"A
prominent, but increasingly controversial child-abuse expert believes
that a 3-month-old Danvers baby was shaken by an angry father hard
enough to cause a brain bleed and other substantial injuries. But
a defense expert testified on Monday that Dr. Alice Newton overlooked
other possible causes of the infant’s subdural hematoma, retinal
bleeding and head swelling, including what he believes is a hereditary
condition.
Dr.
Joseph Scheller, a Baltimore pediatric neurologist hired by Daniel
Green’s lawyer, said he believes the infant’s brain bleed was caused by
pressure from excess spinal fluid that collected in the area between the
brain and the skull, a condition called benign extra-axial fluid
collection. Green,
30, is on trial in Lawrence Superior Court, charged with assault and
battery on a child causing substantial bodily injury, and permitting
substantial bodily injury to a child. ........But
Collins, the defense lawyer, sought to discredit Newton, whose work has
come under increasing public scrutiny in several high-profile cases,
including that of Aisling McCarthy, the Irish nanny accused of killing a
1-year-old child in her care, and the controversial Justina Pelletier
case, in which Newton and her colleagues suspected that Pelletier’s
parents were committing “medical child abuse.”
Collins
specifically asked Newton about the case of Geoffrey Wilson, a Malden
man charged with killing his 6-month-old son. Wilson’s lawyers hired an
expert who discovered last year that the child had inherited a rare
blood vessel disorder present in both his mother and grandmother. “That’s what the newspapers reported,” Newton responded. “Nonetheless, the case was dismissed,” Collins said, prompting an objection by Hopwood. The
trial had been expected to conclude this week, but Hopwood was called
away to deal with a family emergency. Because Scheller, who has yet to
be cross-examined, was due to return to Baltimore Monday evening, and is
not available again this week, the conclusion of the trial was
postponed until July 30."
http://www.salemnews.com/news/local_news/defense-questions-shaken-baby-claim/article_e83af960-697d-512d-b89b-531c31dc14b8.html