skip to main | skip to sidebar

the charles smith blog

Tuesday, May 7, 2019

Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted: Global News Series: Part 4: (Reporters Pippa Reid and Niki Reitmayer)..."Defence lawyer James Lockyer says an appeal can be achieved on the basis of three merits: that the verdict was unreasonable, there was an error of law, or there was a miscarriage of justice. Lockyer, who took part in the exoneration of a number of Canadians, including Milgaard and Robert Baltovich, points out that proving any one of those arguments is difficult. The first hurdle, he says, is convincing an appeals court to review a decision by a trial court. “It’s a very difficult, time consuming and expensive process that very rarely meets with success,” Lockyer said. The Court of Appeal, he says, has the power to make two decisions: to dismiss the appeal, or allow an appeal and quash the conviction."


PASSAGE OF THE DAY: "Exactly a year to the day after Miller’s body was found, Milgaard was convicted of her murder and sentenced to life behind bars, while her real killer — a man named Larry Fisher, who was not yet known to police — continued to walk free. Less than a year after he was put behind bars, Milgaard launched an appeal with the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal, which, on Jan. 5, 1971, was dismissed. Eleven months later, he sought an application for leave to appeal that decision with the Supreme Court of Canada, but the motion was struck down. In 1980, things were bleak. He escaped from the multi-security Stony Mountain Institution in Winnipeg for 77 days, before being shot and recaptured by the RCMP. It wasn’t until 1991 that the Crown’s case against Milgaard started to unravel. The federal minister for justice at the time, Kim Campbell, referred his case to the Supreme Court of Canada for review, in light of fresh evidence that was brought forward. It emerged that DNA discovered on Gail Miller’s body belonged to Larry Fisher, who had been in and out of prison for similar crimes against women since 1969. The public pressure started to build, and in 1992, the Court of Appeal found Milgaard’s conviction should be thrown out on the basis of that new DNA evidence. A new trial was ordered, and in April 1992, Milgaard was released from prison, but it would be another five years before he could truly clear his name."

STORY: "Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted: How does one achieve justice?" by reporters Pippa Reid and Niki Reitmayer, published by Global News on May 7, 2019. (Part four of a five-part series from the Jon McComb Show on 980 CKNW, examining wrongful convictions and why they happen.)

GIST: It was early in 1969.David Milgaard was a teenager when he and his two friends set out on a road trip from Regina to Vancouver, but they’d only make it to Saskatoon. That’s where Milgaard’s more than two-decade long nightmare began, accused of a murder he didn’t commit. But how, after almost a quarter-century behind bars, did Milgaard’s quest for justice begin? And how did he finally clear his name?Milgaard was 16 when police found Gail Miller’s body partly covered in snow in a Saskatoon laneway on January 31, 1969.  An inquiry conducted by the Saskatchewan government into Milgaard’s wrongful conviction found he suffered a miscarriage of justice with investigators being affected by ‘tunnel vision’ — a phenomenon where police zero in on a suspect to the exclusion of all others. Exactly a year to the day after Miller’s body was found, Milgaard was convicted of her murder and sentenced to life behind bars, while her real killer — a man named Larry Fisher, who was not yet known to police — continued to walk free. Less than a year after he was put behind bars, Milgaard launched an appeal with the Saskatchewan Court of Appeal, which, on Jan. 5, 1971, was dismissed. Eleven months later, he sought an application for leave to appeal that decision with the Supreme Court of Canada, but the motion was struck down. In 1980, things were bleak. He escaped from the multi-security Stony Mountain Institution in Winnipeg for 77 days, before being shot and recaptured by the RCMP. It wasn’t until 1991 that the Crown’s case against Milgaard started to unravel. The federal minister for justice at the time, Kim Campbell, referred his case to the Supreme Court of Canada for review, in light of fresh evidence that was brought forward. It emerged that DNA discovered on Gail Miller’s body belonged to Larry Fisher, who had been in and out of prison for similar crimes against women since 1969. The public pressure started to build, and in 1992, the Court of Appeal found Milgaard’s conviction should be thrown out on the basis of that new DNA evidence. A new trial was ordered, and in April 1992, Milgaard was released from prison, but it would be another five years before he could truly clear his name. Defence lawyer James Lockyer says an appeal can be achieved on the basis of three merits: that the verdict was unreasonable, there was an error of law, or there was a miscarriage of justice. Lockyer, who took part in the exoneration of a number of Canadians, including Milgaard and Robert Baltovich, points out that proving any one of those arguments is difficult. The first hurdle, he says, is convincing an appeals court to review a decision by a trial court. “It’s a very difficult, time consuming and expensive process that very rarely meets with success,” Lockyer said.  The Court of Appeal, he says, has the power to make two decisions: to dismiss the appeal, or allow an appeal and quash the conviction. Wally Oppal has sat on both the B.C Supreme Court and the B.C Court of Appeal. He says it’s not an easy task to get an appeal court to reverse the finding of a lower court and enter an acquittal. It’s more common, he says, for an appeal court to send the case back to a trial court for retrial. In 1997, Milgaard was officially exonerated after the Department of Justice ruled the results of the DNA testing conducted by a lab in the UK, showed semen found on Gail Miller could not have originated from Milgaard, and that it matched Larry Fisher. Those DNA results then prompted the Saskatchewan minister of justice to declare a ‘wrong of the most serious kind’ was done to Milgaard. He received an apology, and in 1999 was awarded $10 million by the Government of Saskatchewan in a compensation settlement. Kathryn Campbell is an associate professor at the University of Ottawa — and the director of the Innocence Ottawa project. She says if all appeals in a case are exhausted, it can then be examined by a review board, but new evidence must be presented. “If you’re sitting in a jail cell, how are you even going to get all of that new information? It’s difficult to get a case referred to a minister, and if you’re sitting in a jail cell, it’s hard to get access to a computer.” Innocence Canada, a Canadian non-profit dedicated to identifying and preventing cases of wrongful conviction, says miscarriages of justice often leave wounds no one can heal. Can the system be modified to prevent cases of wrongful conviction?"

