flock Automatic Licence Plate Readers; The ACLU (American Civil Liberties Union) - Kade Crockford and Rebecca Pattichis - reports that more than 40 cities across Massachusetts have cut ties with Flock - and that on November 17, the state’s third-biggest city may join the list, as the Springfield City Council is set to discuss proposed legislation that would bar the use of Flock’s license plate reader technology..."The ACLU of Massachusetts has reviewed millions of data points from audit logs showing who has accessed Flock data from Springfield and for what reasons from January 2024 to early October 2026. These data show: Federal agencies searched Springfield’s Flock data directly. Agencies searching included Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), which is part of ICE, and U.S. Border Patrol.Police nationwide cited “immigration” or federal agencies that enforce immigration — ICE, HSI, Customs and Border Protection, Border Patrol — as their reasons for nearly 1,500 searches of Springfield’s data between January 2024 and August 2026. Police have used Flock to search for people, not just cars, in searches that have queried data from Springfield’s cameras. Springfield police officers have searched Springfield’s Flock data in connection with protests and political rallies, as have other police working for departments in other communities."


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: This story really caught my eye - especially when I read that more than 40 cities across Massachusetts have cut ties with Flock  and that the State's third-biggest city (Springfield)   was studying  proposed legislation that would bar the use of Flock’s license plate reader technology. Americans have been aware of the increasing danger of ever-expanding intrusive surveillance of their private lives.That danger was vividly described by former Vice-President Al Gore in an article which appeared in the guardian that read, in part, as follows:  "Gore has long had qualms about the expansion of the surveillance state in the digital age. He made those concerns public this year in his latest book, The Future: Six Drivers of Social Change, in which he warned: "Surveillance technologies now available – including the monitoring of virtually all digital information – have advanced to the point where much of the essential apparatus of a police state is already in place. Within hours of the Guardian's first story about the NSA, the former vice-president tweeted: "In digital era, privacy must be a priority. Is it just me, or is secret blanket surveillance obscenely outrageous? He said on Friday: "Some of us thought that it was probably going on, but what we have learned since then makes it a cause for deep concern." Yes, there have been protests against burgeoning surveillance in America before, they scarcely resemble the nationwide uproar throughout the USA generated by Flock's licence plate reader technology. I will the reasons for this  to another time. However for now, I will publicly wonder why a similar revolt - one in which town and cities are cancelling flock and similar technologies until until tough safeguards have been built into the process - in Canada, where Flock camera's appear to  be  becoming more and more visible from coast to coast, often spiting without tough the necessary  regulation and controls. So I am inviting my readers who have who have any thoughts as to what is happening with respect to Flock Technology in Canada,  should Canadians show more concern  and  what should be done about it where it is already in use in their communities without any public process, to get in touch with me by email at hlevy15@gmail.com;

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog; 
---------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE ONE OF THE DAY: "Immigration isn’t the only reason Springfield residents should be concerned about Flock and license plate readers.  The records also show that police nationwide, and in Springfield, used Flock data to look for information about people engaged in First Amendment–protected activity. Between January 2024 and early October 2026, police nationwide searched Springfield’s Flock data more than 180 times in connection with protests or political rallies.  The reasons officers gave included “suspicious protester vehicle ‘no kings,’” “protest activity,” “protest rally,” “protest intelligence” and “Trump rally POI [person of interest].” 

--------------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: "The records obtained from Springfield PD also include audits of the department’s searches of license plate reader data held by Flock’s main competitor, Motorola Solutions, through its Vigilant system. Like Flock, Vigilant offers police a nationwide database, including billions of license plate location records collected by private companies.  Unlike Flock, which says ICE is not among its direct government customers, Vigilant has contracted directly with ICE, including ERO.  That relationship shows up in Springfield’s Vigilant records: between February and October 2026, SPD officers ran eight searches that drew on license plate data shared by ICE ERO. SPD did not provide records showing how outside agencies searched its own Vigilant data."

--------------------------------------------------------

STORY: "Flock data from Springfield show why we need clear, enforceable state guardrails on license plate readers," by Kade Crockford and Rebecca Pattichis, published by ACLU Massachusetts on November 13, 2026.

More than 40 cities across Massachusetts have cut ties with Flock. On November 17, the state’s third-biggest city may join the list, as the Springfield City Council is set to discuss proposed legislation that would bar the use of Flock’s license plate reader technology.

To inform the public debate, the ACLU of Massachusetts is publishing information we received from the Springfield Police Department (SPD) in response to a September 2026 public records request.

The ACLU of Massachusetts has reviewed millions of data points from audit logs showing who has accessed Flock data from Springfield and for what reasons from January 2024 to early October 2026. 

These data show: Federal agencies searched Springfield’s Flock data directly.

 Agencies searching included Homeland Security Investigations (HSI), which is part of ICE, and U.S. Border Patrol.Police nationwide cited “immigration” or federal agencies that enforce immigration — ICE, HSI, Customs and Border Protection, Border Patrol — as their reasons for nearly 1,500 searches of Springfield’s data between January 2024 and August 2026. 

