PUBLISHER'S NOTE: Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog:
INTRODUCTION: Battle of the experts: Over the years, I have run into far too many cases in which an innocent parent is caught in what turns out to be a battle of experts in which the expert who the jury finds most convincing determines the outcome of the case.
Justice Jennifer Kinsley's decision for the unanimous three judge appeal panel overturning his conviction of felony murder and his 15-years to life sentence (November 2021) makes it abundantly clear that this is exactly what happened in Joshua's case.
In Judge Kinsley's ruling for the court: "The State's case rested largely on expert testimony asserting that J.F.'s skull fracture was recent, thereby supporting the inference that the fatal injury occurred while J.F. was in Mount's care. Yet there was no direct evidence linking Mounts to the alleged abuse. As a result, this was simply a battle of the experts. Whichever set of experts the jury found more credible and believable was likely to prevail."
"This meant any significant error or omission by defence counsel on his presentation of J.F's medical information to the jury had the potential to tip the scales against Mounts," she continued. "And we believe they did in this case. Collectively and individually, defence counsel's mistakes allowed the jury to hear unchallenged or improper testimony while limiting the the defense's ability to prevent a complete and responsive expert opinion."
---------------------------------------------------
Two Competing Theories:
Judge kinsley also made clear that as no eyewitness testified as to what precisely occurred to cause J,F,'s death, "Thus the evidence at trial largely advanced two competing theories about how he died.
Competing theory one: On the one hand, as Judge Kinsley set out, the State contended that J,F. suffered blunt force trauma to his head during his overnight visit to Joshua Mount's home that Mounts, as the sole caregiver during that time, must have perpetrated,
Competing theory two: per Judge Kinsley: Joshua's lawyers argued that Mounts argued that injuries to JF's brain were long-standing and could have been attributed to previous medical trauma, including both his mother's prenatal drug use, and JF's history of Brief Resolved Unexplained events (so-called BRUE episodes) in which J.F. would stop breathing. (Judge Kinsley: "Both sides relied heavily on expert testimony to support their competing theories.
In short, Joshua Mounts found himself caught in the 'battle' between experts described by Justice Kinsley , which must have appeared to him as if was in an 'arena' rather than a 'courthouse - and given rulings made about the tactics used by the prosecutor to secure a conviction, it must also have appeared that the proverbial 'deck' was stacked against him.
How did the prosecutor stack the deck against Joshua Mounts?:
A: By telling the jury that eight unnamed doctors - none of whom had testified - agreed with the prosecution's theory that Joshua was guilty of murder. As Justice Kinsley ruled: "Finally, we turn to counsel's failure to object to the prosecutor's closing argument, In a case turning on expert credibility, the State's suggestion that eight additional doctors - none of who testified - would have supported its theory of the case, dramatically altered the perceived balance of expert opinion. By effectively inflating the state's expert count from three to 11, the prosecutor invited the jury to rely on evidence not in the record, In the absence of an objection these comments could only. have influenced the jury's assessment, further undermining confidence in the outcome." My comment: Sure, his lawyer should have protested this comment to the roof-tops. But that doesn't excuse the prosecutor from going so far over the line - I have never seen anything quite like it - to buttress a conviction. So unfair.
--------------------------------------------------
"SHE (DR. MAKEROFF) WAS THE ONLY EXPERT TO EQUATE BLUNT FORCE TRAUMA WITH CHILD ABUSE, CONVERTING AN OTHERWISE AMBIGUOUS MEDICAL FINDING INTO AN ASSERTION OF INTENTIONAL, RATHER THAN ACCIDENTAL HARM. AND SHE DID SO WITHOUT PRIOR DISCLOSURE, DEPRIVING THE DEFENCE OF ANY MEANINFUL OPPORTUNITY TO PREPARE, INVESTIGATE, OR REBUT THE OPINION GIVEN THAT J,F.'S MEDICAL RECORDS DID NOT CONTAIN SUCH A CONCLUSION."
