STORY: "After spending 32 years in prison for arson, Lowell man will remain free, SJC rules," by reporter Milton J. Valencia, published by The Boston Globe on May 11, 2017.
GIST: "Victor Rosario,
59, was released from state prison in 2014 after Superior Court Judge
Kathe M. Tuttman vacated his 1983 conviction for arson and eight murders
and ordered a new trial, citing advances in fire investigation
techniques and questions about Rosario’s confessions to the crime. The
state Supreme Judicial Court upheld that decision, agreeing Thursday
that Rosario was convicted on questionable evidence. “This case . . . presents a situation in which a confluence of
factors combined to create a substantial risk of a miscarriage of
justice,” Justice Kimberly S. Budd wrote for the court.
Middlesex District Attorney Marian Ryan will now have to decide whether to hold a new trial for Rosario, a former drug addict who says he found a new life in and out of prison as an ordained minister. Ryan’s office said Thursday that it is still reviewing the court’s decision to determine the next appropriate steps. Rosario said in an interview Thursday that he has been overcome by emotions, which have been building up while he awaited the court’s decision — a decision that could have forced him to return to prison. Rosario was sentenced to life in prison for the fatal 1982 fire in Lowell. He confessed to the arson after a lengthy police interrogation, signing a statement saying he and two accomplices threw Molotov cocktails at the triple-decker. Investigators had questioned Rosario after he admitted to being in the area, and told them that he broke a window in a failed rescue attempt. Rosario claimed before the trial that his confession had been involuntary and that he suffered from psychosis at the time. That argument was not successful. His initial appeal was rejected. In the most recent appeal, however, new mental health experts testified that Rosario was suffering from “delirium tremens” caused by alcohol withdrawal, which would have affected his state of mind and mental capacity at the time. He had been drinking heavily just before the fire and was experiencing withdrawal at the time of the confession. The new diagnosis raised questions as to whether his confession was voluntary. Defense attorneys also challenged the initial determination that the fire was arson and likely caused by a Molotov cocktail. Advances in arson science have cast doubt on some of the investigatory methods used at the time to determine burn patterns. In her decision two years ago, Tuttman found that the new diagnosis of delirium tremens, combined with the advances in forensic science, raised doubt about the confession. She freed him from prison. The Supreme Judicial Court agreed that a “confluence” of factors tainted the conviction. “These factors taken together could have influenced the jury’s verdict,” Budd wrote for the court."
The entire story can be found at:
Middlesex District Attorney Marian Ryan will now have to decide whether to hold a new trial for Rosario, a former drug addict who says he found a new life in and out of prison as an ordained minister. Ryan’s office said Thursday that it is still reviewing the court’s decision to determine the next appropriate steps. Rosario said in an interview Thursday that he has been overcome by emotions, which have been building up while he awaited the court’s decision — a decision that could have forced him to return to prison. Rosario was sentenced to life in prison for the fatal 1982 fire in Lowell. He confessed to the arson after a lengthy police interrogation, signing a statement saying he and two accomplices threw Molotov cocktails at the triple-decker. Investigators had questioned Rosario after he admitted to being in the area, and told them that he broke a window in a failed rescue attempt. Rosario claimed before the trial that his confession had been involuntary and that he suffered from psychosis at the time. That argument was not successful. His initial appeal was rejected. In the most recent appeal, however, new mental health experts testified that Rosario was suffering from “delirium tremens” caused by alcohol withdrawal, which would have affected his state of mind and mental capacity at the time. He had been drinking heavily just before the fire and was experiencing withdrawal at the time of the confession. The new diagnosis raised questions as to whether his confession was voluntary. Defense attorneys also challenged the initial determination that the fire was arson and likely caused by a Molotov cocktail. Advances in arson science have cast doubt on some of the investigatory methods used at the time to determine burn patterns. In her decision two years ago, Tuttman found that the new diagnosis of delirium tremens, combined with the advances in forensic science, raised doubt about the confession. She freed him from prison. The Supreme Judicial Court agreed that a “confluence” of factors tainted the conviction. “These factors taken together could have influenced the jury’s verdict,” Budd wrote for the court."
The entire story can be found at:
PUBLISHER'S NOTE: I am monitoring this case/issue. Keep your eye on the Charles Smith Blog for reports on developments. The Toronto Star, my previous employer for more than twenty incredible years, has put considerable effort into exposing the harm caused by Dr. Charles Smith and his protectors - and into pushing for reform of Ontario's forensic pediatric pathology system. The Star has a "topic" section which focuses on recent stories related to Dr. Charles Smith. It can be found at: http://www.thestar.com/topic/c