Police have used Flock to search for people, not just cars, in searches that have queried data from Springfield’s cameras.

Springfield police officers have searched Springfield’s Flock data in connection with protests and political rallies, as have other police working for departments in other communities.

Before they vote on the proposed ordinance, it’s critical that elected officials in Springfield understand how Flock data collected in Springfield has been used by the SPD and police in other parts of the country.

Nationwide data sharing opened the door to millions of searches — including for immigration and protest surveillance

For years, until early 2026, the Springfield Police Department allowed police across the United States to search data showing where and when Springfield residents and visitors drove. 

Between January 2024 and early December 2025, agencies outside of Springfield searched Springfield’s Flock data more than 9 million times, mining information collected by Springfield’s dozens of Flock cameras.

Police in Texas searched Springfield’s Flock data more than 1.8 million times. Police in Florida, where state law requires local law enforcement to take part in civil immigration enforcement, searched the records more than 600,000 times.

Most of these were nationwide lookups: single searches that ran across thousands of Flock networks at once, including Springfield’s. 

Those nationwide lookups stopped around February 2026. MassLive reported that SPD began limiting access to its data to agencies in Massachusetts and surrounding states earlier this year, and indeed, since February, most of the searches have come from New England and New York.

But that change came from settings that Springfield PD and Flock control, not from any law, and it can be reversed at any time.

Thousands of searches related to immigration enforcement

Between January 2024 and August 2026, police searched Springfield’s Flock data nearly 1,500 times for reasons citing Customs and Border Protection, Border Patrol, HSI, or “immigration.”

The most recent search explicitly naming ICE’s deportation operations was conducted on July 10, 2026, at 7:39 a.m. by an officer with the Barnstable Police Department.

 In the reason field, the officer wrote “Wanted Person (Arrest Warrant/Fugitive) – warrants/ERO.” ERO stands for Enforcement and Removal Operations, ICE’s deportation arm. ERO uses civil administrative “warrants,” signed by immigration officers rather than judges, in its deportation process. 

It wasn’t the first time that Springfield’s data had been searched to support ICE’s deportation agenda: on November 2, 2025, Barnstable police ran five searches with the reason “Ero.”

More recently, in August 2026, the Marlborough Police Department cited HSI as the reason for searching Springfield’s Flock data. HSI is part of ICE, and since January 20, 2025, HSI has been directed to devote resources to civil immigration enforcement alongside ERO. 

(Even prior to the second Trump administration, advocacy groups were raising the alarm about HSI’s involvement in deportation operations.)

Immigration-related searches of Springfield’s Flock data peaked in March 2025, with 428 searches. They continued into 2026: although searches naming immigration-related keywords declined sharply after February 2026, HSI-related searches continued through the summer.

Federal agencies searched Springfield’s data directly 


Flock’s audit logs label some accounts as federal agencies, and public records show that they routinely searched Springfield’s cameras.

For example, in 2025,A Homeland Security Investigations account ran 172 searches b etween March and May of 2025;U.S. Border Patrol accounts ran 201 searches in May and June; andThe Naval Criminal Investigative Service ran 123 searches throughout the year.

The data indicate that federal agencies are now inactive and unable to search through Springfield’s Flock database. 

However, that has not stopped local law enforcement from conducting searches in collaboration with these agencies. In 2026, there were 243 searches, mainly from New England and New York, that referenced HSI.

Meanwhile, the U.S. Postal Inspection Service—the USPS federal police force—has searched Springfield’s data more than 70,000 times since 2024, and those searches continued through early October 2026. 

This is especially alarming in light of recent reporting revealing how the USPS police force has tracked political activists, including by using Clearview AI’s facial recognition and monitoring speech on social media platforms.

Police searched Springfield’s Flock data in connection with protests

Immigration isn’t the only reason Springfield residents should be concerned about Flock and license plate readers. 

The records also show that police nationwide, and in Springfield, used Flock data to look for information about people engaged in First Amendment–protected activity.

Between January 2024 and early October 2026, police nationwide searched Springfield’s Flock data more than 180 times in connection with protests or political rallies. 

The reasons officers gave included “suspicious protester vehicle ‘no kings,’” “protest activity,” “protest rally,” “protest intelligence” and “Trump rally POI [person of interest].” 

In a single day, July 4, 2025, the Lubbock, Texas police department ran 54 searches labeled “protest [].”

Springfield police officers did it, too. On February 19, 2024, SPD Officer Haley Radisic ran six searches on two license plates. The reason Officer Radisic gave for the search: “Palestinian Protest 02-19-2024.” On October 13, 2024, Officer Olivia Malone ran two searches of one license plate, writing “protest” as the reason.

Flock captures and allows for searches of people — not just cars

Flock’s system lets officers search footage with plain-language descriptions, including descriptions of people.

On April 8, 2026, police in Providence, R.I. ran one such search that reached Springfield’s data. 

It was labeled “[people] lime green hoodie and green checkered pajama pants pushing scooter.” Police in Braintree, MA, Nashua, NH, and Norwalk, CT ran similar people-related searches between October 2025 and June 2026.

