"The
Lake County coroner's office — citing new evidence in the case of a
toddler whose death resulted in the controversial murder conviction of a
suburban day care worker — has reclassified the child's cause of death
from homicide to "undetermined." Coroner Thomas Rudd, who has
advocated in the defense of the day care worker, Melissa Calusinski,
announced Wednesday that after reviewing the case, "It is impossible to
conclude that the final head injury was intentionally inflicted." Calusinski,
28, who lived in Carpentersville, is serving a 31-year sentence for a
first-degree murder conviction after authorities argued at her trial
that she slammed the 16-month-old boy, Benjamin Kingan, to the ground
while working at Minee Subee day care center in Lincolnshire. "Most
important was the fact that the original injury to the head was not an
acute injury, but instead a severe chronic injury," Rudd stated in a
news release. Calusinski's
lawyers recently filed a court petition that seeks to get her a new
trial, saying that X-rays reveal that medical experts for the state
inaccurately concluded that the child suffered an acute injury the day
of his death in 2009. "New evidence has now come forward," stated
Rudd, who said he consulted with an independent pathologist. "On June 10, 2015, X-rays of the decedent were discovered on file in
the Coroner's Office that according to the defense attorneys were not
shared or provided to them prior to or during the trial.".........Calusinski's
lawyers have long said that she was coerced into confessing during a
10-hour interrogation that relied on faulty information from forensic
pathologist Eupil Choi, who performed the autopsy. Choi later signed a
statement in which he admitted that he "missed that (Ben) had suffered
an old injury" that predated the day of his death, the petition states.........Kathleen Zellner, Calusinski's lawyer, said she will include
in the post-conviction petition Rudd's finding that cause of death was
"undetermined." "It
is very, very unusual for a coroner to change the cause of death
finding, but Dr. Rudd's conclusions are consistent with the independent
investigation that he conducted," she said Wednesday. "I am not
going to predict an outcome, but I have not found a case where the
pathologist who did the autopsy admitted he made a mistake and told the
jury incorrect information," Zellner said. "This case is unique in case
law across the country." In May, Rudd called for the state's
attorney to review the case on the national television show, "48 Hours,"
which featured Calusinski's case in an episode called "Blaming
Melissa."
http://www.chicagotribune.com/suburbs/lake-county-news-sun/news/ct-day-care-death-ruling-change-met-20150708-story.html