BREAKING NEWS: Anthony Ray Hinton, who spent nearly 30 years on Alabama's death row,
will be freed Friday morning after prosecutors told a judge they won't
re-try him for the 1985 slayings of two fast-food managers after new
testing couldn't match crime scene bullets to a gun found in Hinton's
house. Chief Deputy Jefferson County District Attorney John Bowers and
Assistant District Attorney Mike Anderton filed a motion late Wednesday
afternoon to drop the prosecution of Hinton on the capital murder
charges. The charges are being dropped after "three experts found that they
could not conclusively determine that any of the six bullets" were fired
from a gun found in Hinton's home, the motion states. Jefferson County Circuit Court Judge Laura Petro on Thursday morning
issued an order dismissing the case. She also ordered the Alabama
Department of Corrections to forward paperwork to the Jefferson County
Jail, where Hinton has been awaiting his re-trial, so he can be released
at 9:30 a.m. Friday. ......... The conviction was based largely on the prosecution's gun experts and
the eyewitness testimony of a surviving restaurant manager in a July
26, 1985 shooting and robbery of a Bessemer Quincy's night manager.
But EJI argues in
its motion for dismissal that Hinton had a "powerful alibi" for that
night, with co-workers confirming he was at work 15 miles away at the
time. Hinton was not tried for the Quincy's shooting. Hinton last year was granted a re-trial in the case after
the U.S. Supreme Court found that Hinton's attorney could have hired a
better ballistics expert for
his first trial. His appellate attorneys with the Equal Justice
Initiative in Montgomery have argued that testing in 1994 by nationally
recognized gun experts showed the gun was not the one that fired the
fatal bullets.
At first prosecutors couldn't find the gun and crime scene bullets, but after they were located in a box in a storage facility prosecutors sent them to be re-tested.........(Motion to dismiss); On March 11 two bullets recovered from the bodies of Davidson and
Vason, and the two bullets collected during the investigation of the
robbery of Smotherman were resubmitted to the Alabama Department of
Forensic Sciences for additional microscopic comparison analysis to each
other and to the Smith & Wesson .38 caliber revolver recovered from
Hinton's home, according to the prosecution's motion to drop the
charges. "Three highly-qualified and experienced ADFS forensic scientists, who
are experts in the field of firearms and tool mark identification, each
performed independent forensic examinations of the submitted bullets
and firearm," the motion states. "Utilizing comparison microscopy, each
expert inter-compared all six bullets recovered during the
investigations of the three crimes to each other and to bullets test
fired through the barrel of the firearm taken from (Hinton's) home." "Due to insufficient corresponding individual microscopic
characteristics, all three experts found that they could not
conclusively determine that any of the six bullets were or were not
fired through the same firearm or that they were fired through the
firearm recovered from (Hinton's home)," the motion states. "The only potential evidence that has ever been available to the
State to prove that the Defendant committed the murders of John Davidson
and Thomas Wayne Vason depends upon an absolute, conclusive
determination that the bullets recovered from their bodies were in fact
fired through the barrel of the firearm taken from the (Hinton's) home,"
the motion states. "Based on the microscopic comparisons and
conclusions of all three of the ADFS firearms and tool mark
identification experts, the State does not have sufficient evidence to
warrant further prosecution of these cases."
Updated at 11:30 a.m. April 2 with judge's order dismissing case and ordering Hinton's release.
http://www.al.com/news/birmingham/index.ssf/2015/04/former_alabama_death_row_inmat.html