It’s not just Flock: Springfield’s use of Motorola’s Vigilant system raises the same concerns

The records obtained from Springfield PD also include audits of the department’s searches of license plate reader data held by Flock’s main competitor, Motorola Solutions, through its Vigilant system.

Like Flock, Vigilant offers police a nationwide database, including billions of license plate location records collected by private companies. 

Unlike Flock, which says ICE is not among its direct government customers, Vigilant has contracted directly with ICE, including ERO. 

That relationship shows up in Springfield’s Vigilant records: between February and October 2026, SPD officers ran eight searches that drew on license plate data shared by ICE ERO.

SPD did not provide records showing how outside agencies searched its own Vigilant data. 

City councilors and residents concerned about SPD’s license plate surveillance should request those records to learn whether SPD shares its data directly with ICE’s deportation officers.

The problem is likely much worse than the audits show


The records analyzed here confirm that police continued to search Springfield’s Flock data for immigration-related reasons well into 2026. 

They confirm police used Flock for protest monitoring. 

And they confirm Springfield police have multiple license plate surveillance programs in effect, including with a company that directly contracts with the deportation arm of ICE — significantly expanding the threat of misuse and abuse.


But even these records likely do not capture the full scale of the problem.

That’s because an officer aware of the backlash against license plate readers can conduct an immigration-related search and document it as something else, like “drugs” or “traffic infraction.” 

There is no system in place, technical or bureaucratic, to make sure officers tell the truth in the reason field when conducting a search. 

And the sheer number of searches makes effective oversight impossible.

Massachusetts residents learned this the hard way, after a series of scandals in which local police officers were accused of misusing Flock to track former romantic partners. 

In each case, officers documented their searches with innocuous-sounding reasons like “traffic,” which, according to police leadership, masked the real reasons for the searches.

Despite promises of reform and tweaks from police and Flock, this fundamental problem remains unaddressed, and with searches at this scale it is un-addressable. 

How could Flock or a police department ensure that the hundreds of thousands or even millions of searches run through the system every month are legitimate or follow policy? They can’t. There are simply too many.

But there is something we can do to address the scourge of mass surveillance targeting Massachusetts drivers today.

Springfield and other police departments in Massachusetts should stop using license plate readers until state law regulates them

SPD’s records reveal a license plate reader program that raises serious constitutional concerns for privacy and free speech. 

Left to their own devices, police allowed law enforcement nationwide, including federal agencies, to search information collected about Springfield residents, with almost no restrictions until early 2026 and no effective oversight.

In short, Springfield’s license plate reader program shows why Massachusetts urgently needs state regulations to protect residents’ fundamental privacy rights.

Thankfully, the Springfield City Council has filed legislation to block the use of Flock cameras. 

Lawmakers who seek to protect privacy and constitutional rights should be sure to block the use of all license plate readers, not just Flock’s.

Springfield should join communities across the state in prohibiting its police department from using this dragnet surveillance technology until state lawmakers put checks and balances in place statewide.

 No one should have to fear that just by driving down the street, they expose themselves and their families to warrantless government surveillance from their local department — let alone from police in other cities and states.

Privacy can’t protect itself, but you can join the ACLU’s fight to ensure police cannot use technology like Flock to violate our most cherished rights and liberties. Take action today by emailing the Springfield City Council and the Mayor’s office, then help us spread the word.

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true

Wednesday, November 18, 2026

November 18: Jeffery Epstein: Suicide or murder? Major Development: Dr. Michael Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies bias and error in death investigations, spent a year examining Mr. Epstein’s autopsy file, which was given to him by the dead man’s brother, and has reached a startling conclusion: He says that Epstein's autopsy photos show homicide, in a story sub-headed "Investigations have found most evidence in Jeffrey Epstein’s death points to suicide"..."Michael Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies homicides, got rare access to the autopsy file and disagrees."... He is seeking to publish his findings in a peer-reviewed journal, but has been rejected so far. On Monday he presented them at the Middle Temple, a London legal society, where he argued that Mr. Epstein’s injuries are most plausibly explained by homicidal strangulation. He also asserted that injuries on the body suggest there was a struggle, contrary to the medical examiner’s findings. “The pattern and distribution and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,” he said.'


PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "In one case, Dr. Freeman argued on behalf of a Black teenager charged with murder in Mississippi after a stillbirth, after tests found trace amounts of a cocaine byproduct in the baby’s blood. The umbilical cord had been wrapped around the infant’s neck, and the state had the country’s highest infant mortality rate. The charges were dropped. In 2020, Dr. Freeman co-wrote a landmark metaanalysis on excited delirium, a term often used to explain deaths in police custody. His methodology and conclusions were hotly disputed, but they propelled a widespread rejection of excited delirium as a valid diagnosis or cause of death. More recently, he consulted in the prosecution of a police officer who killed George Floyd in Minneapolis, using statistical probability to counter defense claims that drug abuse or heart disease had caused Mr. Floyd’s death. Dr. Freeman was also part of a panel of experts that identified dozens of deaths in police custody in Maryland that had been misclassified as natural or accidental."