In Part Five of ‘Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted,’ a special series from the Jon McComb show on 980 CKNW, find out whether changes to our justice system are necessary to prevent instances of wrongful convictions.


The entire story can be read at:
https://globalnews.ca/news/5222475/canadas-wrongfully-convicted-achieving-justice/

PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/charlessmith. Information on "The Charles Smith Blog Award"- and its nomination process - can be found at: http://smithforensic.blogspot.com/2011/05/charles-smith-blog-award-nominations.html Please send any comments or information on other cases and issues of interest to the readers of this blog to: hlevy15@gmail.com.  Harold Levy: Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog.





Posted by Harold Levy at Tuesday, May 07, 2019
Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to FacebookShare to Pinterest
Newer Post Older Post Home

Blog Nation Badge

Crime Blogs

Followers

The Charles smith blog

Blog Directory - Blogged

Blog Archive

  • ►  2025 (407)
    • ►  June (66)
    • ►  May (89)
    • ►  April (59)
    • ►  March (64)
    • ►  February (64)
    • ►  January (65)
  • ►  2024 (743)
    • ►  December (60)
    • ►  November (61)
    • ►  October (73)
    • ►  September (63)
    • ►  August (55)
    • ►  July (62)
    • ►  June (78)
    • ►  May (57)
    • ►  April (62)
    • ►  March (66)
    • ►  February (46)
    • ►  January (60)
  • ►  2023 (732)
    • ►  December (68)
    • ►  November (59)
    • ►  October (58)
    • ►  September (67)
    • ►  August (72)
    • ►  July (62)
    • ►  June (70)
    • ►  May (66)
    • ►  April (54)
    • ►  March (58)
    • ►  February (52)
    • ►  January (46)
  • ►  2022 (679)
    • ►  December (73)
    • ►  November (44)
    • ►  October (33)
    • ►  September (38)
    • ►  August (53)
    • ►  July (70)
    • ►  June (51)
    • ►  May (66)
    • ►  April (83)
    • ►  March (60)
    • ►  February (47)
    • ►  January (61)
  • ►  2021 (825)
    • ►  December (77)
    • ►  November (83)
    • ►  October (81)
    • ►  September (77)
    • ►  August (70)
    • ►  July (84)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (71)
    • ►  April (61)
    • ►  March (63)
    • ►  February (43)
    • ►  January (46)
  • ►  2020 (612)
    • ►  December (31)
    • ►  November (32)
    • ►  October (36)
    • ►  September (34)
    • ►  August (41)
    • ►  July (52)
    • ►  June (55)
    • ►  May (50)
    • ►  April (59)
    • ►  March (69)
    • ►  February (83)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ▼  2019 (520)
    • ►  December (53)
    • ►  November (56)
    • ►  October (43)
    • ►  September (47)
    • ►  August (39)
    • ►  July (25)
    • ►  June (46)
    • ▼  May (49)
      • Bulletin: Criminalizing Reproduction: Louisiana go...
      • Bulletin: False Confessions: The Central Park Five...
      • Facial recognition technology: Canada: Significant...
      • Technology Series: (Part fifteen): A visit to Ecu...
      • Technology Series: (Part Fourteen) : Bulletin: Maj...
      • Central Park Five Jogger Case: Mini-series to de...
      • Technology Series Thirteen: Artifical Intelligenc...
      • Charles Ray Finch: North Carolina: Extraordinary ...
      • Technology Series: (Part Twelve): Artificial inte...
      • Criminalizing Reproduction: President's poisonous ...
      • Criminalizing Reproduction: (Attacks on Science, M...
      • Technology Series: (Part Eleven): Extremely impor...
      • Technical Series (Part Ten): Bulletin: "Amazon hea...
      • Technology Series (Part Nine): Global News report...
      • Arson 'Science': Cameron Todd Willingham: Stuart ...
      • Technology series: (Part Eight): Algorithms: Ethic...
      • Criminalizing Reproduction: (Attacks on Science, M...
      • Technology Series: (Part Seven): Software privacy ...
      • Technology Series: (Part Six): Algorithms: (Acco...
      • Technology Series: (Part Five): 'One Month, 500,0...
      • Bulletin: (Criminalizing reproduction): "The Misso...
      • Chris Tapp: Idaho: Major Development: (False conf...
      • Radley Balko: Faulty Crime scene Investigation: Th...
      • Technology Series: (Part Four) Can Predictive Po...
      • Technology Series (Part Three): Major Development:...
      • Technology Series. (Part two): Is 'Gangs Matrix,' ...
      • BULLETIN: Criminalizing Reproduction: (Attacks on ...
      • Criminalizing reproduction: Georgia: ((Attacks on ...
