"Entering a court can be daunting for just about anyone, but
carries more confusion and risk for those with an
intellectual disability. Defendants with intellectual disabilities can be at risk of
false imprisonment, longer sentences and lack of access to
parole, largely because of communication difficulties. It is hoped New Zealand Law Foundation-funded research
carried out in Dunedin at the Donald Beasley Institute will
lead to improvements in how the court system caters for
defendants with intellectual disabilities. Institute director Brigit Mirfin-Veitch said the research
report was being used as a teaching tool for judges and
lawyers. The quashing of Teina Pora's rape and murder convictions this
year made the work topical. Mr Pora's then-undiagnosed foetal alcohol spectrum disorder
is considered a factor in his false confession to the 1992
crime. The focus of the study was defendants, but the two-year
project included interviews with intellectually disabled
witnesses and victims, as well as with lawyers and judges. Lack of funding for intellectual disability research meant
few evidence-based resources and detailed statistics had been
produced. Restrictions on legal aid funding since 2009 have exacerbated
difficulties for those with intellectual disabilities, report
co-author and University of Otago law faculty dean Prof Mark
Henaghan says. The legal aid changes restricted the choice of lawyer. This was problematic, because not every lawyer was suited to
dealing with clients with intellectual disabilities.........Mr Pora was a ''classic example'' of a defendant failed by
the system because of communication problems.
''Systems just don't seem to understand how important it is
to have good communication.'' ''In that one moment, you can lose your opportunity to be
fully understood.'' Jail was a harsher punishment for the intellectually disabled
than for other defendants, because of the toughness of the
environment. This weighed heavily on judges, who were aware of the problem
and wanted more research and resources, Prof Henaghan said. ''If you're a judge you'd feel awful sentencing someone for
something they may not have done, or sentencing them
inappropriately when they've got a disability that you didn't
quite understand,'' Prof Henaghan said. Founded in 1984, the Donald Beasley Institute is New
Zealand's only independent institute devoted to researching
intellectual disability."
http://www.odt.co.nz/news/dunedin/347248/disabled-face-risks-courts