----------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE TWO OF THE DAY: For his Epstein investigation, he teamed up with two other skeptics, Itiel Dror, a cognitive neuroscientist whose real-world experiments have repeatedly embarrassed forensic practitioners, and Anders Eriksson, a forensic pathologist who led a Swedish government review concluding that “shaken baby” prosecutions had been based on flawed reasoning. They are continuing to seek a publisher for their analysis. In the meantime, Dr. Freeman prepared his talk on Monday, which received a flurry of advance news coverage."

-----------------------------------------------------

PASSAGE THREE OF THE DAY: "When the jail employee who found the body finally spoke with investigators two years after the fact, he recalled that Mr. Epstein’s rear end had been suspended about an inch off the floor. Dr. Freeman used the employee’s description to reconstruct the hanging, creating 3-D computer models based on Mr. Epstein’s physique and the autopsy photos. He then used illustrations to argue that strangulation from behind was a better explanation for Mr. Epstein’s injuries, including what he said were fingernail marks above the ligature line, an abrasion at the base of the neck, and a deep, fresh hemorrhage in the left shoulder muscle. He faulted investigators for not testing Mr. Epstein’s fingernails for DNA."

--------------------------------------------------------

STORY: "Challenging Consensus, Scientist Says Photos Show Epstein Was Killed," by Shaila Dewan and Leo sands  published by The New York Times, on November 16,  2026. (Shaila Dewan is a New York Times Times Reporter covering criminal justice — policing, courts and prisons — across the country. Leo Sands is a correspondent for the Breaking News Hub of The New York Times based in London.)

SUB-HEADING: "Investigations have found most evidence in Jeffrey Epstein’s death points to suicide. Michael Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies homicides, got rare access to the autopsy file and disagrees."

PHOTO CAPTION: "Dr. Michael Freeman spent a year analyzing photos and other evidence around Jeffrey Epstein’s death."

GIST: "Michael Freeman says he had one thought when he first saw a photo from Jeffrey Epstein’s autopsy: “Wait a minute, that doesn’t look like a hanging mark.”

The noose had not left a smooth, consistent line on Mr. Epstein’s neck that slanted to a peak, as in a textbook hanging. Instead, the mark was deep, ragged and branched into a Y-shape on one side.

Dr. Freeman, a forensic scientist who studies bias and error in death investigations, spent a year examining Mr. Epstein’s autopsy file, which was given to him by the dead man’s brother.

He is seeking to publish his findings in a peer-reviewed journal, but has been rejected so far. On Monday he presented them at the Middle Temple, a London legal society, where he argued that Mr. Epstein’s injuries are most plausibly explained by homicidal strangulation. He also asserted that injuries on the body suggest there was a struggle, contrary to the medical examiner’s findings.

“The pattern and distribution and multitude of injuries are not explained by a suicidal hanging,” he said.

The totality of the circumstances surrounding Jeffrey Epstein’s death in a federal detention center in 2019 points overwhelmingly to suicide, and several investigations have failed to produce evidence that anyone other than Mr. Epstein had a hand in it. Dr. Freeman’s analysis, parts of which he floated in a New York Times investigation earlier this year, may rekindle long-smoldering debates about his death.

Forensic pathologists who have seen some of the autopsy photos, though not the entire set, have agreed that the mark on Mr. Epstein’s neck was atypical for a hanging. Some of those experts said the images could still be consistent with suicide, but they cautioned that the injuries alone could not tell the full story, and that a cascade of institutional failures would make it difficult to ever conclusively determine what happened.

The New York City medical examiner’s office, which performed the autopsy, said this week that it “stands by its determination” of suicide.

Much information that medical examiners would normally use to determine a cause of death was unavailable; the examiner was not permitted to inspect the cell, for example. That has left the autopsy photographs as some of the only concrete evidence.

After being asked by a journalist to look at the hanging mark, Dr. Freeman asked Jeffrey Epstein’s brother, Mark, whether he could see the complete file. As next of kin, Mark Epstein was one of the few people who had access to the autopsy. He shared the file with Dr. Freeman last November. Dr. Freeman was not paid for his analysis, they said.

Mark Epstein said in an interview last week that he had shown the materials to other experts who asked to see them — but whom he declined to name — and that the results had been inconclusive. “They were all hemming and hawing,” he said.

Shortly before Monday’s talk, Mr. Epstein posted the autopsy photos online for all to see.

Dr. Freeman said in an interview that he had no idea who might have killed Mr. Epstein, nor did he care. He was focused only on what he called oversights in the death investigation and autopsy report. “All I’m interested in is, how did this get so sideways?” he said.

Jeffrey Epstein, a wealthy financier and convicted sex offender, is far from a typical subject for Dr. Freeman. As a consultant and scholar, he has argued that medical examiners too often ignore the most plausible cause of death in favor of one that excuses deadly force by the police or reinforces racial stereotypes.

