COMMENTARY: "How a Canadian professor’s life became a horror show," by Mohamed Fahmy, published by The Toronto Star on May 23, 2017. (Mohamed Fahmy is an award-winning journalist and war correspondent. He is the author of The Marriott Cell: An Epic Journey from Cairo’s Scorpion Prison to Freedom.)
SUB-HEADING: "French election results renew hope justice will finally come to Hassan Diab."
GIST: This story has been compared to a B-movie. Canadian-Lebanese
professor Hassan Diab is left in awe when a French journalist
approaches him in 2007 at the University of Ottawa to inform him he is
under investigation in relation to a bombing that killed four people
near the Copernic St. synagogue in Paris close to three decades ago. Thirteen months later the RCMP arrests Diab at the request of the French police, who consider him the suspect. The
suspenseful movie trailer begins with quick flashes of Diab’s life
spiralling out of control as the extradition court battle intensifies on
Canadian soil. Journalists film Diab and dozens of his supporters
holding signs protesting his innocence. The
flimsy case against Diab is built on German “secret unsourced
intelligence” handed to the French. Authorities blamed the Palestinian
Front for the Liberation of Palestine for the bombing. The militant
group had claimed responsibility for a string of bombings,
assassinations, and hijacking of airplanes in the late 1960s and 1970s. German
intelligence reports submitted to court that I read indicate “five
Palestinians” known to the investigators as members of the PFLP could
have been behind the attack. Rania Tfaily,
Diab’s wife confirmed to me that he was not born in Palestine and had no
Palestinian origins. More shockingly, the intelligence names the
suspect as “Hassan El Diab” not “Diab” — a big difference that could be
translated into a case of mistaken identity. At
this point of the drama we get a view of the real bomber as he fills in
the registration card at the Celtic Hotel in Paris and checks in under
the alias of Alexander Panadriyu, a Cypriot citizen. Four
handwriting experts have declared Diab’s handwriting does not match the
writing of the bomber on the card. Several French experts insist his
handwriting matches five words written by the suspect — a conclusion
widely critiqued. The political thriller
takes a new turn when the palm and fingerprints on the hotel
registration card and in the car that transported the explosives do not
match Diab’s prints taken by the RCMP. Case
documents reveal the hotel receptionist and porter described the bomber
as a man in his mid-40s. Diab was 26 at the time. Not a single hotel
employee was able to identify Diab when the French police showed them
his photo. Nevertheless, the unprecedented
two-year extradition hearing ended in catastrophe. Diab was committed
to extradition in June 2011. He was flown to Paris in 2014 where he has
been languishing in a tiny cell for 22-hours day after he lost his
appeal to an embarrassing Canadian court order. To
the naked eye this case would not have resulted in a conviction in a
fair Canadian criminal court. Experts believe the 1999 Extradition Act
is a black hole in the Canadian legal system that should be re-examined. Unfortunately,
this is not a film we can stop or fast forward as we please. It’s a
painful reality haunting Diab and his family every day......The good news is that French
investigating judges ordered his release six times in the past year. One
judge even confirmed there was “consistent evidence” Diab was a student
in Lebanon during the time of the bombing in 1980."
The entire story can be found at:
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/c
Harold Levy: Publisher; The Charles Smith Blog;