      • Technology Series (Part One): Use of futuristic t...
      • Forensics Reform Series 3: Eminent criminal justic...
      • Andrew Krivak: New York: False Confession Case: M...
      • Forensics Reform Series: Part Two: U.K "Forensic s...
      • Forensics Reform Series: Part One: USA: Bite-mark...
      • Global News: Wrongful Convictions Series. (Part fi...
      • Criminalizing reproduction: Alabama close to passi...
      • Criminalizing reproduction: "Georgia governor sign...
      • Sedley Alley: Tennessee: A case that cried out for...
      • Kathleen Folbigg: Australia: A most enlightening a...
      • Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted: Global News Series...
      • Arkansas: Belynda Goff: Reporter Mike Masterson c...
      • Mark Lundy: New Zealand: Major (Welcome) Developm...
      • Kyle Unger: Manitoba: Flawed hair analysis: Major...
      • Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted: (Part three of five...
      • Henry Keogh: South Australia: Major Development: H...
      • Christopher Abernathy: Illinois: False confession ...
      • Canada’s Wrongfully Convicted: (Part two of five ...
      • Mark Lundy: New Zealand..."Lundy a victim of 'junk...
      • Charle Erickson: Missouri: (False confession serie...
      • Charles Erickson: Missouri: False confession serie...
    • ►  April (40)
    • ►  March (45)
    • ►  February (37)
    • ►  January (40)
  • ►  2018 (561)
    • ►  December (39)
    • ►  November (44)
    • ►  October (7)
    • ►  September (32)
    • ►  August (55)
    • ►  July (53)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (60)
    • ►  April (42)
    • ►  March (44)
    • ►  February (54)
    • ►  January (62)
  • ►  2017 (621)
    • ►  December (42)
    • ►  November (39)
    • ►  October (79)
    • ►  September (48)
    • ►  August (56)
    • ►  July (39)
    • ►  June (63)
    • ►  May (47)
    • ►  April (76)
    • ►  March (65)
    • ►  February (5)
    • ►  January (62)
  • ►  2016 (1013)
    • ►  December (82)
    • ►  November (106)
    • ►  October (105)
    • ►  September (99)
    • ►  August (90)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (42)
    • ►  May (93)
    • ►  April (91)
    • ►  March (80)
    • ►  February (72)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ►  2015 (939)
    • ►  December (70)
    • ►  November (76)
    • ►  October (92)
    • ►  September (92)
    • ►  August (57)
    • ►  July (90)
    • ►  June (87)
    • ►  May (76)
    • ►  April (114)
    • ►  March (54)
    • ►  February (84)
    • ►  January (47)
  • ►  2014 (597)
    • ►  December (40)
    • ►  October (49)
    • ►  September (47)
    • ►  August (50)
    • ►  July (3)
    • ►  June (61)
    • ►  May (70)
    • ►  April (64)
    • ►  March (76)
    • ►  February (73)
    • ►  January (64)
  • ►  2013 (661)
    • ►  December (42)
    • ►  November (61)
    • ►  October (99)
    • ►  September (83)
    • ►  August (15)
    • ►  July (33)
    • ►  June (43)
    • ►  May (61)
    • ►  April (52)
    • ►  March (46)
    • ►  February (56)
    • ►  January (70)
  • ►  2012 (619)
    • ►  December (55)
    • ►  November (23)
    • ►  October (19)
    • ►  September (58)
    • ►  August (71)
    • ►  July (73)
    • ►  June (69)
    • ►  May (34)
    • ►  April (68)
    • ►  March (51)
    • ►  February (48)
    • ►  January (50)
  • ►  2011 (830)
    • ►  December (59)
    • ►  November (58)
    • ►  October (65)
    • ►  September (86)
    • ►  August (54)
    • ►  July (78)
    • ►  June (79)
    • ►  May (68)
    • ►  April (84)
    • ►  March (86)
    • ►  February (47)
    • ►  January (66)
  • ►  2010 (764)
    • ►  December (62)
    • ►  November (8)
    • ►  October (105)
    • ►  September (63)
    • ►  August (83)
    • ►  July (83)
    • ►  June (71)
    • ►  May (65)
    • ►  April (57)
    • ►  March (87)
    • ►  February (49)
    • ►  January (31)
  • ►  2009 (465)
    • ►  December (55)
    • ►  November (28)
    • ►  September (53)
    • ►  August (49)
    • ►  July (32)
    • ►  June (34)
    • ►  May (56)
    • ►  April (34)
    • ►  March (42)
    • ►  February (43)
    • ►  January (39)
  • ►  2008 (370)
    • ►  December (47)
    • ►  November (21)
    • ►  October (49)
    • ►  September (36)
    • ►  August (1)
    • ►  June (15)
    • ►  May (41)
    • ►  April (54)
    • ►  March (35)
    • ►  February (33)
    • ►  January (38)
  • ►  2007 (103)
    • ►  December (20)
    • ►  November (48)
    • ►  October (31)
    • ►  September (4)