He is not a board-certified forensic pathologist, the highest credential for medical examiners in the United States, but he has doctorates in epidemiology and forensic medicine and teaches forensic medicine at two universities. Dr. Freeman, an American, is also a fellow of the Faculty of Forensic & Legal Medicine at the Royal College of Physicians in the United Kingdom and the editor of its journal.

In one case, Dr. Freeman argued on behalf of a Black teenager charged with murder in Mississippi after a stillbirth, after tests found trace amounts of a cocaine byproduct in the baby’s blood. The umbilical cord had been wrapped around the infant’s neck, and the state had the country’s highest infant mortality rate. The charges were dropped.

In 2020, Dr. Freeman co-wrote a landmark metaanalysis on excited delirium, a term often used to explain deaths in police custody. His methodology and conclusions were hotly disputed, but they propelled a widespread rejection of excited delirium as a valid diagnosis or cause of death.

More recently, he consulted in the prosecution of a police officer who killed George Floyd in Minneapolis, using statistical probability to counter defense claims that drug abuse or heart disease had caused Mr. Floyd’s death. Dr. Freeman was also part of a panel of experts that identified dozens of deaths in police custody in Maryland that had been misclassified as natural or accidental.

Forensic pathology is sometimes said to be more art than science, and disagreements among experts are common. Medical examiners point out that they must defend their opinions in court, but Dr. Freeman is among critics who have complained that there are too few safeguards against bias and error.

For his Epstein investigation, he teamed up with two other skeptics, Itiel Dror, a cognitive neuroscientist whose real-world experiments have repeatedly embarrassed forensic practitioners, and Anders Eriksson, a forensic pathologist who led a Swedish government review concluding that “shaken baby” prosecutions had been based on flawed reasoning.

They are continuing to seek a publisher for their analysis. In the meantime, Dr. Freeman prepared his talk on Monday, which received a flurry of advance news coverage.

The talk was to be held at the University College London, where reservations quickly reached capacity. But on Sunday, the school suddenly announced that it would not take place, citing “well-being implications for our students.” The talk was moved to the Middle Temple and those planning to attend were told they would have to watch it online.

In 2019, the medical examiner who performed the autopsy, Dr. Kristin Roman, faced limitations. There were no photos of Mr. Epstein hanging or with the strip of cloth around his neck. The piece of cloth sent to the medical examiner was not the one that had been used as a noose. The prison employee who found the body initially declined to speak to authorities.

Still, Dr. Roman told federal investigators that she had no doubt it was a suicide. There were no signs of a struggle and the body was “pristine,” she told them, with no bruises and no debris under the fingernails.

“This doesn’t look anything like a strangulation,” she said in a statement she gave to federal authorities.

Dr. Roman has since retired from the medical examiner’s office.

When the jail employee who found the body finally spoke with investigators two years after the fact, he recalled that Mr. Epstein’s rear end had been suspended about an inch off the floor.

Dr. Freeman used the employee’s description to reconstruct the hanging, creating 3-D computer models based on Mr. Epstein’s physique and the autopsy photos. He then used illustrations to argue that strangulation from behind was a better explanation for Mr. Epstein’s injuries, including what he said were fingernail marks above the ligature line, an abrasion at the base of the neck, and a deep, fresh hemorrhage in the left shoulder muscle.

He faulted investigators for not testing Mr. Epstein’s fingernails for DNA.

Dr. Freeman delivered the presentation in the master treasurer’s office of the legal society, with his co-authors and Mark Epstein sitting nearby. Toward the end, he showed a QR code linking to the autopsy photos.

“You will be able to see them for yourself, so that this is no longer an issue of one person makes one statement and then everybody has to believe it,” he said, adding, “This is a time for people to make up their own mind.”

Afterward, he turned to those in the room. “I tried not to sound like a kook,” he said, laughing.""

The entire story can be read at:

 https://share.google/yjBwMoKXKTVKRNKmR

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true

Tuesday, November 17, 2026

November 17: Yvonne "Missy" Woods: Colorado: Extraordinary Development in the aftermath of revelations of the former State Forensic Scientists breach of trust and her imprisonment: The American Civil Liberties Union (ACLU) alleges a years-long cover-up in the States Colorado DNA debacle and has called for Colorado Supreme Court action, as CBS News (Reporter Tori Mason) reports, noting that, "Matthew Segal, co-director of the ACLU's State Supreme Court Initiative, told CBS Colorado this should not be viewed as the misconduct of a single employee. "The evidence is that in both 2014 and 2018, fraud by Missy Woods was brought to the attention of supervisors at the CBI, and instead of discharging their obligation to do something about it and to disclose that fraud to criminal defendants, supervisors covered it up," Segal said. The ACLU argues that the failure to disclose Woods' misconduct violated defendants' constitutional rights and allowed her to continue working on criminal cases for years after concerns were first raised."


PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Investigators found Woods altered or deleted DNA data in at least 1,045 cases during her nearly three decades working for CBI. But attorneys argue the number of cases affected could be significantly higher, because some of the original forensic data is no longer available."

