STORY: "Investigators comb lake for new evidence in Swearingen death row case," by reporter Keri Blakinger, published by The Houston Chronicle on November 2, 2017.
GIST: "Nearly 20 years after the murder of college student Melissa
Trotter rocked Montgomery County, dive teams are out searching for more
evidence in the county's only death row case. The renewed search efforts come weeks after word of an abandoned
confession plot between Larry Swearingen - who was convicted in
Trotter's slaying - and Houston serial killer Anthony Shore threatened
to cloud the case and pointed to the possibility of more evidence. "We're trying to be thorough and check off all the boxes," said
Montgomery County District Attorney Brett Ligon. "We don't anticipate
finding anything 20 years later." Search efforts led by Montgomery County Precinct 1 Constable Philip
Cash, at Ligon's request, kicked off on Monday at an undisclosed
location. So far, investigators did not indicate finding any new
evidence but the hunt was still ongoing Thursday morning. "We were hopeful something could be found but we weren't really expecting anything," Ligon said. After years of slow-burning appeals and quiet courtroom wrangling,
Swearingen's case rocketed back into the limelight last month after a
flurry of unexpected developments. First, the confession plot with
Shore. Then, a filing snafu and a cancelled execution. Next, a DNA
testing agreement and a lake-bottom search. Through it all, Trotter's family has yearned for justice. "I'm frustrated," said Sandy Trotter, the slain teen's mother. "But I am convinced this is all in God's timing." On the day of Melissa Trotter's appearance in December 1998, she and
Swearingen were spotted together in Montgomery College library.
Afterward, a biology teacher saw the 19-year-old leaving the school with
a man. Hair and fiber evidence later showed that she'd been in Swearingen's car and home the day she vanished. The killer's wife testified that she came home that evening to find
the place in disarray - and in the middle of it all were Trotter's
lighter and cigarettes. That afternoon, Swearingen placed a call routed
through a cell tower near FM 1097 in Willis - a spot he would have
passed while heading from his house to the Sam Houston National Forest
where Trotter's decomposing body was found 25 days later. Swearingen was convicted and sentenced to death in 2000, but since
then has repeatedly evaded the state's harshest punishment through a
series of dogged appeals, many focusing on efforts to insure DNA
testing. Both he and Shore had execution dates set for this fall, but judges
called them off not long after news emerged of the pair's alleged
confession scheme. Hours before he was scheduled to die on Oct. 18, Shore won a 90-day
stay after prosecutors said the four-time killer admitted to an
abandoned plan to confess to Swearingen's crime. Over the years, Swearingen has consistently professed his innocence.
Shore, on the other hand, has consistently admitted to the 1992 killing
of Maria del Carmen Estrada - for which he was convicted - as well as
the gruesome strangulations of 14-year-old Laurie Tremblay, 9-year-old
Diana Rebollar and 16-year-old Dana Sanchez. Officials first found out about the possibility of a last-minute
confession attempt back in July, when a death row cell search uncovered
materials relating to Trotter's killing - including a hand-drawn map
marking the supposed location of more evidence - stashed in Shore's
cell. The day before his scheduled execution, Shore told investigators he'd
only considered confessing to get his friend off, and not because he'd
actually committed the additional crime. The multiple murderer also
agreed to answer questions about other cases, and a judge greenlit
pushing back his first scheduled execution date. At the time, Swearingen also had a death date on the calendar - for
Nov. 16 - but that has since been called off as the result of a filing
error after the Montgomery County District Clerk sent notice of the
execution to the wrong office. And while prosecutors in Harris County reset an execution date for
Shore, Montgomery County prosecutors have not filed for a new date in
the Swearingen case. Instead, they've agreed to more DNA testing in a
final effort to clear the water in the two-decade-old case."