About Me

My photo
Harold Levy
Two Blogs Now: The Charles Smith Blog; The Selfless Warriors Blog: I created the Charles Smith Blog in 2007 after I retired from The Toronto Star to permit me to keep digging into the story of the flawed pathologist and the harm he had done to so many innocent parents and caregivers, and to Ontario’s criminal justice system. Since then it has taken new directions, including examinations of other flawed pathologists, flawed pathology, and flawed science and technology which has marred the quality of justice in courtrooms around the world. On International Wrongful Conviction Day in 2024, I was thrilled to have the Blog recognized by Innocence Canada, when I was presented with the, "Rubin Hurricane Carter Champion of Justice Award." The heart of the Blog is my approach to following cases which raise issues in all of these areas - especially those involving the death penalty. I have dedicated 'The Selfless Warrior Blog’ (soon to appear) to those exceptional individuals who have been ripped out of their ordinary lives by their inability to stand by in the face of a glaring miscarriage of justice. They are my ’Selfless Warriors.’ Enjoy!
View my complete profile
 

Search This Blog

https://forensicresources.org/

  • CSI DDS | Forensic Science Testimony. CSI bad science issues and their contribution to wrongful convictions.
    Forensics: 80 years after his death, North Dakota World War II serviceman’s remains identified
    2 days ago
  • The Marshall Project
    How ‘Coercive Control’ Is Expanding Domestic Abuse Laws in Several States
    2 days ago
  • Wrongful Convictions Report
    Lucky girl, that Brittany
    2 days ago
  • Forensic Resources
    Expert assistance in toxicology and pharmacology available starting July 1, 2025 through Expert Services Project
    4 days ago
  • Pursue Democracy
    It’s malice not cowardice
    6 days ago
  • Gamso - For the Defense
    Until They Are Dead
    6 days ago
  • Comments on: In a Louisiana Parish, Hundreds of Cases May Be Tainted By Sheriff’s Office Misconduct
    A 68-year-old Grandfather Died in ICE’s Custody. His Family Seeks Answers.
    2 weeks ago
  • In the news by Karen Franklin PhD
    Adolescence, interrogated
    2 months ago
  • Crime & Justice Research Alliance
    Program That Aims to Reduce Cyclical, Retaliatory Gun Violence Saw Shootings Decline After Prevention Program in Lansing, MI
    3 months ago
  • Grits for Breakfast
    Grits publishes "Tulia" zine for 25th anniversary: Preorder now!
    8 months ago
  • Wrongful Conviction News
    Life after a wrongful conviction: Meet Charles Jackson
    2 years ago
  • MIP
    2022 Annual Report
    2 years ago
  • Stop Wrongful Convictions
    Truth About The Innoculations – Dr. Chetty
    3 years ago
  • Wrongly Convicted Group Website
    Could Conner Have Washed Ashore?
    4 years ago
  • Wrongful Convictions Blog
    Ohio Chief Justice Convenes Wrongful Conviction Task Force
    5 years ago
  • Forensic Science in North Carolina
    Forensic Toxicology Online Symposium
    6 years ago
  • Little Rascals Day Care Case