----------------------------------------------------

QUOTE OF THE DAY: ""It's important to remember here that it is the state that committed this misconduct," Segal said. Now, the ACLU wants the Colorado Supreme Court to shift responsibility for addressing those potentially compromised cases. Rather than requiring individual defendants to prove Woods tampered with evidence in their cases, attorneys want the state to demonstrate that misconduct did not occur. Segal said the issue is also about preserving confidence in Colorado's criminal justice system. "One way I would put it is that it takes a village to do a criminal case right, and it can take a village to taint a criminal case as well," he said. "And here, unfortunately, the second thing happened."'

----------------------------------------------------

SECOND QUOTE OF THE DAY: "In a statement to CBS Colorado, CBI Strategic Communications Director Rob Low wrote: "We continue to recognize the seriousness of Missy Woods' misconduct and the concerns it has raised about the integrity of forensic evidence. CBI has addressed these issues extensively and remains committed to ensuring the reliability of its forensic work and maintaining public trust."

STORY: "ACLU alleges years-long cover-up in Colorado DNA scandal, calls for Colorado Supreme Court action," by Reporter Tori Mason, published by CBS News, on November 10, 2026. (Tori Mason is an Emmy-award winning reporter and weekend evening anchor at CBS Colorado.)

GIST: "Missy Woods is behind bars for tampering with DNA evidence at the Colorado Bureau of Investigation. Now, the American Civil Liberties Union says her misconduct has exposed much deeper problems and is calling for accountability beyond the former analyst.

The ACLU, ACLU of Colorado and the Exoneration Project are urging the Colorado Supreme Court to hold the state accountable for what attorneys describe as a years-long cover-up that may have compromised thousands of criminal cases.

Investigators found Woods altered or deleted DNA data in at least 1,045 cases during her nearly three decades working for CBI. But attorneys argue the number of cases affected could be significantly higher, because some of the original forensic data is no longer available.

Matthew Segal, co-director of the ACLU's State Supreme Court Initiative, told CBS Colorado this should not be viewed as the misconduct of a single employee.

"The evidence is that in both 2014 and 2018, fraud by Missy Woods was brought to the attention of supervisors at the CBI, and instead of discharging their obligation to do something about it and to disclose that fraud to criminal defendants, supervisors covered it up," Segal said.

The ACLU argues that the failure to disclose Woods' misconduct violated defendants' constitutional rights and allowed her to continue working on criminal cases for years after concerns were first raised.

In a statement to CBS Colorado, CBI Strategic Communications Director Rob Low wrote:

"We continue to recognize the seriousness of Missy Woods' misconduct and the concerns it has raised about the integrity of forensic evidence. CBI has addressed these issues extensively and remains committed to ensuring the reliability of its forensic work and maintaining public trust.

We have confidence in the dedicated investigators and scientists who carry out CBI's mission every day. We respect the judicial process and believe that questions concerning individual cases are best addressed through that process."

The agency has a web page that details its response to Woods' misconduct.

According to the filing, the ACLU says the delay also resulted in the loss of crucial DNA instrument data, making it difficult or impossible to determine whether Woods manipulated evidence in additional cases.

"It's important to remember here that it is the state that committed this misconduct," Segal said.

Now, the ACLU wants the Colorado Supreme Court to shift responsibility for addressing those potentially compromised cases. Rather than requiring individual defendants to prove Woods tampered with evidence in their cases, attorneys want the state to demonstrate that misconduct did not occur.

Segal said the issue is also about preserving confidence in Colorado's criminal justice system.

"One way I would put it is that it takes a village to do a criminal case right, and it can take a village to taint a criminal case as well," he said. "And here, unfortunately, the second thing happened."

ACLU alleges years-long cover-up in Colorado DNA scandal, calls for Colorado Supreme Court action - CBS Colorado 

The entire story can be read at:


PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true

Monday, November 16, 2026

November 16: Joshua Mounts: Ohio: Having won his appeal (In April) on a conviction of felony murder in the death of his 7-month old son, he may learn on Tuesday (November 17) whether the State will send him back to court for a new trial. For reasons set out in my publisher's note below, I truly hope this will not happen. Why? In Judge Kinsley's powerful words: "The State's case rested largely on expert testimony asserting that J.F.'s skull fracture was recent, thereby supporting the inference that the fatal injury occurred while J.F. was in Mount's care. Yet there was no direct evidence linking Mounts to the alleged abuse. As a result, this was simply a battle of the experts. Whichever set of experts the jury found more credible and believable was likely to prevail."


The Ohio Court of Appeal, First District decision:  (Case Law Wire note):  Link to the full decision: 

https://caselawwire.com/ohio/state-v-mounts-court-reverses-murder-conviction-and-remands-for-new-trial-finding-ineffective-assistance-of-both-trial-and-appellate-counsel/

----------------------------------------------------


PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog:

INTRODUCTION:  Battle of the experts:  Over the years, I have run into far too many cases in which an innocent  parent is caught in what turns out to be a battle of experts in which the expert who the jury  finds most convincing determines the outcome of the case.