B: By putting forward a 'child abuse' witness found by the appeal court to have given 'expert evidence,' who had not filed an expert witness report required by law in order to help the defendant prepare for trial. As Judge Kinsley set out in her ruling, like any other defendant in a criminal case, Joshua had the right to expect expert witnesses called by the prosecution to provide them with written report summarizing the expert's testimony, findings, analysis, conclusions conclusions , or opinion and the experts qualifications, As you might expect, that didn't happen here. The prosecutor called a witness named Dr. Kathi Makoroff who, although entitled to testify as to her observations, went far on by delivering devastating opinion testimony - none of which was backed up by a written report, Indeed, as Judge Kinsley wrote, "These opinions went beyond describing Dr. Makoroff's observations about J.F.'s condition and the treatment she provided. Rather Dr. Makoroff formed conclusions, based on her expertise, about what happened to J.F. She therefore testified as an expert who was required to comply with Crim. R. 16 (K). (The requirement to submit a full report. HL); As Judge Kinsley points out, "She (Dr. Makoroff) was the only expert to equate blunt force trauma with child abuse, converting an otherwise ambiguous medical finding into an assertion of intentional, rather than accidental harm. And she did so without prior disclosure, depriving the defence of any meaningful opportunity to prepare, investigate, or rebut the opinion given that J.F.'s medical records did not contain such a conclusion." My comment: Yes. Josh's lawyer failed to challenge Dr. Makoroff's testimony. But it was the prosecutor, who went way over the line by presumably knowing her background, and yet putting her in the witness box, without giving Josh the required expert witness report which would allow him to make his defence against her devastating testimony. Oh yes. As we learn elsewhere in Judge Kinsey's decision: "Without an objection from the defence, she also opined that J.F.s injuries did not predate his overnight stay with mounts, She explains that in her expert opinion, a child would not behave normally after sustaining the type of injuries J.F. had. Very damning indeed. All for the prosecution. All without having given Joshua the benefit of the report required by law. So unfair.
C: By attacking the credibility of Dr. Andrea Weins (one of only 50 experts board certified in both forensic pathology and neuropathology) one of Joshua Mounts three expert witnesses, the prosecutor weakened the defence on 'a key defence position - that J.F.'s brain injury predated his time with Mounts. In Judge Kinsey's words: "With respect to Dr. Wiens specifically, the jury heard the State accuse her of misidentifying the fracture site of the recut slide - which the State implied showed no healing". Although the trial judge suggested that any confusion arising from her report (at least she had filed one) could be corrected by amending her report, Joshua's lawyer rejected this approach, the judge placed limits on Dr. Wein's testimony at the prosecution's behest, and, as the appeal court noted, "Preventing her (Dr. Weins) from clarifying this left the jury with a misleading impression." Most unfair: My comment: This is a prime example of the 'battle' Judge Kinsey referred to. Too bad for Joshua Mount. He was facing life in prison for murder if convicted, caught in an adversary system, the doctor who could show the jury that he had not killed his son - who in his short life had troubled health episodes - that doctor was now under attack. All of which shows that our adversary system of criminal justice is poorly suited when it comes to trials. Yes, Joshua's defence lawyer did not hand this difficult situation well (the appeal was granted because of 'ineffective assistance' from both Joshua's trial and appeal counsel); But it was the prosecutor who so sorely crippled Joshua's defence.
---------------------------------------------
Why Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated and to grieve the death of his son - and why he should not be put to the risk of a new trial.
The appeal court decision makes clear that Joshua Mounts scarcely had a chance to be vindicated in court, because of the cascade of prosecution errors that piled up against him his trial, noting that: "Each deficiency - the failure to present Dr. Weins full and accurate opinion, the admission of undisclosed and highly consequential expert testimony from Dr. Makaroff, and the failure to object to the prosecutor's improper closing argument. occurred in a case that turned entirely on expert credibility."
"Here, the errors did not merely accumulate," Judge Kinsley continued, "They compounded one another, allowing the jury to hear misleading or undisclosed expert opinions while preventing the defence from fully presenting the only defence expert who reviewed the original histology slide."
Although his conviction has been overturned, on Tuesday (November 17) , Joshua, who had just turned 27 when he was arrested in March, 2018, and is going to be 36 in January, may learn if the prosecution is going to insist on subjecting him to the risk and uncertainty, if not emotional torture, of a trial once again. Considering the appeal courts unequivocal findings relating to abysmal prosecutorial misconduct, I truly hope that this will not happen - especially when one considers that Joshua has been at CRC prison since his conviction, for almost 5 years - however, this doesn't doesn't count the almost 4 years he was held on a $1 million-dollar straight bond in the Hamilton County Detention Center. (Joshua, was arrested in March, 2018 and has remained incarcerated for a total of almost 9 years.)
Drs. Andrea Wiens, Dr. Andrew Guajardo (like Dr. Wiens, one of the 50 Neuropathologists in the United States) and Dr. Satish Chundru, the experts who testified on Joshua's behalf, collectively concluded in their reports - yes, they all filed reports - that, as Judge Kinsley opines, "As to J.F. s death, they agreed that the blood near the fracture site they identified was not fresh and that J.F.'s skull exhibited evidence of healing, including new. bone formation, which included that J.F.'s injuries were not recent. Dr. Wiens also testified that J.F.'s repeated BRUE episodes created a greater likelihood that underlying etiology explained his death."
Let justice prevail for Joshua.
Harold Levy: Publisher: The Charles Smith Blog.