PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Mumma also requested a forensic analysis of two cellphones found in Yarmolenko’s car the day of her death. Records of voicemails and phone calls to and from at least one of the phones were obtained by Mount Holly Police, but complete phone data was not, according to court documents. Neither phone was forensically analyzed."
STORY: "Mark Carver to appear in court Tuesday," by reporter Adam Lawson, published by The Gazette on April 1, 2019.
GIST: "A Gaston County man serving a life sentence for the killing of
a UNC Charlotte student more than a decade ago returns to court Tuesday
in the latest effort to win a new trial. An attorney representing
Mark Carver hopes to convince a judge that evidence not presented at
his 2011 trial warrants a new look in a case that has garnered national
attention over questions of whether a jury convicted the wrong person in
the 2008 death of 20-year-old Ira Yarmolenko. The defense in
Carver’s appeal suffered a setback when a more accurate type of DNA
testing of material scraped from Yarmolenko’s fingernails that could’ve
“isolate(d) the male contributor” of the samples failed to yield any
results, according to the North Carolina Center on Actual Innocence. Chris Mumma, executive director of the group, requested the sampling in February. “Unfortunately,
between the amount of evidence that was used up in 2008 testing and
degradation, the lab was unable to obtain any DNA results,” the
organization posted on Facebook. “Steps like this are necessary steps
for us to be able to take in our efforts to bring innocent people home
as quickly as possible. Although it will take longer, we look forward to
proving Mark’s innocence at his hearing the first two weeks of April.” Mumma
also requested a forensic analysis of two cellphones found in
Yarmolenko’s car the day of her death. Records of voicemails and phone
calls to and from at least one of the phones were obtained by Mount
Holly Police, but complete phone data was not, according to court
documents. Neither phone was forensically analyzed. Carver, 50, has spent more than eight years in prison while maintaining his innocence. District
Attorney Locke Bell continues to say Carver received a fair trial and
the jury rendered the right decision. The hearing that begins Tuesday
will center on whether Carver received adequate representation by his
defense attorneys, Brent Ratchford and David Phillips, who is now a
Superior Court judge. “This is whether his attorneys gave him a good trial or not,” Bell
said. “It’s not guilt or innocence. So if she were to win, it does not
mean he didn’t do it, it would simply mean they didn’t do their jobs. My
position is they did their jobs.” The Center on Actual Innocence subpoenaed Phillips and Ratchford, two
Mount Holly police officers and Bill Stetzer, an original prosecutor in
the case now working as an assistant in the U.S. Attorney’s Office in
Charlotte. Also listed was Gaston County Police Crime Scene
Investigator Jim Workman, who Mumma alleged touched Yarmolenko’s car
with his bare hands in the same spot Carver’s DNA was found. The
state listed as a potential witness Carver’s former psychologist, Dr.
Vikram Shukla, according to court documents. Mumma has asked the court
to restrict the doctor’s questioning to Carver’s limitations related to
carpal tunnel and radial tunnel syndromes, low IQ and difficulty
understanding complex processes and carrying out a daily living routine. She wants any medical records submitted by Shukla to be entered under seal. “Mr.
Carver’s mental health history was not part of the state’s case or
theory at trial and is irrelevant... to the claims before the court at
the evidentiary hearing,” the motion said. The state has requested that all witnesses in the case be sequestered. Yarmolenko was found by two jet skiers halfway submerged in water
along the banks of the Catawba River in Mount Holly on May 5, 2008. The
young woman had a draw string from a hoodie, a bungee cord and a ribbon
wrapped around her neck. Carver and his cousin, Neal Cassada, were
fishing at the time of the discovery, and questioned by police that
day. They were charged seven months later with first-degree murder in
Yarmolenko’s death. Cassada died from a heart attack on the eve of his
trial, but like Carver, he maintained his innocence throughout the case."
https://www.gastongazette.com/news/20190401/mark-carver-to-appear-in-court-tuesday
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/