Justice Jennifer Kinsley's decision  for the unanimous three judge appeal panel overturning his conviction of felony murder  and his 15-years to life sentence  (November 2021) makes it abundantly clear that this is exactly what happened in Joshua's case.

In Judge Kinsley's ruling  for the court: "The State's case rested largely on expert testimony asserting that J.F.'s skull fracture was recent, thereby supporting the inference that the fatal injury occurred while J.F. was in Mount's care. Yet there was no direct evidence linking Mounts to the alleged abuse. As a result, this was simply a battle of the experts. Whichever set of experts the jury found more credible and believable was likely to prevail."

"This meant any significant error or omission by defence counsel on his presentation of J.F's medical information to the jury had the potential to tip the scales against Mounts," she continued. "And we believe they did in this case. Collectively and individually, defence counsel's mistakes allowed the jury to hear unchallenged or improper testimony while limiting the the defense's ability to prevent a complete and responsive  expert opinion."

---------------------------------------------------

Two Competing Theories:

Judge kinsley also made clear that as no eyewitness testified as to  what precisely occurred to cause J,F,'s death, "Thus the  evidence at trial largely advanced two competing theories about how he died.

Competing theory one: On the  one hand, as Judge Kinsley set out,   the State contended that J,F. suffered blunt force trauma to his head during his overnight visit to Joshua Mount's home that Mounts, as the sole caregiver during that time, must have perpetrated,

Competing theory two: per Judge Kinsley:  Joshua's lawyers argued that Mounts argued that injuries to JF's brain were long-standing and could have been attributed to previous medical trauma, including both his mother's prenatal drug use, and JF's history  of Brief Resolved Unexplained events (so-called BRUE episodes) in which J.F. would stop breathing. (Judge Kinsley: "Both sides relied heavily on expert testimony to support their competing theories. 

In short, Joshua Mounts found himself caught  in the 'battle' between experts described by Justice Kinsley , which must have appeared to him as if was in an 'arena' rather than a 'courthouse - and given rulings made about the tactics used by the prosecutor to secure a conviction, it must also have appeared that the proverbial 'deck' was stacked against him.

How did the prosecutor stack the deck against Joshua Mounts?:

A:  By telling the jury  that eight unnamed doctors - none of whom had testified - agreed with the  prosecution's theory that Joshua was guilty of murder. As Justice Kinsley ruled: "Finally, we turn  to counsel's failure  to object to the prosecutor's closing argument, In a case turning on expert credibility, the State's  suggestion that eight additional doctors - none of who testified - would have supported its theory of the case,  dramatically altered the perceived balance of expert opinion. By effectively inflating the state's expert count from three to 11, the prosecutor invited the jury  to rely on evidence not in the record, In the absence of an objection these comments could only. have influenced the  jury's assessment, further undermining confidence in the outcome." My comment: Sure, his lawyer should have protested this comment to the roof-tops. But that doesn't excuse the prosecutor from going so far over the line  - I have never seen anything quite like it - to buttress a conviction. So unfair.

--------------------------------------------------

"SHE (DR. MAKEROFF)  WAS THE ONLY EXPERT TO EQUATE BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA WITH CHILD ABUSE, CONVERTING AN OTHERWISE AMBIGUOUS MEDICAL FINDING INTO AN ASSERTION OF INTENTIONAL, RATHER THAN ACCIDENTAL HARM. AND SHE DID SO WITHOUT PRIOR DISCLOSURE, DEPRIVING THE DEFENCE OF ANY MEANINFUL OPPORTUNITY TO PREPARE, INVESTIGATE, OR REBUT THE OPINION GIVEN THAT J,F.'S MEDICAL RECORDS DID NOT CONTAIN SUCH A CONCLUSION."

B: By putting forward  a 'child abuse'  witness found by the appeal court to have given 'expert evidence,'  who had not filed an expert witness report required by law in order to help the defendant prepare for trial.  As Judge Kinsley set out in her ruling, like any other defendant in a criminal case, Joshua had the right to expect  expert witnesses called by the prosecution to provide them with written report summarizing  the expert's testimony, findings, analysis, conclusions  conclusions , or opinion and the experts qualifications, As you might expect, that didn't happen here. The prosecutor called a  witness named Dr. Kathi Makoroff who, although entitled to testify as to  her observations, went far on by delivering devastating opinion testimony - none of which was backed up by a written report, Indeed, as Judge Kinsley wrote, "These opinions went beyond describing Dr. Makoroff's observations about J.F.'s condition and the treatment she provided. Rather Dr. Makoroff formed conclusions, based on her expertise, about what happened to J.F. She therefore testified as an expert who was required to comply with Crim. R. 16 (K). (The requirement to submit a full report. HL); As Judge Kinsley points out, "She  (Dr. Makoroff) was the only expert to equate blunt force trauma with child abuse, converting an otherwise ambiguous medical finding into an assertion of intentional, rather than accidental harm. And she did so without prior disclosure, depriving the defence of any meaningful opportunity to prepare, investigate, or rebut the  opinion given that J.F.'s medical records did not contain such a conclusion."  My comment: Yes.  Josh's lawyer failed to challenge Dr. Makoroff's testimony. But it was the prosecutor,  who went way  over the line by presumably knowing her background, and yet putting her in the witness box, without giving Josh the required expert witness report which would allow him to make his defence against her devastating testimony. Oh yes. As we learn elsewhere in Judge Kinsey's decision: "Without an objection from the defence, she also opined that J.F.s injuries did not predate his overnight stay with mounts, She explains that in her expert opinion, a child would not behave normally after sustaining the type of injuries J.F. had. Very damning indeed. All for the prosecution. All without having given Joshua the benefit of the report required by law. So unfair.