    Death noted: Former publisher of Edenton paper
    6 years ago
  • Forensic Pathology Forum
    My Father Killed Himself — Advice from a Physician and Suicide Survivor.
    6 years ago
  • Innocence Project of Florida
    Exoneration Anniversary: Wilton Dedge
    6 years ago
  • The Watch
    Afternoon links: Conservatives and criminal-justice reform
    6 years ago
  • Comments for Fault Lines
    Comment on Thank You, and Farewell by Brian Cowles
    7 years ago
  • View-from-Wilmington
    A new book on forensic science and the law
    8 years ago
  • Megrahi: You are my Jury
    Sunday Times letter highlights errors in Kenny MacAskill’s book
    8 years ago
  • Justiceforaarushitalwar.com
    CBI USES ‘TYPOGRAPHICAL ERROR’ TO SAVE FACE !!
    9 years ago
  • Innocence Matters: The Innocent should not be in prison
    John Klene's Innocence Matters
    12 years ago
  • Todd Willingham was Executed, but His Story Gets a New Life | The Arson Research Project
    March 25 2013
    12 years ago
  • On SBS
    New Research Questions Classic Model of Shaken Baby Syndrome
    13 years ago
  • Welcome to the Justice 4 Simon website
  • The Crime Report – Criminal Justice News, Statistics & Resources
  • The Wrongful Conviction of Jason Payne / Home
  • Susan Neill-Fraser is Innocent | Facebook
  • The Innocence Project - Home
  • Home
  • The Exoneration Initiative
  • Simple Justice
  • Comments on: MAIN
  • Petition | Free Pam Jacobazzi | Change.org
  • Envista Forensic Engineering Services and Forensic Consultants
  • innocent.org.uk
  • The Crime Report – Criminal Justice News, Statistics & Resources
  • The Innocence Project
  • The Marshall Project
  • Inquiry into Pediatric Forensic Pathology in Ontario - Home Page
  • Jeffrey Havard
  • Medill Innocence Project
  • Home
  • AIDWYC: The Association In Defence of the Wrongly Convicted
  • The case of Hank Skinner
  • Free Rodney Lincoln - Free an innocent man from a wrongful conviction in St. Louis, Missouri
  • McElroy Law
  • NZPIP - The Home of the New Zealand Public Interest Project. Working in the interests of justice and the public good.

http://www.personal.psu.edu/dhk3/blogs/DoubleHelixLaw/

  • The Marshall Project
    How ‘Coercive Control’ Is Expanding Domestic Abuse Laws in Several States
    2 days ago
  • Forensic Resources
    Expert assistance in toxicology and pharmacology available starting July 1, 2025 through Expert Services Project
    4 days ago
  • Pursue Democracy
    It’s malice not cowardice
    6 days ago
  • Comments on: In a Louisiana Parish, Hundreds of Cases May Be Tainted By Sheriff’s Office Misconduct
    A 68-year-old Grandfather Died in ICE’s Custody. His Family Seeks Answers.
    2 weeks ago
  • Innocence Project
    Perry Lott is Exonerated After 35 Years of Wrongful Conviction in Ada, Oklahoma
    1 year ago
  • Wrongly Convicted Group Website
    Could Conner Have Washed Ashore?
    4 years ago
  • On SBS
    New Research Questions Classic Model of Shaken Baby Syndrome
    13 years ago
  • BEtter Consulting – Legal Services
  • Free Clayton Allison