C: By attacking the credibility of Dr. Andrea Weins  (one of only 50 experts board certified in both forensic pathology and neuropathology) one of Joshua Mounts  three expert witnesses, the prosecutor  weakened the defence on 'a key defence position - that J.F.'s  brain injury predated his time with Mounts.  In Judge Kinsey's words: "With respect to Dr. Wiens specifically,  the jury heard the State accuse her of misidentifying the fracture site of the recut slide - which the State implied showed no healing".  Although the trial judge suggested that any confusion arising from her report (at least she had filed one)  could be corrected by amending her report,  Joshua's lawyer rejected this approach,  the judge placed limits on Dr. Wein's testimony at the prosecution's behest,  and, as the appeal court noted, "Preventing her (Dr. Weins) from clarifying this left the jury with a misleading impression." Most unfair: My comment: This is a prime example of the 'battle'   Judge Kinsey referred to. Too bad for Joshua Mount. He was facing life in prison for murder if convicted,  caught in an adversary system, the doctor who could show the jury that he had not killed his son - who in his short life had troubled health episodes - that doctor was now under attack. All of which shows that our adversary system of criminal justice  is poorly suited when it comes to trials.  Yes,  Joshua's defence lawyer  did not handle  this difficult situation well  (the appeal was granted because of 'ineffective assistance' from both Joshua's trial and appeal counsel);   But it was the prosecutor who so sorely crippled Joshua's defence.

---------------------------------------------

Why Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated  and to grieve the death of his son - and why he should not be put to the risk of a new trial.

The appeal court decision makes clear that Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated in court, because of the cascade of prosecution  errors that piled up against him his trial, noting that: "Each deficiency - the failure to present Dr. Weins full and accurate opinion,  the admission of undisclosed and highly consequential expert testimony from Dr. Makaroff, and the failure to object to the prosecutor's improper closing argument.  occurred in a case that turned entirely on expert credibility."

"Here, the errors did not merely accumulate," Judge Kinsley continued, "They compounded one another, allowing the jury to hear misleading or undisclosed expert opinions while preventing the defence from fully presenting the only defence expert who reviewed the original histology slide."

Although his conviction has been overturned, on Tuesday (November 17) ,  Joshua, who had just turned 27 when  he was arrested in March, 2018, and is going to be 36 in January,  may learn if the prosecution is going to insist on  subjecting him to the risk and uncertainty, if not emotional torture,   of  a trial once again.  Considering the appeal courts unequivocal findings  relating to  abysmal prosecutorial misconduct,  I truly hope that this will not happen -  especially  when one considers that Joshua has been at CRC prison since his conviction, for almost 5 years - however, this doesn't  doesn't count the almost 4 years he was held on a $1 million-dollar straight bond in the Hamilton County Detention Center. (Joshua,  was arrested in March, 2018 and has remained incarcerated for a total of almost 9 years.)

Drs. Andrea Wiens, Dr. Andrew Guajardo (like Dr. Wiens, one of the 50 Neuropathologists in the United States) and Dr.   Satish Chundru, the experts who testified on  Joshua's behalf,  collectively concluded in their reports - yes, they all filed reports - that, as Judge Kinsley opines,  "As to J.F. s death,  they agreed that the blood near the fracture site they identified was not fresh and that J.F.'s skull exhibited evidence of healing, including new. bone formation, which included  that J.F.'s injuries were not recent. Dr. Wiens also testified that J.F.'s repeated  BRUE episodes created a greater likelihood  that underlying etiology  explained  his death."

Let justice prevail for Joshua.

Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.

PUBLISHER'S NOTE:  I am monitoring this case/issue/resource. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system.  Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog. FINAL WORD:  (Applicable to all of our wrongful conviction cases):  "Whenever there is a wrongful conviction, it exposes errors in our criminal legal system, and we hope that this case — and lessons from it — can prevent future injustices."Lawyer Radha Natarajan: Executive Director: New England Innocence Project; FINAL, FINAL WORD: "Since its inception, the Innocence Project has pushed the criminal legal system to confront and correct the laws and policies that cause and contribute to wrongful convictions.   They never shied away from the hard cases — the ones involving eyewitness identifications, confessions, and bite marks. Instead, in the course of presenting scientific evidence of innocence, they've exposed the unreliability of evidence that was, for centuries, deemed untouchable." So true